[M][N] Medic Mafia - Page 5

On March 09 2018 03:59 AMG wrote:
He keeps posting giant piles of words that I haven't had enough coffee to read. It's 5am here.

On March 09 2018 04:21 darthfoley wrote:
Lol townmedic!HF ensuring he kills another townmedic N1 would surely be superb.

Mafia will probably shoot HF (if he's actually town and/or townmedic) and medic me, potentially killing 2/3 town medics in one night. Really really stellar idea.

On March 09 2018 08:16 rsoultin wrote:
But then I also just have a hard time picturing either Viva or HF as scum.

Hey, HF...is DF still your top scumread? Because you effectively prevented his NK if scum believed you...not that I think he was high on the list unless as a possible medic dodge anyway, assuming he's town.

On March 09 2018 17:37 rsoultin wrote:


I'd be more on board with this if we didn't have 3 town medics, which makes ccing impossible without a mass claim.

Do you fundamentally disagree that shooting into claimed medics narrows down the fake claim (assuming a scum fake claim)?

And if no fake claims, how does info from the 'night kills' when we get two more free vig shots and one save without a scum roleblocker (assuming shots on 3 medics 3 nights in a row) possibly outweigh removing 3 names from lynch consideration?

We'd be looking for two scum in seven people rather than two in ten. I like those odds. Especially if even one of those medics is lynchbait. Like, if we can clear some lynch bait, and they're not in my top townreads (assuming my top townreads are correct) this game is practically solved.

I really don't see how NK info outweighs this. Sometimes I find NK info helps, but usually I find it WIFOMy anyway.

Three confirmed town vs. NK guesswork.

Yeah I really, really think the mass claim is the best move for town here.

On March 09 2018 19:58 rsoultin wrote:


Confirmed town is the point. Less wiggle room for mafia is the point. At least three more nights if the game even lasts that long of being able to use our power roles is the point.

What nk information are you even expecting to get that is better served by not mass claiming?

On March 09 2018 20:00 rsoultin wrote:

I think you haven't given me a single reason that makes sense for you to have changed your mind beyond receiving your role pm.

On March 09 2018 20:40 rsoultin wrote:


This is exactly a Day 2 mass claim.

This game never lasts past Day 5.

10 today.
7 day 3.
With no rb, 4 day 4 unless we have medics hold their saves to get a day 5 3-man lylo.