|
On April 15 2019 06:29 Pandain wrote:
Disinformation I thought you played really well! I mean town was tunneled hard on there being a town recruiter so that fundamentally decided the last days lynch (and thinking surrounding it), but without you I don't think vivax would have been lynched.
you should sign up for artanis's game
I really loved day 2. It was just so crazy and no one had any idea what was going on.
thanks!
i will consider signing up for artanis's game, but i am going on a vaction (in Italy!) for a week in early May, so I think that might be a bit tight time wise.
think i could have played d1 a bit better. my early attempt at digging at Euclid was a tad too heavyhanded.
|
|
|
On April 15 2019 06:27 rsoultin wrote:
So the reason the roles were so non-standard and could target other townies was that all of those roles could still become mafia. And it would give town tools against mafia later in the game theoretically. Obviously that's not how the game played out lol ><
Yeah that was never going to work. Townies fucking love claiming their roles. You really need to account for mass claiming.
Repeated recruiting is way too strong for mafia. Recruiting mechanisms need to be capped at like 1 person.
|
|
|
/m111 was sarcasm. Yes I do love rolling some mafia. But seeing the not best night actions as a host is...
Second a PI sent a note...
It said:
Dear Euclid
The person you are looking for is dead.
Your faithful PI
If you are giving me a night action I am damn well using it to my fullest!
|
|
|
I wouldn't recommend lynching Sentinel. Damdred is very likely town so his voting at the deadline should be non-alignment indicative.
Top lynches:
Palmar
Vivax
Pretty good lynches:
Mig
Disfo
Tumblewood
Likely town/shouldn't lynch:
Mocsta
Damdred
Tubesock
Pandain
Other people I'm unsure about.
pretty good reeds, grack.
also very entertaining to read.
10/10
|
Balance:
First yes this was very scum favored. More so than it should have been. Recruiting is OP. It is. Also they got it on fibonacci nights. They should have gotten on nights that were followed by the Fibonacci Day. This would have gave them nights 1,2,4. Instead of 1,2,3,5. This would have given town one more mislynch in this game. Damdred not getting modkilled would have gotten town another mislynch.
Mass Claims day one would have resulted in claims of 2 lovers, a cop, a kinda JK, a poisoner, a anti recruiter or roleblocker whatever palmar claimed, and a 3p. Under half of them would get you mafia.
The setup was going to be 21 players 2 mafia that recruit but are goons, a cop, a pgo, and a unrecruitable vet. A few days before the game started the 3 of us decided that it could be alot more themed and that is what we went with. I have gotten many messages that most of you had fun even if it was a not super balanced game. I know some of the vets didnt really care for it though. Oh well.
Rayn dont make that post again plz. Because if you were mafia and that was your scum team I would have mod killed you right there. If you are town I dont mod kill you...
|
I had a good time. Good enough to comment instead if party. Thx hosts!
|
On April 15 2019 07:15 VisceraEyes wrote:
I had a good time. Good enough to comment instead if party. Thx hosts!
Join Artanis's game.
We want more VE!
|
Join the club pal, I'm beating off bridesmaids with a stick
|
On April 15 2019 07:24 VisceraEyes wrote:
Join the club pal, I'm beating off bridesmaids with a stick
Tell them you're already taken by some nerd on a mafia forum.
|
Canada11355 Posts
Did I really win first by the way?
|
Interesting,
Palmar rb me n1
My role was that transparent?
|
On April 15 2019 06:25 rsoultin wrote:
Yeah we discussed later that if we kept the recruitment mechanic we'd offset it so there weren't so many recruited mafia.
Artanis has suggested maybe we should have made it a pm game (and probably given mafia a recruiter instead of have the recruiting mechanic be for the whole team). I forget why we didn't do that tbh. Maybe just concern that an early recruiter lynch would be super bad for mafia? But we probably shouldn't have been so concerned about that.
i remember wishing very hard that this were a PM game around D2
|
Ya I think PMs would've worked. I seem to recall PM games falling out of favor here when I was playing toward the end.
|
On April 15 2019 07:10 Onegu wrote:
Rayn dont make that post again plz. Because if you were mafia and that was your scum team I would have mod killed you right there. If you are town I dont mod kill you...
Dont make a game where players who have won dont leave the game again and i promise you youll never get something like that.
|
GG. Not the result i expected. All scum were in my idk pile N1 but i knew i am gonna win D2 most likely i just didnt care that much (well i didnt in the first place when i realised what role damdred rly was).
|
It's hilarious how hindu/arab effectively killed themselves D1 though
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
EPT
