|
United Kingdom30775 Posts
On August 25 2019 20:33 Vivax wrote:
Jocks scum game has improved from his last scum game. He might have even won this after a rayn lynch. I really don't know how cop and HF couldn't read rayn if eywa can. Maybe we should elevate this strategy of threatening to stop playing to scum standard until it stops working.
It's hard to lynch an un ccd cop my dude.
|
On August 25 2019 20:35 Holyflare wrote:Show nested quote +On August 25 2019 20:33 Vivax wrote:
Jocks scum game has improved from his last scum game. He might have even won this after a rayn lynch. I really don't know how cop and HF couldn't read rayn if eywa can. Maybe we should elevate this strategy of threatening to stop playing to scum standard until it stops working. It's hard to lynch an un ccd cop my dude.
He wouldn't have gotten that far without that bluff
|
Yo its in her name idk what you want from her. Jeez.
|
On August 25 2019 20:33 Vivax wrote:
Jocks scum game has improved from his last scum game. He might have even won this after a rayn lynch. I really don't know how cop and HF couldn't read rayn if eywa can. Maybe we should elevate this strategy of threatening to stop playing to scum standard until it stops working.
Thanks my dude.
I think I'm a god natural scum player, because in real life I am scum (or at least that's what my parents have always told me).
|
|
|
On August 25 2019 18:58 Chezinu wrote:
Thank you to all those who hosted the game. It seems like this game will bring me back to the mafia world. If Alakaslam can host a game, perhaps one day Liquidia will allow me to host a game.
My next game will be probably be play in a more sane manner.
You can host whenever now! We are Wild West
|
On August 25 2019 19:35 Holyflare wrote:
And this 2kp thing was really a fuck up. Nobody knew about it and you can't say that we should have known ablut something nobody ever mentioned. If mafia were never aware then squishy is never mafia there, cop reveals and rayn is mafia. Job done.
Fml.
Yes, but I can’t reveal what I tell the mafia. And FF did know about the rule the whole time.
Correct, I failed to make it clear. I fucked up. I was trying to make clear that it was the case without stating that I had to tell the mafia team.
To do otherwise would have been cheating, HF.
|
United Kingdom30775 Posts
On August 25 2019 23:13 Alakaslam wrote:Show nested quote +On August 25 2019 19:35 Holyflare wrote:
And this 2kp thing was really a fuck up. Nobody knew about it and you can't say that we should have known ablut something nobody ever mentioned. If mafia were never aware then squishy is never mafia there, cop reveals and rayn is mafia. Job done.
Fml. Yes, but I can’t reveal what I tell the mafia. And FF did know about the rule the whole time. Correct, I failed to make it clear. I fucked up. I was trying to make clear that it was the case without stating that I had to tell the mafia team. To do otherwise would have been cheating, HF.
I don't think it's cheating to say mafia know the mafia setup because mafia could have easily pushed me for making a no lynch plan.
|
United Kingdom30775 Posts
Wait wait, waittttt.
What were copcake's checks? Eywa who flipped and squishy?
|
On August 26 2019 01:45 Holyflare wrote:
Wait wait, waittttt.
What were copcake's checks? Eywa who flipped and squishy?
Eywa checked *red, then FF night 2 with no return.
|
United Kingdom30775 Posts
Oh checking FF.... really boring 
|
United Kingdom30775 Posts
I think in future I'm just not going to sign up to games that I can't be around for deadline. It's silly having 8-ish hours of time people can talk while the entirety of Europe is just not there that's critical to a lynch.
|
I thought it would be cool to try a different time zone deadline, but I do think I prefer the standard later evening Europe/afternoon US/morning Asia deadline. Seems best for everyone. With most the players being in Europe anyway, it makes for a better eod.
|
The good thing about this deadline is that I didnt get lynched for being afk and missing deadline.
|
Yeah I checked Ewya and I was torn between FF and Jock.
|
I'm not sure why you guys didn't sheep me... Rayn was obvious and Jock was PoE with 50/50 shot.
I think both HF and Jock are probably better scum players than town players, but the rest of the town felt very obvious with associative reads.
|
Like, I get the lynch... Though, if your followup plan is lynching squishy, you should at least give my reads a shot first because the chain lynch was an objectively bad play and the entire reason I didn't want to lynch squishy over me.
Beyond that though, after the flip, you need to give more attention to my reads, because I've never shown to have bad reads in my town games here.
Also, @HF, cases don't make sense because if I'm scum reading player A correctly and you're incorrectly scum reading player B... That means your view of what makes someone scum is incorrect, so in order to persuade you, I need to make up reasoning that is not actually alignment indicative... Since you're reading the game wrong, you're also not going to see why what I'm seeing is alignment indicative.
|
United Kingdom30775 Posts
On August 26 2019 06:13 Eywa- wrote:
I'm not sure why you guys didn't sheep me... Rayn was obvious and Jock was PoE with 50/50 shot.
I think both HF and Jock are probably better scum players than town players, but the rest of the town felt very obvious with associative reads.
What you stated in the obs qt about following my reads is because I used to be a really good town player (at least, actually lynching mafia consistently) but that's changed nowadays and it feels like nobody really plays the style that is compatible with me and nobody has the time either (and neither do I to be honest. Don't care enough).
I think town people played relatively well in displaying their towniness though.
|
On August 26 2019 07:10 Holyflare wrote:Show nested quote +On August 26 2019 06:13 Eywa- wrote:
I'm not sure why you guys didn't sheep me... Rayn was obvious and Jock was PoE with 50/50 shot.
I think both HF and Jock are probably better scum players than town players, but the rest of the town felt very obvious with associative reads. What you stated in the obs qt about following my reads is because I used to be a really good town player (at least, actually lynching mafia consistently) but that's changed nowadays and it feels like nobody really plays the style that is compatible with me and nobody has the time either (and neither do I to be honest. Don't care enough). I think town people played relatively well in displaying their towniness though.
Yeah, I mean, I could see that. We definitely have very different play styles. I think everyone in the game needs to just understand better where they fit (within the current game state) and play accordingly in order for town to have success... This is 3 scum wins in a row, definitely a bit out of the ordinary.
|
One thing I noticed (probably best not to listen to anything i say though) is that no-one from town realized that there was never really a plan and everyone was in their own little world. Eywa actually had a good plan and I'm surprised that no-one mentioned killing rayn day 3 just off the back of that (which is why i thought i had to bus rayn at the start of day 3), but everyone went back to improvising and trying to figure it out themselves.
It means you can be more active as mafia and its no longer obvious because the organization isn't there. The games I've been involved in here where town has had alot of success were the ones where people were cooperating on PoE and getting information but it just seemed like there wasn't enough of that in this game.
But I'm a stupid Jock and have no idea what I'm talking about 
|
|
|
|
|
|
EPT
