|
On February 07 2018 22:45 Damdred wrote:
Mderg pretend I havent read the game to a deep level,. If what Koshi says isnt true can you give me your sxum reada with a condensed reason for each?
rsoultin: Feels like a completely different person than last game. Much less nice and inclusiv, much more aggressive in questioning people.
Koshi: Seems like he is just trying to lynch by number of posts. Feels lazy unlike town hero koshi.
darthfoley: Scumread on Mocsta for what I consider dumb reasons, omgus on Trfel, rayn and Mocsta and some general "bitchiness"
|
On February 08 2018 00:07 Koshi wrote:
What mderg did looks way more "what can I say about this filter". Nothing more. Just that.
I completely miss the feeling he does it to solve the game. To come closer to the truth.
I litterally looked at the player list and thought: "What do I think about them". When I didn't really know I looked at their filter. I very much need to do stuff like that to I keep my thoughts in order.
|
On February 08 2018 00:08 Conversion wrote:and I'd like rsoultin to respond, but I doubt she will. It would help her case a lot more if she did so than you, as I need to be able to see what she is thinking and experience her clarifying her points. If I really want to nitpick on the mderg point: Show nested quote +On February 07 2018 22:14 mderg wrote:
A good old summary post you all know and love. Comment: Who actually likes these posts?
Damdred: Nothing Comment: Literally says nothing.
ritoky: doesn't give a fuck, tone says town. Read on me kind of makes sense except I haven't been active or present enough to do anything. I've been really disconnected from the game, though Comment: translates to, I guess he is town, but disclaimer I didn't do anything this game.
Mocsta: Feels different from last game, almost his whole game revolved around roultin at the start. Started being a bit more jumpy now. Not sure how that makes me feel. Comment: Says nothing.
darthfoley: Not liking his early scumread on Mocsta, for what I consider dumb reasons. Some omgus on Trfel, Rayn and Mocsta. Sounds very annoyed at some points. Could maybe see scum. Comment: Possible scum
Rels: Nothing Comment: Literally says nothing.
Conversion: Didn't like him questioning me about this "bullshit" thing with rsoultin at first. his reasoning actually makes sense for a townie, though. his posts mostly don't seem very memorable but his points on rsoultin resonate really well with me. Gets a pass for now. Comment: I guess his read was good, but he gets a "pass" since I didn't like his earlier post. Does this mean I am town only for this day?
rsoultin: Her posts give of a much different feel from the last game. She's not this nice lady trying to get everyone involved and figure out their motives. She's much more aggressive in her questioning of people. Would lynch. Comment: We already knew this from his vote and earlier post.
raynpelikoneet: don't know, honestly. His reads seem fine for the most part. Comment: Says nothing.
Koshi: Doesn't feel like the great multiple awards winning town hero Koshi. Seems like he wants to lynch 99% based on post count. Not to my liking. Comment: Says nothing aside from I don't like Koshi this game
Holyflare: Comment: ???
Trfel: Heavy focus on Conversion early on but then switched off him, not quite sure why. Like his pressure on koshi. Comment: Says nothing.
prplhz: No idea how to read him at this point Comment: Says nothing.: This post is literally saying most of the players are null, maybe one is possible scum. It is not a good post. It was unnecessary.
Like half the time where you comment "says nothing" it only says nothing because you want it to say nothing. I have exactly 4 null reads: Damdred, Rels, Holyflare and prplhz
|
On February 08 2018 00:14 Trfel wrote:
@Conversion, fair enough, I see that.
Personally I'm not a fan of his read progression on rsoultin. Feels like he goes from nothing to serial killer post was exaggerated to I see some of Mocsta's stuff (but the quality/accuracy of the read doesn't make me townread Mocsta) to passive-aggressiveness to not town rsoultin. Feels like following thread sentiment without adding much.
The Mocsta thing really sticks out to me. Did mderg agree with Mocsta's case? It seems like he did, since he was saying that he was seeing it and the biggest reasons he (mderg) is suspicious of rsoultin for are in it. But his own read on Mocsta is that he (Mocsta) is town because of being focused instead of jumping around. Nothing at all to do with Mocsta's suspicions of rsoultin that mderg himself seems to agree with strongly enough to vote.
Does anyone else see that?
@Koshi, I see what you're saying now. I guess I don't expect everyone to solve the game by POE, I know that I don't. Not opposed to the rest of what you're saying though. Thanks for explaining your prplhz/mderg thing earlier, by the way, that really helped. I had missed rsoultin asking for your prplhz read.
rsoultin read progression was something like: didn't like the serial killer post to rsoultin feels passive-aggressive, so doesn't look like town rsoultin.
I guess that's pretty close to thread sentiment but I've never claimed that I didn't sheep.
My townread on Mocsta is largely based on his rsoultin case. I think that says enough.
|
On February 08 2018 00:26 Conversion wrote:
Someone (I think DF) also called out how hilarious it was that mderg commented on how he liked Mocsta for kind of knowing where he was going in the game, but also said he had a hard time really understanding his posts..
I think we centralize on prplhz/mderg/rsoul here. I'm leaning more towards prplhz/mderg, but I didn't like rsoultin's latest string of posts either. I will explain that soon.
That point is just semantics, though. Mocsta knowing where he was going was in no way about him making clear and concise posts.
|
On February 08 2018 00:58 Trfel wrote:Show nested quote +On February 08 2018 00:53 mderg wrote:On February 08 2018 00:14 Trfel wrote:
@Conversion, fair enough, I see that.
Personally I'm not a fan of his read progression on rsoultin. Feels like he goes from nothing to serial killer post was exaggerated to I see some of Mocsta's stuff (but the quality/accuracy of the read doesn't make me townread Mocsta) to passive-aggressiveness to not town rsoultin. Feels like following thread sentiment without adding much.
