|
On February 07 2018 22:16 rsoultin wrote:Pending on you, koshi. It skeeves me out a little that you're focused on lynchbait and right on my alignment where most everyone else is wrong. I know you've picked your scum game up recently. But I can see where you're coming from on your prp lynch and it really comes down to whether or not 1) I agree that all the active people are more likely town or at least have a decent shot at it or 2) that it makes sense for you to think that. Also, could you explain this? I think you said it was about df and why rayn scumreads him, but I'm not following at all: Show nested quote +On February 07 2018 20:10 Koshi wrote:
Why did you say that though? It sounds a bit weird. Mayne cuz I am not a native speaker but still..
I believe your arguments are wrong
That sounds so icky.
If you cant follow it you are not reading the thread. It is rayn is nr 1 reason to scumread df and he explained it.
And I already explained this very post to mocsta as well. And on top of that df answered me already.
I cant help blind people in a forum mafia game. This is just pathetic.
|
You have to not have read 7-10 posts to not understand the post...
Explain to me in extreme detail why prplhz is town or "ok" for you. I want to completely understand it.
|
I offcially revoke my leaning townread on rsoultin. I dont want to lynch her today. But fuck this thread control type of play that doesnt push the game forward at all. All stupid safe reads and nothing interesting in over 100 posts.
I am not entertained. You may die.
|
There are 10 more posts in the thread about that. It has nothing to do with skimming. You are just filling your filter and not solving the game. You cannot miss all the fucking posts about this.
|
On February 07 2018 22:27 rsoultin wrote:Show nested quote +On February 07 2018 22:23 Koshi wrote:
You have to not have read 7-10 posts to not understand the post...
Explain to me in extreme detail why prplhz is town or "ok" for you. I want to completely understand it. There's not much to completely understand. I didn't think there was anything particularly alignment indicative in what he'd posted, which is why I asked you (if I recall correctly) for your read on him.
You tr prplhz at some point. Or at least were ok with him. You keep asking me about prplhz and your own read is foggy as fuck. Reread prplhz if needed and explain how you felt about him this entire game. What are you telling me?? You have had no opinion at all on him this entire fucking game?
What are you doing?????
|
rsoultin is not solving this game. That is for sure. Blah. Last time you were way more obvious mafia.
I remember my banana apple post.
|
On February 07 2018 22:30 rsoultin wrote:Show nested quote +On February 07 2018 22:28 Koshi wrote:
There are 10 more posts in the thread about that. It has nothing to do with skimming. You are just filling your filter and not solving the game. You cannot miss all the fucking posts about this. -shrugs- It wasn't obvious to me. So sue me.
Yeah. I am. For negligence.
|
On February 07 2018 22:33 Mocsta wrote:Show nested quote +On February 07 2018 22:28 Koshi wrote:
There are 10 more posts in the thread about that. It has nothing to do with skimming. You are just filling your filter and not solving the game. You cannot miss all the fucking posts about this. Sigh. I agree. Really stuck on where to vote before i go to bed I was willing to give rsoultin a chance but now she is just wasting it on filter commentary. Mderg list post feels disconnected which he even comments on. Im happy with a vote on rsoultin mderg or damdred I think its good there 4 or 5 people with votes. Tug of war that is split this hard means at least one wagon is mafia in my opinion. Im going to read mderg and tina past game now to finalise vote
Rsoultin mderg and prplhz are good places to plant a vote. We will probably lynch the townie out of the 3 on d1 but removing that person is fine anyway.
Damdred is maybe not mafia. Some shady people are too outspoken on him.
|
On February 07 2018 22:37 mderg wrote:Show nested quote +On February 07 2018 22:17 Koshi wrote:
Can still lynch mderg. No way a townie ends up with 10 mafia suspects in a 13 player game. That's not where you end up while solving things.
This is nitpicking. And that is all it is. Are you saying I have 10 mafia suspects?
Yes. That is what it says.
You are nitpicking filters and not trying to find the alignment behind the filters.
I dont know why you are nitpicking the filters. But I am sure that you are doing just that.
This game is about finding 3 mafia out of 12 players. You are looking for the 3 and not for the 9.
