|
Aotearoa39261 Posts
I'm rather out of "mafia" at the moment - celebrating my two year anniversary this weekend ^^ but the analysis you're doing looks really good.
EvilMonkey is Mr Blonde, check out the second night "swooped down" - seeing as we intially pinned this trait to Shadowdrgn as the dragon could swoop - the monkey swooping fits perfectly. Mr Blonde perfectly fits EvilMonkey's name (just check the clues yourself, i know you're capable ^^) and we can safely assume thats who he is.
As a side note for everyone, Chuiu seems to love pinning mafia to names - and that makes our lives quite easy. So far we've got evilmonkey and queasy on their name connections. This should be our first port of call when analysing clues in the future (imo), if you can pin clues to a name then bring it up and we just need to check if it fits (like in the L situation  !) and then we can proceed to act on it
|
On April 13 2008 12:47 Plexa wrote:I'm rather out of "mafia" at the moment - celebrating my two year anniversary this weekend ^^ but the analysis you're doing looks really good. EvilMonkey is Mr Blonde, check out the second night "swooped down" - seeing as we intially pinned this trait to Shadowdrgn as the dragon could swoop - the monkey swooping fits perfectly. Mr Blonde perfectly fits EvilMonkey's name (just check the clues yourself, i know you're capable ^^) and we can safely assume thats who he is. As a side note for everyone, Chuiu seems to love pinning mafia to names - and that makes our lives quite easy. So far we've got evilmonkey and queasy on their name connections. This should be our first port of call when analysing clues in the future (imo), if you can pin clues to a name then bring it up and we just need to check if it fits (like in the L situation !) and then we can proceed to act on it
Yay, so he was Mr.Blonde?
You should do another clue interpretations soon after the next day post when you can.
Happy anniversary :D
|
On April 13 2008 12:42 0cz3c wrote:
Pink, when you seached, did you search for Spoinka and got Spoink (a pokemon, ^_^), or did you search for Spoink (and cut off the 'a'.).
There might be a ton of Pokemon references that Chuiu might have made that have been overlooked, but this would only be the case if you searched for Spoinka.
(I just seached "Spoinka" in Google, and the first two pages only showed usernames with Spoinka).
yeah i searched for spoinka in the free encyclopedia and found that little pokemon without legs :p
btw : that encyclopedia is what I use to find words i dont understand (for all my research : except artanis , can't put him on a caracter yet)
|
On April 13 2008 12:54 HeRoS)Pink wrote:Show nested quote +On April 13 2008 12:42 0cz3c wrote:
Pink, when you seached, did you search for Spoinka and got Spoink (a pokemon, ^_^), or did you search for Spoink (and cut off the 'a'.).
There might be a ton of Pokemon references that Chuiu might have made that have been overlooked, but this would only be the case if you searched for Spoinka.
(I just seached "Spoinka" in Google, and the first two pages only showed usernames with Spoinka). yeah i searched for spoinka in the free encyclopedia and found that little pokemon without legs :p btw : that encyclopedia is what I use to find words i dont understand (for all my research : except artanis , can't put him on a caracter yet)
Artanis is a protoss hero in the campaign... don't know any other reasons.
|
Aotearoa39261 Posts
I feel that the spoinka clue is a little too streched, but not enough to disregard it entirely - let me do a quick check of names
|
|
|
On April 13 2008 12:56 Camlito wrote:Show nested quote +On April 13 2008 12:54 HeRoS)Pink wrote:On April 13 2008 12:42 0cz3c wrote:
Pink, when you seached, did you search for Spoinka and got Spoink (a pokemon, ^_^), or did you search for Spoink (and cut off the 'a'.).
There might be a ton of Pokemon references that Chuiu might have made that have been overlooked, but this would only be the case if you searched for Spoinka.
(I just seached "Spoinka" in Google, and the first two pages only showed usernames with Spoinka). yeah i searched for spoinka in the free encyclopedia and found that little pokemon without legs :p btw : that encyclopedia is what I use to find words i dont understand (for all my research : except artanis , can't put him on a caracter yet) Artanis is a protoss hero in the campaign... don't know any other reasons.
