|
On November 01 2017 22:59 Conversion wrote:Show nested quote +On November 01 2017 22:55 happykrogan wrote:On November 01 2017 22:37 Conversion wrote:On November 01 2017 22:36 Conversion wrote:
the problemI have with the scumread of “DF is attacking anyone possible” is that he could have just saved himself the effort and pushed me exactly how he pushed me last game and most likely started a wagon. my play hasn’t differed too wildly (as pointed out by krogan), so why would he waste time throwing shade at other people when he has two very good lynch targets he can focus on (me/shockey) EBWOP The best explanation I can think of right now is that he doesn't want to follow thread sentiment because it could cause problems later in the game. The thing is, Shockey is the thread sentiment right now, I am not. People have me at a lazy null b/c they don't want to revisit my filter due to time or such, so it'd be a pretty safe push as a mafia. If I flip town, he could have said, "Well he was acting really scummy" or "I didn't like his tantrum/outburst" and no one would bat an eye until end game, really
Why are you defending DF so hard anyway?
What’s in it for you?
|
On November 01 2017 23:27 Damdred wrote:
Hello
@oats honestly I couldnt say I have never seen him roll scum, just town in the few we have played. So guesswork is all I can say.
more gut reads Tictac is going to be town for his tone and trying to catch up without hiding his thoughts. I liked him a bit. Especially that he was takimg stances.
I have fairly subsrantial town list but no real scum feeling yet meh
Of the people posting so far, who do you like the least and why?
|
Here’s my first impression aka people I like.
Happy krogan - naturally flowing, really getting into it with a game under his belt.
A lot more active now, seems excited to play.
Good town vibes.
Shockey - I’ve played with before as scum. From what I remember he was more timid then.
I don’t sense that here. I think he’s town.
Tick tock - I like tick tock. His string of posts shows he’s interested in having an opinion.
His thoughts are flowing well.
He’s a town lean.
|
On November 01 2017 23:40 Conversion wrote:Show nested quote +On November 01 2017 23:25 ruXxar wrote:On November 01 2017 22:59 Conversion wrote:On November 01 2017 22:55 happykrogan wrote:On November 01 2017 22:37 Conversion wrote:On November 01 2017 22:36 Conversion wrote:
the problemI have with the scumread of “DF is attacking anyone possible” is that he could have just saved himself the effort and pushed me exactly how he pushed me last game and most likely started a wagon. my play hasn’t differed too wildly (as pointed out by krogan), so why would he waste time throwing shade at other people when he has two very good lynch targets he can focus on (me/shockey) EBWOP The best explanation I can think of right now is that he doesn't want to follow thread sentiment because it could cause problems later in the game. The thing is, Shockey is the thread sentiment right now, I am not. People have me at a lazy null b/c they don't want to revisit my filter due to time or such, so it'd be a pretty safe push as a mafia. If I flip town, he could have said, "Well he was acting really scummy" or "I didn't like his tantrum/outburst" and no one would bat an eye until end game, really Why are you defending DF so hard anyway? What’s in it for you? I'm not defending DF I'm trying to explain that I don't understand/agree with you and krogan's reasons, so I'm asking questions
Doesn’t matter what you call it. You’re stifling the aggression towards DF.
Let him defend himself.
|
On November 01 2017 23:51 Damdred wrote:
If there is someone I dont like, df put together a string of posts that I just didnt feel good about at points.
I do think that the auicidal nature that conversion is approaching every conversation right now hes probably just going to be town.
Like rayn and I had this talk maybe a year ago? there is this point where you just basically tell town to go fuck thwmselves and it comes off as town.
and conversion is coming off that way to me.
But I got way off track with that post meh
I agree about DF.
About conversion... the jury is still out.
He was never this edgy as town. This game and the last is not how I remember town conversion playing.
|
On November 02 2017 03:05 Oatsmaster wrote:Show nested quote +On November 02 2017 01:06 Tictock wrote:
Ok got through page 15.
I think I'm warming up to Conv a little more, he seems to be sticking to his guns despite the pressure. I'll give him the Town lean back.
