[N][M]Noir Mini Mafia - Ch. 5 - Page 7

Post a Reply

Prev 1 5 6 7 8 9 10 Next All

Fecalfeast

Canada11355 Posts

August 15 2020 21:47 GMT

#632

On August 16 2020 06:27 Eywa- wrote:

Show nested quote +

Is this how you play mafia? Lol

Why do we care if you'll take responsibility. If you're willing to take responsibility, you should be willing to go the other way, you first then LS right?

What is this logic? Can someone explain what's going on

Fecalfeast

Canada11355 Posts

August 15 2020 21:47 GMT

#634

I miss mr. cheesecake

Fecalfeast

Canada11355 Posts

August 15 2020 21:53 GMT

#640

sorry instead of playing mafia i was having this happen

Fecalfeast

Canada11355 Posts

August 15 2020 21:59 GMT

#643

I think i kill trfel over eywa here?

Trfel read a lot more defensive when you were accusing him daddyred as if he's more worries about how he appears than eywa has been imho

i'm playing fast and loose no filters rn but ill be here for deadline. I want a kill

Fecalfeast

Canada11355 Posts

August 15 2020 22:03 GMT

#646

On August 16 2020 07:02 Vivax wrote:

Show nested quote +

Trfel not really setting off alarm bells for me. He seems focused enough on a picture in his head, as mafia he posts enough but tends to not let it shine through that he has particular preferences.

This is a stupid leading question but why do I get scum vibes off every post you make this game?

Fecalfeast

Canada11355 Posts

August 15 2020 22:04 GMT

#647

Kinda interesting that everyone has kinda written off cheesecake as town, myself included lol

Fecalfeast

Canada11355 Posts

August 15 2020 22:05 GMT

#648

the only reason i'd lynch shockeyy is because he was the only player off the main wagon who isn't flipped town or cheesecake

Fecalfeast

Canada11355 Posts

August 15 2020 22:29 GMT

#653

On August 16 2020 07:23 Trfel wrote:
Didn't realize anyone actually played Starcraft here, haha. Fun times.

I'll try to post on ShoCkeyy in a bit. I think the reason I'm suspecting him is that the reasoning for him to scumread LightningStrike changed seemingly arbitrarily but I need to double check. It's been a few days since I looked at it.

I stand by lynching someone over no one, for the record. Even a town read for me. It may not give me any new information but it helps everyone else and that makes it worth it (compared to no lynch). Also there is always the chance I'm wrong. I messed up once before and no lynched instead of lynching a town read and it lost us the game, I don't intend to make that mistake again.

Fecalfeast, I don't care how I look, I just don't like being insulted. Sorry if I'm a bit sensitive to that, TL Mafia and life both haven't been very kind to me for a while.

Fair enough. Hard to look at the game and keep in mind the real life surrounding it.

Fecalfeast

Canada11355 Posts

August 15 2020 22:42 GMT

#656

Cheesecake has been Mia since 4 days ago

Fecalfeast

Canada11355 Posts

August 15 2020 22:55 GMT

#660

##unvote
##vote shockeyy

Fecalfeast

Canada11355 Posts

August 15 2020 22:55 GMT

#661

##unvote

Fecalfeast

Canada11355 Posts

August 15 2020 22:56 GMT

#662

IDK

Fecalfeast

Canada11355 Posts

August 15 2020 22:56 GMT

#663

WHO IS HERE HANDS UP

Fecalfeast

Canada11355 Posts

August 15 2020 22:58 GMT

#666

On August 16 2020 07:41 Dadred wrote:

Show nested quote +

So cheesecake isn't voting. And we have a lot of worthless votes.

Hrm

What have you discerned from this dammy wammy slammy?

Who is scum?

Fecalfeast

Canada11355 Posts

August 15 2020 22:58 GMT

#667

On August 16 2020 07:57 Trfel wrote:

Show nested quote +

Yeah, still suspicious. I feel like most people try to get a chance to evaluate the replacement first.

Unless you have a read on Dadred already, in which case I'm all ears?

actually schockeyy also voted damdred post replacement so you didn'teven look you just saw the votes and said it eh?

Fecalfeast

Canada11355 Posts

August 15 2020 22:59 GMT

#668

On August 15 2020 10:27 ShoCkeyy wrote:
Ohhh just saw LS post. Makes it even easier.

##unvote
##vote damdred

Fecalfeast

Canada11355 Posts

August 15 2020 23:00 GMT

#670

##vote trfel

ok

Fecalfeast

Canada11355 Posts

August 15 2020 23:04 GMT

#675

On August 16 2020 08:01 Trfel wrote:

Show nested quote +

Fair enough, I apologize and withdraw my suspicion. I can't seem to find what I saw a few days ago any more.