HIgh ranked leader + a praetor
EDIT : I remember fusion speaking about army and accusing generalstan
praetor : the commander of an army
|
On April 13 2008 13:00 Plexa wrote:
I feel that the spoinka clue is a little too streched, but not enough to disregard it entirely - let me do a quick check of names
Well im just throwing stuff that could help if i get killed
|
On April 13 2008 11:25 Camlito wrote:
[3,31]Next door French_Toast was grabbing a midnight snack.
Do clues like this still work in this game? (this clue relates to midnightgladius).
we dont know.
There are two camps.
One says that all non mafia sentences are filler, and we should only look at clues and traits that are linked to specific mafia.
The other says that, looking at the last mafia game, clues are to be found even in "extra" sentences, and we should look for a repeat of clues, in the form of extraneous and out of place words, and not just at specific mafia behaviour.
|
Aotearoa39261 Posts
On April 13 2008 13:05 HeRoS)Pink wrote:Show nested quote +On April 13 2008 13:00 Plexa wrote:
I feel that the spoinka clue is a little too streched, but not enough to disregard it entirely - let me do a quick check of names Well im just throwing stuff that could help if i get killed And thats great 
I can't see any obvious name connections to Mr Red... however the name DamageControl stuck out at me =/ i don't know why
|
On April 13 2008 13:08 Plexa wrote:Show nested quote +On April 13 2008 13:05 HeRoS)Pink wrote:On April 13 2008 13:00 Plexa wrote:
I feel that the spoinka clue is a little too streched, but not enough to disregard it entirely - let me do a quick check of names Well im just throwing stuff that could help if i get killed And thats great I can't see any obvious name connections to Mr Red... however the name DamageControl stuck out at me =/ i don't know why
Rofl i was just about posting something about DamageControl Being
Black mamba
Reason : words such as Ease , Recover, stumbled all about controlling damage ( or not : stumbled)
|
Ease shows up a ton
I really think anything linked to that is solid
|
I feel that the spoinka clue is a little too streched Intentional pun? If so, 5/5.
For Mr Red, until we get more clues, there's only Dr.Dragoon due to falling = how dragoons deal damage in rpg games.
And sonuvbob's retarded chocobo picture + the red blood of his nazgul pierced friend.
Both seem pretty meh, but that's what I found while looking.
|
Aotearoa39261 Posts
On April 13 2008 13:08 fusionsdf wrote:Show nested quote +On April 13 2008 11:25 Camlito wrote:
[3,31]Next door French_Toast was grabbing a midnight snack.
Do clues like this still work in this game? (this clue relates to midnightgladius). we dont know. There are two camps. One says that all non mafia sentences are filler, and we should only look at clues and traits that are linked to specific mafia. The other says that, looking at the last mafia game, clues are to be found even in "extra" sentences, and we should look for a repeat of clues, in the form of extraneous and out of place words, and not just at specific mafia behaviour. And there is a third camp which suggests the two camps are not mutually inclusive
|
On April 13 2008 13:46 Plexa wrote:Show nested quote +On April 13 2008 13:08 fusionsdf wrote:On April 13 2008 11:25 Camlito wrote:
[3,31]Next door French_Toast was grabbing a midnight snack.
Do clues like this still work in this game? (this clue relates to midnightgladius). we dont know. There are two camps. One says that all non mafia sentences are filler, and we should only look at clues and traits that are linked to specific mafia. The other says that, looking at the last mafia game, clues are to be found even in "extra" sentences, and we should look for a repeat of clues, in the form of extraneous and out of place words, and not just at specific mafia behaviour. And there is a third camp which suggests the two camps are not mutually inclusive
And a fourth camp that says they are not mutually exclusive :D
|
Aotearoa39261 Posts
*doh* fail
scratch that third camp
|
On April 12 2008 23:00 MTF wrote:L led the way against Ghar, but it was a seemingly good clue. Eti307 supported him quite a bit and at the same time pointed the finger at ShadowDrgn. D.arkive also posted not too much later in support of L's finding, though this still does not prove L is guilty. Plexa needs to tell us who sent him + Show Spoiler [this message.] +Original Message:
hi!
i just read your latest post. i'd like to direct your attention towards ghar's signature, which you seem to have left out of your reasoning:
"All right, theyre on our left, theyre on our right, theyre in front of us, theyre behind us...they cant get away this time."
this is a quote by some reckless general whose troops are surrounded by enemies, but who still remains positive and not afraid of losing.
now when you connect this to mr. pink's traits...