I'm a tad disappointed to have nothing new from the Damer bros. They seem like the caliber of player that I prefer to take a wait and see approach with though.
Mixed bag about Oats. I felt like so had a way to read him a long time ago but his strong scum game last game makes me want to hold off. He is so all over the place right now that I'm kinda just scratching my head.
HF having RL issues explains him being a bit lacking but don't give him a full pass, he can be a slippery scum player. This HF read is really bad. Tick tock thinks HF is scummy, but doesn't want to commit to his read based on out of game stuff which is not relevant to HFs alignment. But still keeps him open as a lynch option
This post is bad and you should feel bad.
|
On November 02 2017 03:44 Oatsmaster wrote:Show nested quote +On November 02 2017 03:40 ruXxar wrote:On November 02 2017 03:05 Oatsmaster wrote:On November 02 2017 01:06 Tictock wrote:
Ok got through page 15.
I think I'm warming up to Conv a little more, he seems to be sticking to his guns despite the pressure. I'll give him the Town lean back.
I'm a tad disappointed to have nothing new from the Damer bros. They seem like the caliber of player that I prefer to take a wait and see approach with though.
Mixed bag about Oats. I felt like so had a way to read him a long time ago but his strong scum game last game makes me want to hold off. He is so all over the place right now that I'm kinda just scratching my head.
HF having RL issues explains him being a bit lacking but don't give him a full pass, he can be a slippery scum player. This HF read is really bad. Tick tock thinks HF is scummy, but doesn't want to commit to his read based on out of game stuff which is not relevant to HFs alignment. But still keeps him open as a lynch option This post is bad and you should feel bad. Alright dude, totally gonna feel bad because you told me to
You nitpick on one little tiny itsy bitsy sentence of all the posts the guy makes and you blow it up like front page news and calls him mafia.
Great detective work there.
|
On November 02 2017 03:49 darthfoley wrote:Show nested quote +On November 01 2017 23:57 ruXxar wrote:On November 01 2017 23:51 Damdred wrote:
If there is someone I dont like, df put together a string of posts that I just didnt feel good about at points.
I do think that the auicidal nature that conversion is approaching every conversation right now hes probably just going to be town.
Like rayn and I had this talk maybe a year ago? there is this point where you just basically tell town to go fuck thwmselves and it comes off as town.
and conversion is coming off that way to me.
But I got way off track with that post meh I agree about DF. About conversion... the jury is still out. He was never this edgy as town. This game and the last is not how I remember town conversion playing. Conversion wasn't edgy at all last game. He was wishy washy and non-committal as hell which is how I caught him. His play from last game and this game are much different.
Different, yet not similar to how I remember town conversion playing.
Doesn't matter either way, I don't think the guy is mafia.
|
On November 02 2017 03:53 darthfoley wrote:
It's really interesting how quickly this faux wagon built up on me. Gotta reread those pages and see who's legit and who's not. Pretty confident that Krogan is just uber town though
Faux wagon? You look legit scummy.
|
On November 02 2017 03:54 darthfoley wrote:Show nested quote +On November 02 2017 03:53 ruXxar wrote:On November 02 2017 03:49 darthfoley wrote:On November 01 2017 23:57 ruXxar wrote:On November 01 2017 23:51 Damdred wrote:
If there is someone I dont like, df put together a string of posts that I just didnt feel good about at points.
I do think that the auicidal nature that conversion is approaching every conversation right now hes probably just going to be town.
Like rayn and I had this talk maybe a year ago? there is this point where you just basically tell town to go fuck thwmselves and it comes off as town.
and conversion is coming off that way to me.
But I got way off track with that post meh I agree about DF. About conversion... the jury is still out. He was never this edgy as town. This game and the last is not how I remember town conversion playing. Conversion wasn't edgy at all last game. He was wishy washy and non-committal as hell which is how I caught him. His play from last game and this game are much different. Different, yet not similar to how I remember town conversion playing. Doesn't matter either way, I don't think the guy is mafia. The jury is still out but you don't think the guy is mafia? So the jury is in? lolwat
Yes, the bickering between him and shockey was enough for me.