Why are you not looking for the 9?
|
On February 07 2018 22:42 mderg wrote:Show nested quote +On February 07 2018 22:41 Koshi wrote:On February 07 2018 22:37 mderg wrote:On February 07 2018 22:17 Koshi wrote:
Can still lynch mderg. No way a townie ends up with 10 mafia suspects in a 13 player game. That's not where you end up while solving things.
This is nitpicking. And that is all it is. Are you saying I have 10 mafia suspects? Yes. That is what it says. You are nitpicking filters and not trying to find the alignment behind the filters. I dont know why you are nitpicking the filters. But I am sure that you are doing just that. This game is about finding 3 mafia out of 12 players. You are looking for the 3 and not for the 9. Why are you not looking for the 9? Are you fuckng serious?
This is serious fucking business.
|
On February 07 2018 23:12 rsoultin wrote:Sorry if you're town, Ian. I'm just done. Calling me scum and shooting me multiple exclamation point question mark shouty posts is one thing. Claiming I'm just filling my filter when I'm trying to leave a post flip legacy is another. Well, it's there. I'm done. I don't know if I'm right or not but whatever.
You are not going to get lynched so just breath and try again.
|
Tfrel.
One of the easiest ways to solve this game is by PoE.
I thought everybody did that. Remove townies from your list and look into others more indepth.
If mderg is town he is the first who isnt doing that. Converstion okish and rayn okish iirc.
|
What mderg did looks way more "what can I say about this filter". Nothing more. Just that.
I completely miss the feeling he does it to solve the game. To come closer to the truth.
|
On February 08 2018 00:12 Conversion wrote:
Man I'm tempted to sheep Koshi 100% and just lynch mderg or prplhz this game. Both filters are terrible.
Koshi, why mderg > prplhz? I may be missing it from your filter, but I'm assuming it's because of mderg's list post and tone.
I dont really care about which one atm.
prplhz is still doing nothing. Is it mafia hiding or a townie who doesnt care? I dont know.
Mderg just isnt making the right posts.
|
On February 08 2018 00:31 mderg wrote:Show nested quote +On February 07 2018 22:45 Damdred wrote:
Mderg pretend I havent read the game to a deep level,. If what Koshi says isnt true can you give me your sxum reada with a condensed reason for each? rsoultin: Feels like a completely different person than last game. Much less nice and inclusiv, much more aggressive in questioning people. Koshi: Seems like he is just trying to lynch by number of posts. Feels lazy unlike town hero koshi. darthfoley: Scumread on Mocsta for what I consider dumb reasons, omgus on Trfel, rayn and Mocsta and some general "bitchiness"
Mderg, you understand this read on me feels extremely shallow? I made it very obvious why I am lynching into you guys. Very very obvious.
|
##Unvote
##Vote: mderg
Both wagons like fine as I think mafia lies within Rels/Damdred/mderg/prplhz and HF.
So congratz to the ones who get their lynch.
I would never lynch rsoultin today. Way too much value that gets lost if she is town. Wayyyy too much value. Only lynch rsoultin if you believe you will be able to read mderg better as this game progresses or have a townread on him.
I also still haven't read a decent case on why rsoultin is mafia. The best points I saw were meta related. All the rest is not that brilliant.
|
It's not that I am certain mderg is mafia. But in my opinion he is not solving the game as a townie would.
What did he achieve today, is he closer to figuring out this puzzle, has he ever gave you the feeling he is closing down on mafia? And if he didn't, is he at least trying to clear some townies so his PoE pool gets smaller?
Which waves did he make, did he piss someone off by poking and prodding?
Did he help town develop reads? Was a a value to town? Did somebody ever had a "aha that's a good point moment"
Like... I am not sure he is mafia. But he didn't try hard enough and when we aren't 100% sure on day 1. Lynch question marks. Don't lynch easy to read players who deliver shittons of content.
|
Well if both mderg and rsoultin are town we have to start looking at rayn and HF who has been avoiding each other I feel like. Not sure if that is completely correct but when I didn't do anything they did push this thread towards a place I didn't like. Which is darthfoley/rsoultin mafia.
I don't buy that.
I might be wrong though.
|
HF mafia who lets rayn do the driving D1. Seems plausible.
|
Tinfoil though. I like rayn atm. But I suck at reading him lately. Well... I just always read him town.
|
|
|
|
|
|
EPT
