Hi I am here

VE shadiest to me so far. Comes in and feels the need to let us know he has reads but he isnt ready to post any of them yet. Asks slam a close to pointless question and just snap agrees with him, makes an early activity excuse and makes some easy setup speculation posts. So touches of guilty conscience posts + fake activity without actually looking for mafia.

VE have enough people posted for you to share your reads yet? And if so what are they? Majority of the players have posted by now.

@holyflare why is FF in your town circle? Nothing he has posted seems towny to me. Especially his post about LS always looking mafia to him but then flipping to saying I guess you are towny enough, feels off to me.

Grack/sentinel/jockm/ksc/ff all useless so far. Slam I have no clue.

disfos post about having to read his pm 5 times felt townie to me for some reason.

Mig

United States4714 Posts

April 06 2019 04:56 GMT

#436

I never have any idea of your alignment slam. If you are town you should recognize my town play pretty easily tho.

Mig

United States4714 Posts

April 06 2019 05:06 GMT

#441

I am not misrepresenting anything, I just said your post felt off to me FF.

What exactly did LS do that made you say he was towny enough for you? Who do you think the mafia are?

Mig

United States4714 Posts

April 06 2019 05:11 GMT

#443

Theres 15 pages of content, thats not enough for you to have any ideas? Its hard to find mafia day1 but there is plenty of content to at least have some ideas.

Mig

United States4714 Posts

April 06 2019 05:19 GMT

#445

So the only thing you find weird is damdred?

What do you think about rayn/hf?

Mig

United States4714 Posts

April 07 2019 15:34 GMT

#807

I am back, my apologies for the lack of activity. Been at a poker tournament for 2 days and I cant read mafia while I play. So I have not read anything past page23 so far.

Fun fact, in all the times I have played mafia I have never actually been lynched as town. So could potentially be a first! If I do here its my own fault for being gone for so long, although I have no idea why people would even think I am mafia from the only posts I have so far. Even from just a couple posts I clearly put some effort into actually thinking about the game and going through filters trying to figure out who the mafia are.

I should be here in and out through the deadline so I will get caught up with the thread before then. If anyone has any questions for me I will answer them.

Mig

United States4714 Posts

April 07 2019 15:51 GMT

#812

In general I agree that disappearing for a long time and making an excuse is indicative of mafia. In this case it isnt alignment indicative because it is the truth and if people want proof I can provide it.

Like I said if I get lynched my apologies to the town. I would just say to read my posts and actually think about whether they come from the perspective of a mafia trying to fake look for mafia or a townie actually trying to figure out the game based on the information I had.

Mig

United States4714 Posts

April 07 2019 15:55 GMT

#814

I havent read the thread, I am on page 27. Give me a minute. I didnt want to just show up 2hrs before the deadline and make a post in case people wanted to ask me something with more time left.

Mig

United States4714 Posts

April 07 2019 15:56 GMT

#815

Hf did you ever answer why you thought FF was town?

Mig

United States4714 Posts

April 07 2019 16:17 GMT

#821

Grack do you have any reason besides the lynch all liars for wanting to lynch rayne?

Mig

United States4714 Posts

April 07 2019 17:22 GMT

#830

That’s your only reason for voting ewya rayne? Do you have anything to say about mz/gracks reasoning against you?

Mig

United States4714 Posts

April 07 2019 19:15 GMT

#925

The arguing/speculation about the setup and roles seems like a waste of time 3 hours before lynch. Lets try to lynch who is scummiest. My wincon says win with town I do not care about lynching anything other than non town. We will have more information tomorrow after people flip anyway.

Thoughts on a palmar lynch? His stuff feels forced to me. If he just said I want to lynch damdred because of his only posts being speculation on setup then fine but then he felt the need to justify it with 8 paragraphs coming up a theory about how hes a mafia trying to pretend to be a 3rd party? Its the start of the game and Damdred has barely posted. Seems like a real stretch, when I played with palmar back in the day he was always one of the better players which makes me question whether he really believes what hes saying here or if this is just a safe/easy mislynch for him to push

meapak have you figured out who you are voting for yet?

Mig

United States4714 Posts

April 07 2019 19:20 GMT

#936

How does it make any sense that Eywa says he wins if LS recruits him but then he also wants to lynch LS?

Mig

United States4714 Posts

April 07 2019 19:29 GMT

#957

Nothing about any of this confirms someone as town. Maybe LS needs to recruit 2 town and 1 mafia to win or 1 mafia 1 town 1 third party. We have no idea. Which is why this is a waste of time to even speculate on it until some flips happen.

Mig

United States4714 Posts

April 07 2019 19:41 GMT

#983

Meapak do you think eywa is mafia? As a mafia who thought he was at risk of being recruited by LS would he out himself and freak out right before lynch like this. He could have just stayed quiet.

Eywa do you think meapak is mafia?

Mig

United States4714 Posts

April 07 2019 19:48 GMT

#992

Just seems like a dumb play for mafia to make. He wasnt under any pressure, he could have just sat back and stayed quiet. Why get in a big fight over roles with rayn then out yourself over the LS stuff. Its not impossible mafia does it but doesnt it seem more like an emotional town play? And I guess you think all the stuff with him claiming to misread his role pm was faked?

Eywa smh. I

Mig

United States4714 Posts

April 07 2019 19:50 GMT

#996

HF do you still think meapak is mafia?

Mig

United States4714 Posts

April 07 2019 19:51 GMT

#997

tumblewood why are you voting me over mocsta when your most recent post about finding someone scummy was him?

Mig

United States4714 Posts

April 07 2019 19:57 GMT

#1002

Eywa even if LS is a recruiter you have no idea what his alignment is and you have no idea what alignments he recruits from. Maybe some of the people he recruits are mafia/3rd party.

If you think LS is mafia then fine lynch him but if you think hes part of town its a waste of time.

Why dont you just try lynching the person you think is mostly likely to flip mafia.