No idea what I'm doing. But maybe ShoCkeyy isn't mafia after all :/

Fecalfeast

Canada11355 Posts

August 15 2020 23:10 GMT

#677

trfel vote someone

Fecalfeast

Canada11355 Posts

August 15 2020 23:21 GMT

#681

On August 16 2020 08:11 Trfel wrote:

Show nested quote +

Unfortunately I'm not sure

Eywa- I thought was mafia, then I thought maybe he was town, now I'm really unsure. I'm interested why he suspects me so heavily, hopefully that will help me read him. He's also one of the players I need to re-evaluate.
Dadred I will give the benefit of the doubt for now.
ShoCkeyy maybe town? Maybe?
LightningStrike I also need to reread, I could see him being mafia though.
Mr. Cheesecake I think is town.
Vivax I kinda think is town, he's been around and pushing things that are important to him.
Fecalfeast I could see being mafia as well except he's been rather active. I need to take another look at him.

Basically Eywa-/LightningStrike/Fecalfeast for now, maybe Dadred later.

Why do you think cheesecake is town when they've been afk for 4 days? Have you ever elaborated on this?

You made a post that says he irks you but since he is active you'd rather not kill him.
+ Show Spoiler [quote] +

On August 11 2020 02:50 Trfel wrote:

Show nested quote +

On August 10 2020 13:09 Mr. Cheesecake wrote:

On August 10 2020 10:11 Trfel wrote:

On August 10 2020 01:44 Eywa- wrote:
I read another game from HoldenGolden and there are several striking differences. In the other game, he doesn't really try to question other people in the same post that he's breaking out a scum read (he does that here). Also, he developed his read in the other game a lot more, here he posted the vote and then stated the read, but only after being asked. I also found his last game to be a lot more of a meme, his posts were less focused early and became more focused over the course of day 1 and developed into reads.

I think he's just naked mafia here, but even I admit it's a small sample size.

The first thing that struck me is how he immediately commented on Shockey for something that FF did before Shockey and none of the discussion that followed even mentioned FF... I immediately thought, someone is getting spewed here, but I don't know who. That's when I looked more into HoldenGolden's past games.

I'm torn because I think the mechanically correct play here is to kill GTacc (combination of him being scummy and not being involved in the stupid discussion about claimed confirmed town), but I really want to vote HoldenGolden... So, we're killing one of them today.

Can I ask how you went about finding HoldenGolden's previous games? I wasn't aware that there were any previous games to look at?

I don't have many reads, unfortunately. I kinda like HoldenGolden though, he seems to be one of the few people who is active and poking around and trying to investigate things and get reads. Especially in an inactive game like this, that seems rather towny.

That's about all I have to say currently. Feel free to poke me, I'll try and check in every so often.

This post says nothing and does not address the guy voting you (me). Please engage with me. Do you not have a few vague reads asides from the Holden one? I realize that it is still early and the game has not exactly fleshed out, but a few things have happened at least that you can be commenting on. At least FF gave some substance.

I don't particularly care that you are voting for me. I see no reason to care.

I didn't really have any other reads worth mentioning, no. I'm not going to try to pretend to have something where I don't.

However I really don't like Mr. Cheesecake's above post (quoted). It feels rather aggressive while aggression is completely unwarranted. First, he accuses me of saying nothing (first, this is false because it's a townread on HoldenGolden; and second, it's a very short post, I didn't pretend to say anything anyway). And second, he justifies his request for reads by adding "at least Fecalfeast gave some substance" at the end. Why does he feel the need to justify asking me to provide reads? It feels very accusatory, and really feels like he's trying to tell me why I'm mafia.

That said, Mr. Cheesecake's post on ShoCkeyy is not completely terrible. I find ShoCkeyy hard to read, so I'll re-evaluate this in a moment. Honestly Mr. Cheesecake being active and doing things is probably reason enough not to lynch him, even if he irks me.

Then you reiterate in your list post

On August 11 2020 04:21 Trfel wrote:
Terrible Takes by Trfel

Town Lean
Mr. Cheesecake + Show Spoiler +

I still feel a bit bugged by how he played earlier in the game, but since then he's been investigating things and more importantly, he's been pushing his reads. In a low-activity game like this, there is less incentive for mafia to push reads. Despite the aforementioned things that I don't like, the rest of his play feels towny and investigative.

that mafia has an incentive to be inactive and so cheese is towny for that
then just recently you said

On August 15 2020 08:27 Trfel wrote:
I still feel like Mr. Cheesecake is town from earlier, though he hasn't posted in quite a while and that's disappointing. But that's not really alignment indicative. When he was posting, it felt like he was town. I only have one reason to call Eywa- mafia and at this point, it's not super compelling anymore, especially when compared to GTacc, ShoCkeyy, and LightningStrike.

indicating your read hasn't improved (since he's not been around) but you are now able to just say "he's town" without a hint of doubt?

Prev 1 5 6 7 8 9 10 Next All

Please or register to reply.

[N][M]Noir Mini Mafia - Ch. 5 - Page 7

Completed

Ongoing

Upcoming