[M][N] Bebop Mafia

[M][N] Bebop Mafia - Page 15

raynpelikoneet

Finland43226 Posts

October 24 2018 21:05 GMT

#281

Okay so Koshi the i-wont-ever-lynch-rayn-until-D3-even-if-i-thought-he-could-be-mafia guy got away with "leading" a lynch on HF for literally no reason, and never said anything of substance really throughout whole game (not to blame him, apparently he didnt really have to..)

DF came with the basic 8 min after deadline post blaming the lynch and then never took any action against the guy who lead the lynch for no reason (aka Koshi). I know df sometimes does the first part as town too but id still lynch him (or anyone) for that every time.

Holyflare

United Kingdom30774 Posts

October 24 2018 21:24 GMT

#282

On October 25 2018 05:57 [UoN]Sentinel wrote:

Show nested quote +

On October 25 2018 05:51 Holyflare wrote:

On October 25 2018 04:34 [UoN]Sentinel wrote:

On October 25 2018 03:46 Holyflare wrote:

On October 23 2018 10:12 [UoN]Sentinel wrote:

On October 23 2018 09:39 byj wrote:

On October 23 2018 08:55 [UoN]Sentinel wrote:

On October 23 2018 08:22 byj wrote:
Zzz, guess it's time for me to go sleep again... and wake up to an empty thread

What are your thoughts on my effortpost

+ Show Spoiler +

TL;DR

I agree with you on DF, Koshi and prplhz, but I got no clue about ruXxar. I hate to say it, but it made you seem less scummy. But still what you said after the lynch makes you seem so scummy... even riding onto another lynch with HF is something beneficial for Scum I'd say, and something I'd do. Assuming you get it you have the chance to upgrade from a VT to a power role, and once pressed about changing the vote you could argue that it's because you think that HF was town - and thus implying lynch votes onto you are misdirected and should be onto HF if they really think he's scum... maybe I'm reading way too much into it ¯\_(ツ)_/¯
Guess I'll go to sleep for real now, looking forward to hearing from you Koshi and ruXxar

My D1 plan was pretty simple:

1) Lynch any good source of information. Especially in a game this inactive I have absolutely no idea who's town and who's scum (most of) D1. Whoever we lynch, hopefully it's contentious enough that we get different wagons. Maybe even if we lynched Palmar in absentia (like over the course of the day, not rapidly at the end), we would've had a productive conversation about it.

BUT lynching someone like HF who has said a lot of stuff will give us lots of information. If we lynch Palmar he has said nothing and the fact that he is town gives us no additional information (besides how people voted and why). If we lynch HF we get all that and we get to see lots of confirmed town posts. If he turned out to be scum we just stopped scum from running the thread in their frame.

And you might ask "why didn't you lynch your scum reads instead?" which is the ideal town strat right? Right now my most probable scumteam is ruXxar and darthfoley. I would have no idea besides a very light suspicion on DF that those two were scum. Probably someone else would be an idiot or I'd somehow convince myself Koshi was scum and I'd get a towny lynched even if I had my way.

2) Get a wagon on me. First of all mafia is way more fun when everyone is talking about you. But second from my perspective I had no idea what to make of the game so I wanted to reduce the number of variables. Towns generally give more risky and more substantial arguments for lynching someone. Scums either tag along or have to frame the argument in which the target (me) is scum and ignore the one in which the target is not scum. I've used it before to varying success but usually it helps more than it hurts.

Maybe it makes it a little more ass to play a game with me - I don't know, you tell me about that one.

It's generally not a good idea to lynch the person doing the most talking in a game where there are 0 posts.

I talked as much D2 as you did D1 and vice versa

I wouldn't say much was lost in terms of activity

That didn't work out either though did it?

Did your plan to lynch byj work out?

I mean this is being pretty obtuse because I didn't want to lynch byj in the end and he hadn't said anything of substance or quantity when I wanted to lynch him but in future a game plan shouldn't revolve around killing the only person or persons propelling the game forward by talking because:

A) Mafia is going to kill them anyway if they're talking too much and causing activity.
B) You get more information the longer they're alive. If that person didn't get killed by mafia but they're the only one playing then it's more likely than not that they are mafia.
C) Talking more, if they are town, means that mafia has to talk more to blend in and thus make more mistakes.

Saying the lynch would be polarising and thus you would gain more information because of it is not a good game plan. It's not the worst offense in the game by any means.

Alakaslam

United States17322 Posts

October 27 2018 18:16 GMT

#283

Ah shit how did I miss this?

Dammit

Alakaslam

United States17322 Posts

October 27 2018 18:17 GMT

#284

On October 24 2018 08:32 iamperfection wrote:
tl mafia is dead

absolutely atrocious play by both sides really how koshi dosen't get policy lynched for that day 1 is inexcusable.

Ridiculously town favored setup and still manage to lose? Cop didn't know he was cop? How is that even possible if you read your role pm. how did you know you were town ?

im actually flabbergasted

I pronounced the curse long ago.

Smashboards too will die.