[N][M]Noir Mini Mafia - Ch. 5

On August 01 2020 01:19 GlowingBear wrote:


/in

You don't get to be mafia in this game, alright?

On August 09 2020 12:46 HoldenGolden wrote:


Can you elaborate on how you feel Shockeyy seems to be forced tonally?

Out of curiosity, is trfel known for having spectacular entrances?

On August 09 2020 21:32 HoldenGolden wrote:

Unvote
Vote: lightingstrike



Do you got jeebies now? If so, care to explain it to the class?


Expect if this was mafiascum, it would be 2 weeks per day phase lol.

On August 09 2020 22:04 HoldenGolden wrote:
Oh It got cutted apparently.

Your conclusion is fine if it was actually committed to something. You have gone from "it looks forced? -> overhappy tone but I might be wrong".

The might part stands out to me as potentially scum motivated. It gives you the ability to return to the overhappy tone point assuming a you scum/shockeyy town situation. It was enough of a ping early on to switch.

On August 09 2020 22:50 Eywa- wrote:
HoldenGolden, I'm not familiar with the flavor, are you softing doc?

On August 09 2020 23:16 HoldenGolden wrote:
No I was only talking about shockey. I asked only about trfel because you inferred that he tends to have good openings.

I'll let it rest on the back burner for now though.

Eywa I'm disappointed. I'm softing godfather. No it's just Noir style lingo since the game is named after the genre.

That said, if you think I'm softing a PR role, why would you ask me directly lol?

On August 09 2020 23:26 Eywa- wrote:

You're town, unvote me.

On August 09 2020 23:42 Eywa- wrote:

This is a Mickey Mouse question, if I'm mafia I just role block him, no need to ask him.

On August 09 2020 23:42 Vivax wrote:
Yo I'm back from camping. Don't know if I have the energy to contribute much atm but we'll see.

On August 10 2020 00:19 Mr. Cheesecake wrote:


I once played a game where everyone was claiming town D1 and the mafia was the only one to claim he was the serial killer (nobody else claimed they were scum). I think this is because people have a difficult time lying, even when it is something as innocuous as pointless townclaims, so they play it off as trolling / sarcasm.

As long as you are claiming ##Vote: Trfel




obviously you don't think trfel is mafia here, but what do you actually think about the scum claim in general. How is this any different to what Fecal did?



Why exactly does this make him scum? I find the fact that he calls you town more interesting. Is this his "one read"? I guess but he sounds so sure.

On August 10 2020 00:41 Mr. Cheesecake wrote:


Do you seriously think that scum are going to bluehunt that openly in the thread? I don't think it is alignment indicative. I am more interested in his town read on you and holden's scumread on you, which seems to be the first point of real contention in this game.

On August 10 2020 01:07 Mr. Cheesecake wrote:
LS what do you think about the differing reads on you. One of them is mafia? Are they both town? Both scum? Help me out here. I think Holden is more likely scum over Eywa. Calls someone out for being flip-floppy and then says that is potentially scum motivated, which is entirely flip floppy in itself (it doesn't "commit to something", as he said). By his own logic, he is mafia. Town aren't sure about anything, much less on D1. Additionally, I got the opposite read so If he's town the read is pretty poor.

Regardless you should vote Trfel.