Traits
- Seems to be well composed
- Not phased by death, (necessary change?)
- Able fighter
(- Potentially one of the four horsemen of the apocalypse)
... i think this fits the second and third trait quite well. the general isn't afraid of dying, even though outnumbered. and, as a professional soldier, he is a good fighter as well.
furthermore, as SoMuchBetter said, Ghar is currently inactive due to a martial arts appointment. i have no idea if Chuiu knew this and would use this as a hint, but Ghar being a fighter himself would fit Mr.Pink's third character trait perfectly.
and say what you will, but the picture of him holding the scalp of a chopped-off head fits just too well. . Whoever it was, they were dedicated to Ghar taking the fall. Looking into others...
That PM came from me. It appears you think that makes me mafia. It does not.
First, read again what I wrote and tell me what of that is complete made-up bullshit. With the knowledge we had at that point, I think it all made sense. I just wrote what I thought was the truth.
Second, had I wanted to start a bandwagon, I would've posted this in the thread instead of in a PM. I posted this privately because I wanted Plexa's opinion on my thoughts.
Third, you'll have to admint that there really was a lot of plausible evidence against Ghar (especially that picture), which made 30 people believe he was guilty. I was not the only one who thought he was mafia.
|
Germany2896 Posts
lol I voted for the innocent of the two, but not for the guilty one. I seem to have really good detective skills.
|
[QUOTE]On April 13 2008 18:25 MasterOfChaos wrote:
lol I voted for the innocent of the two, but not for the guilty one. I seem to have really good mafia skills
|
On April 13 2008 18:00 Scorch wrote:Show nested quote +On April 12 2008 23:00 MTF wrote:L led the way against Ghar, but it was a seemingly good clue. Eti307 supported him quite a bit and at the same time pointed the finger at ShadowDrgn. D.arkive also posted not too much later in support of L's finding, though this still does not prove L is guilty. Plexa needs to tell us who sent him + Show Spoiler [this message.] +Original Message:
hi!
i just read your latest post. i'd like to direct your attention towards ghar's signature, which you seem to have left out of your reasoning:
"All right, theyre on our left, theyre on our right, theyre in front of us, theyre behind us...they cant get away this time."
this is a quote by some reckless general whose troops are surrounded by enemies, but who still remains positive and not afraid of losing.
now when you connect this to mr. pink's traits...
Traits
- Seems to be well composed
- Not phased by death, (necessary change?)
- Able fighter
(- Potentially one of the four horsemen of the apocalypse)
... i think this fits the second and third trait quite well. the general isn't afraid of dying, even though outnumbered. and, as a professional soldier, he is a good fighter as well.
furthermore, as SoMuchBetter said, Ghar is currently inactive due to a martial arts appointment. i have no idea if Chuiu knew this and would use this as a hint, but Ghar being a fighter himself would fit Mr.Pink's third character trait perfectly.
and say what you will, but the picture of him holding the scalp of a chopped-off head fits just too well. . Whoever it was, they were dedicated to Ghar taking the fall. Looking into others... That PM came from me. It appears you think that makes me mafia. It does not. First, read again what I wrote and tell me what of that is complete made-up bullshit. With the knowledge we had at that point, I think it all made sense. I just wrote what I thought was the truth. Second, had I wanted to start a bandwagon, I would've posted this in the thread instead of in a PM. I posted this privately because I wanted Plexa's opinion on my thoughts. Third, you'll have to admint that there really was a lot of plausible evidence against Ghar (especially that picture), which made 30 people believe he was guilty. I was not the only one who thought he was mafia.
Nah, I don't automatically assume that you are Mafia because of the PM. It does, however, put you under more scrutiny. I know everyone believed Ghar was guilty and I mentioned that the clues did seem to add up, but I have to look more closely at those who seemed to push the most at the beginning and tried to allay doubts as to the persons guilt.
|
|
|
|
|
|
EPT