The Mocsta thing really sticks out to me. Did mderg agree with Mocsta's case? It seems like he did, since he was saying that he was seeing it and the biggest reasons he (mderg) is suspicious of rsoultin for are in it. But his own read on Mocsta is that he (Mocsta) is town because of being focused instead of jumping around. Nothing at all to do with Mocsta's suspicions of rsoultin that mderg himself seems to agree with strongly enough to vote.
Does anyone else see that?
@Koshi, I see what you're saying now. I guess I don't expect everyone to solve the game by POE, I know that I don't. Not opposed to the rest of what you're saying though. Thanks for explaining your prplhz/mderg thing earlier, by the way, that really helped. I had missed rsoultin asking for your prplhz read. rsoultin read progression was something like: didn't like the serial killer post to rsoultin feels passive-aggressive, so doesn't look like town rsoultin. I guess that's pretty close to thread sentiment but I've never claimed that I didn't sheep. My townread on Mocsta is largely based on his rsoultin case. I think that says enough. The last sentence, I don't see that at all in your filter. You've said that your townread on Mocsta is due to staying focused and not jumping around like he did last game as mafia. Show nested quote +On February 07 2018 20:53 mderg wrote:On February 07 2018 08:47 darthfoley wrote:On February 06 2018 20:25 mderg wrote:
Mocsta seems townie based on the fact that he kind of seems to know where he's going this game. I'd really like mderg to expand on this point because tbh I have no idea where Mocsta is going outside of his rsoultin read. Pretty much everything early on revolved around his scumread on rsoultin and his desire to get her lynched. Last game it felt like he latched onto every other case without any focus on who he actually voted or wanted to lynch. To me this doesn't say anything about what you think about his case/read on rsoultin itself, it talks about the way he's pushing (focused, with direction vs opportunistic, pushing everyone). Still listening if I am missing something though. Heading out for class, voting mderg for now. The above seems very inconsistent. Mderg also doesn't seem to care if people are making reads and sharing thoughts that he agrees with; it doesn't affect his read on the person who posted the thoughts at all.
I can actually see why you don't see it in my filter. I didn't really mention that because in my mind it was self explaining but if you're not in my mind it's probably not.
|
On February 08 2018 01:06 Koshi wrote:Show nested quote +On February 08 2018 00:31 mderg wrote:On February 07 2018 22:45 Damdred wrote:
Mderg pretend I havent read the game to a deep level,. If what Koshi says isnt true can you give me your sxum reada with a condensed reason for each? rsoultin: Feels like a completely different person than last game. Much less nice and inclusiv, much more aggressive in questioning people. Koshi: Seems like he is just trying to lynch by number of posts. Feels lazy unlike town hero koshi. darthfoley: Scumread on Mocsta for what I consider dumb reasons, omgus on Trfel, rayn and Mocsta and some general "bitchiness" Mderg, you understand this read on me feels extremely shallow? I made it very obvious why I am lynching into you guys. Very very obvious.
Apart from not really being in the game I didn't see any obvious reasons
|
On February 08 2018 01:37 Trfel wrote:
Mderg, what do you think about rsoultin's points on darthfoley?
They look pretty on point...
|
On February 08 2018 03:06 Damdred wrote:
Mderg I sort of feel your read on basedgodkoshi is a bit... underwhelming. I think Koshi has on the surface decent points (i disagree with him because your list in review looks the same as last game somewhat.) so I dont necessarily scum level of koshi laziness or going along with the thread sentiment.
What's your point here?
|
I think my rsoultin scumread may actually be stupid here.
|
On February 08 2018 04:06 darthfoley wrote:Show nested quote +On February 08 2018 00:26 Conversion wrote:
Someone (I think DF) also called out how hilarious it was that mderg commented on how he liked Mocsta for kind of knowing where he was going in the game, but also said he had a hard time really understanding his posts..
I think we centralize on prplhz/mderg/rsoul here. I'm leaning more towards prplhz/mderg, but I didn't like rsoultin's latest string of posts either. I will explain that soon. yes, it was I! I still think that inconsistency is very weird, even after he explained it. I kinda bought it but not really Catching up now 1 hour before deadline
still no actual inconsistency there.
|
On February 08 2018 04:29 rsoultin wrote:Show nested quote +On February 08 2018 04:28 mderg wrote:
I think my rsoultin scumread may actually be stupid here. That's unfortunate for you given I'm the main counterwagon. Who would you even want to lynch then?
I think I might want to lynch darthfoley
|
Yeah, I'm feeling this lynch
##vote: darthfoley
|
On February 08 2018 04:51 rsoultin wrote:Show nested quote +On February 08 2018 04:50 rsoultin wrote:
This is distracting from the more relevant fact that Mderg is town and being lynched
and frankly I could care less whose e-penis is bigger. Show nested quote +On February 08 2018 04:50 rsoultin wrote:
This is distracting from the more relevant fact that Mderg is town and being lynched
and frankly I could care less whose e-penis is bigger. Show nested quote +On February 08 2018 04:50 rsoultin wrote:
This is distracting from the more relevant fact that Mderg is town and being lynched
and frankly I could care less whose e-penis is bigger. Show nested quote +On February 08 2018 04:50 rsoultin wrote:
This is distracting from the more relevant fact that Mderg is town and being lynched
and frankly I could care less whose e-penis is bigger. !!!!!
!
|
On February 08 2018 04:54 rsoultin wrote:Show nested quote +On February 08 2018 04:52 Holyflare wrote:
I don't care if mderg is town and getting lynched though. He's pulling off his only chance for survival. No way he does that as scum.
kind of wifom but I would tend to agree
|
|
|
|
|
|
EPT
