|
On February 21 2008 06:51 Amber[LighT] wrote:Show nested quote +On February 21 2008 06:38 randombum wrote:
Mafia CANNOT BE TOWN, CHIUIU CHOSE TOWNIES. so amber your entire arguement is flawed. Can this be 100% verified by chuiu? I'm under the impression everyone is a 'towny' so wouldn't saying you're a bodyguard be an unfair advantage?
Bodyguard - Random towny(ies) will receive the role of bodyguard once the mayor and pardoner have been elected. The mayor alone will know who these people are. Random and townies. Meaning that Chuiu picks bodyguards randomly out of a pool of plain townies, so only townies without special roles can be randomly chosen as a body guard. Mafia don't count as townies, they pretend to be townies in the game, but by the rules they're never classified as townies.
Edit: ok I'm only assuming that bodyguards can't have any other towny roles, but I'm pretty sure everything else is fact.
Edit2: Ok technically mafia ARE townies during the day, but during night they're purely mafia and since bodyguards work only in the night it's not possible for a mafia to be bodyguard.
(also that wouldn't make logical sense in a "realistic" point of view, because then wouldn't a mafia bodyguard kill the mayor the first chance he gets?)
|
Ok then nevermind.
I withdraw my vote for Caller.
I have no vote this round.
|
On February 21 2008 06:27 Falcynn wrote:
I think that if FS says that caller is bodyguard, then we move on and try to go after lynching another possibility and see if caller gets gets hit by the mob tonight. If he doesn't die then we can decide if we want to lynch him next day, if he does get killed then that just means that we saved ourselves from wasting a day lynching a dead man. However I don't think that FS would lie, because if he's lieing and he is mafia then he just made a pretty stupid move, because when Caller does get lynched (I hope he doesn't get lynched tonight, but I feel he will get lynched eventually whether because of a vote or vigilante) and it turns out he's mafia then that would undoubtedly prove FS is mafia (because mafia can't be bodyguards so it'd mean that FS was defending a mafia this whole time), and since I don't believe FS would make such a stupid move I have to agree with Caller being a BG.
So for that reason I'll go ahead and Vote for Live2Win to get lynched I don't really have a strong feeling about this so I probably will change my vote eventually. However I'm just trying to offset the caller votes for now.
actually this makes more sense then then what i was trying to express lol
i'll go ahead here and
change my vote to Live2Win (from Caller)
|
infinity21
Canada6683 Posts
let's see if L2W is a mafia
I vote for Live2Win to be lynched
p.s. if you're not mafia, then I'm really sorry o_o;;
|
|
|
On February 21 2008 08:03 dinmsab wrote:
My vote is for Live2Win.
Random people who come in just to vote! Its people like you who are either mafia! or bad townies.
|
Although I would love not to get lynched right now, I think that people should at least explain their reasoning before doing something rash like voting arbitrarily.
I withdraw my vote from Amber[Light] and will abstain for now.
|
Valhalla18444 Posts
my vote goes to Tracil
you're either mafia or a moron, either way you're better off dead
|
On February 21 2008 08:23 FakeSteve[TPR] wrote:
my vote goes to Tracil
you're either mafia or a moron, either way you're better off dead
wtf, that's so suspicious!
|
Valhalla18444 Posts
i mean honestly you're suspicious of everyone who says anything at all
that means you're either mafia and its a front. or you're a complete idiot. either way, you aren't gonna do any useful pardoning
|
I really don't think Caller is mafioso, purely based on the fact that he accused ShaLLoW[baY] of being mafioso. Although if Caller is mafioso this will make me look really scummy =/.
I vote to lynch Mini Moose 2707. This guy is a Mafia player vet and he has discussed little to nothing. Either he doesn't care much for this particular game or he knows that if you're mafioso it is better to lay low.
|
Valhalla18444 Posts
it is better to lay low. its got to be with a moron like tracil on the prowl
everyone who says anything ever is mafia lynch them all!!!!!!!!!!
|
|
|
Given that I was suspicious of you for not saying anything, Steve, I find it highly suspicious that you're calling me out for being suspicious of people who talk. Likewise, given that I'm voting for someone explicitly because they *aren't* talking, I wonder if you're been paying attention... like... at all.
I don't really know where you've pulled this stuff from. And I've already said why actually pardoning people is a bad idea pretty much all the time. Maybe you'd like to tell me what circumstances it might be a good idea in, hmm?
|
Lynch NotSorry, seriously just look at his name, it just yells evil killer type guy. Seriously who wants a killer that feels bad afterwards!
|
Valhalla18444 Posts
On February 21 2008 08:37 Tracil wrote:
I find it highly suspicious that
you have said this to basically everybody
|
17017 Posts
On February 21 2008 08:03 dinmsab wrote:
My vote is for Live2Win.
GTFO.
And it's natural for people to be suspicious, so I don't see why Tracil being suspicious is any indication of guilt.
|
Answer my question. Cease ignoring my actual points. Oh, encouraging people to be silent is pretty retarded, please don't do that.
<->
When I talk in this game, it is, in fact, generally about who I find suspicious or would like to see lynched when it's not about how I think the game should be played. It should be no wonder that you see me accusing people and the like and almost nothing else. It's not like we're here to discuss cake.
|
Valhalla18444 Posts
On February 21 2008 08:51 Tracil wrote:
Answer my question. Cease ignoring my actual points. Oh, encouraging people to be silent is pretty retarded, please don't do that.
<->
When I talk in this game, it is, in fact, generally about who I find suspicious or would like to see lynched when it's not about how I think the game should be played. It should be no wonder that you see me accusing people and the like and almost nothing else. It's not like we're here to discuss cake.
you find everyone suspicious
you look at posts and then take what you need to call them mafia, but most of the people you're calling out have been innocent.
i dont even want to post anything because it'll be picked apart by you and i really don't feel like having another 20 post back-and-forth that you will eventually concede
|
I'm sorry I don't have psychic powers of scum detection and can only rely on what I see. I have been suspicious of many people, but that's natural in this game. I try to root out the *most* suspicious.
Speaking of picking things out, 'not wanting to post anything because he'll pick it apart' will do for now. That's a lame attitude to take. I would have expected more conviction from our mayor. Then again, saying nothing substantial seems to be his stock in trade. After all, it got him elected.
|
|
|
|
|
|
EPT