Either they're both scum or theyre both town.
|
On November 02 2017 03:59 Oatsmaster wrote:Show nested quote +On November 02 2017 03:59 ruXxar wrote:On November 02 2017 03:54 darthfoley wrote:On November 02 2017 03:53 ruXxar wrote:On November 02 2017 03:49 darthfoley wrote:On November 01 2017 23:57 ruXxar wrote:On November 01 2017 23:51 Damdred wrote:
If there is someone I dont like, df put together a string of posts that I just didnt feel good about at points.
I do think that the auicidal nature that conversion is approaching every conversation right now hes probably just going to be town.
Like rayn and I had this talk maybe a year ago? there is this point where you just basically tell town to go fuck thwmselves and it comes off as town.
and conversion is coming off that way to m e.
But I got way off track with that post meh I agree about DF. About conversion... the jury is still out. He was never this edgy as town. This game and the last is not how I remember town conversion playing. Conversion wasn't edgy at all last game. He was wishy washy and non-committal as hell which is how I caught him. His play from last game and this game are much different. Different, yet not similar to how I remember town conversion playing. Doesn't matter either way, I don't think the guy is mafia. The jury is still out but you don't think the guy is mafia? So the jury is in? lolwat Yes, the bickering between him and shockey was enough for me. Either they're both scum or theyre both town. tell me why you think that ticktoc is confirmed town?
On November 01 2017 23:44 ruXxar wrote:
Tick tock - I like tick tock. His string of posts shows he’s interested in having an opinion.
His thoughts are flowing well.
He’s a town lean.
I like his tone.
Light hearted and jovial, the same way I play when I'm excited to roll town.
His reads are good and consistent on HF and Shockey.
Reads the game pretty much the same way I do, which makes it look like he doesn't have a whacky agenda.
Explains his reads so that you can see where he's coming from with his thought process.
|
On November 02 2017 04:12 ShoCkeyy wrote:Show nested quote +On November 02 2017 03:59 ruXxar wrote:On November 02 2017 03:54 darthfoley wrote:On November 02 2017 03:53 ruXxar wrote:On November 02 2017 03:49 darthfoley wrote:On November 01 2017 23:57 ruXxar wrote:On November 01 2017 23:51 Damdred wrote:
If there is someone I dont like, df put together a string of posts that I just didnt feel good about at points.
I do think that the auicidal nature that conversion is approaching every conversation right now hes probably just going to be town.
Like rayn and I had this talk maybe a year ago? there is this point where you just basically tell town to go fuck thwmselves and it comes off as town.
and conversion is coming off that way to me.
But I got way off track with that post meh I agree about DF. About conversion... the jury is still out. He was never this edgy as town. This game and the last is not how I remember town conversion playing. Conversion wasn't edgy at all last game. He was wishy washy and non-committal as hell which is how I caught him. His play from last game and this game are much different. Different, yet not similar to how I remember town conversion playing. Doesn't matter either way, I don't think the guy is mafia. The jury is still out but you don't think the guy is mafia? So the jury is in? lolwat Yes, the bickering between him and shockey was enough for me. Either they're both scum or theyre both town. I read this as "I still haven't made a decision, so let me claim both". What makes the bickering between us aligned some how? lol
I've called you town, and I'm now calling conversion town.
It means you're both town.
What I mean by my "both scum" statement is that the only time I've seen people attack each other like that in that manner where is when the both are scum, not as Scum v Town.
Pretty much what it was like when I and rsoul bussed each other as scum.
|
On November 02 2017 04:10 darthfoley wrote:Show nested quote +On November 02 2017 04:09 ruXxar wrote:On November 02 2017 03:59 Oatsmaster wrote:On November 02 2017 03:59 ruXxar wrote:On November 02 2017 03:54 darthfoley wrote:On November 02 2017 03:53 ruXxar wrote:On November 02 2017 03:49 darthfoley wrote:On November 01 2017 23:57 ruXxar wrote:On November 01 2017 23:51 Damdred wrote:
If there is someone I dont like, df put together a string of posts that I just didnt feel good about at points.
I do think that the auicidal nature that conversion is approaching every conversation right now hes probably just going to be town.
Like rayn and I had this talk maybe a year ago? there is this point where you just basically tell town to go fuck thwmselves and it comes off as town.
and conversion is coming off that way to m e.
But I got way off track with that post meh I agree about DF. About conversion... the jury is still out. He was never this edgy as town. This game and the last is not how I remember town conversion playing. Conversion wasn't edgy at all last game. He was wishy washy and non-committal as hell which is how I caught him. His play from last game and this game are much different. Different, yet not similar to how I remember town conversion playing. Doesn't matter either way, I don't think the guy is mafia. The jury is still out but you don't think the guy is mafia? So the jury is in? lolwat Yes, the bickering between him and shockey was enough for me. Either they're both scum or theyre both town. tell me why you think that ticktoc is confirmed town? On November 01 2017 23:44 ruXxar wrote:
Tick tock - I like tick tock. His string of posts shows he’s interested in having an opinion.
His thoughts are flowing well.
He’s a town lean.
I like his tone. Light hearted and jovial, the same way I play when I'm excited to roll town. His reads are good and consistent on HF and Shockey. Reads the game pretty much the same way I do, which makes it look like he doesn't have a whacky agenda. Explains his reads so that you can see where he's coming from with his thought process. You don't see lighthearted or jovial
On November 02 2017 04:13 Conversion wrote:Show nested quote +On November 02 2017 04:10 darthfoley wrote:On November 02 2017 04:09 ruXxar wrote:On November 02 2017 03:59 Oatsmaster wrote:On November 02 2017 03:59 ruXxar wrote:On November 02 2017 03:54 darthfoley wrote:On November 02 2017 03:53 ruXxar wrote:On November 02 2017 03:49 darthfoley wrote:On November 01 2017 23:57 ruXxar wrote:On November 01 2017 23:51 Damdred wrote:
If there is someone I dont like, df put together a string of posts that I just didnt feel good about at points.
I do think that the auicidal nature that conversion is approaching every conversation right now hes probably just going to be town.
Like rayn and I had this talk maybe a year ago? there is this point where you just basically tell town to go fuck thwmselves and it comes off as town.
and conversion is coming off that way to m e.
But I got way off track with that post meh I agree about DF. About conversion... the jury is still out. He was never this edgy as town. This game and the last is not how I remember town conversion playing. Conversion wasn't edgy at all last game. He was wishy washy and non-committal as hell which is how I caught him. His play from last game and this game are much different. Different, yet not similar to how I remember town conversion playing. Doesn't matter either way, I don't think the guy is mafia. The jury is still out but you don't think the guy is mafia? So the jury is in? lolwat Yes, the bickering between him and shockey was enough for me. Either they're both scum or theyre both town. tell me why you think that ticktoc is confirmed town? On November 01 2017 23:44 ruXxar wrote:
Tick tock - I like tick tock. His string of posts shows he’s interested in having an opinion.
His thoughts are flowing well.
He’s a town lean.
I like his tone. Light hearted and jovial, the same way I play when I'm excited to roll town. His reads are good and consistent on HF and Shockey. Reads the game pretty much the same way I do, which makes it look like he doesn't have a whacky agenda. Explains his reads so that you can see where he's coming from with his thought process. You don't see lighthearted or jovial agreed. your entire back and forth with me was anything but lighthearted or jovial also telling someone you're going to vote them until they admit they were wrong seems the opposite of that as well..
I invite you to read the first 2 pages of my filter.
|
On November 02 2017 04:19 Oatsmaster wrote:Show nested quote +On November 02 2017 04:18 ruXxar wrote:On November 02 2017 04:10 darthfoley wrote:On November 02 2017 04:09 ruXxar wrote:On November 02 2017 03:59 Oatsmaster wrote:On November 02 2017 03:59 ruXxar wrote:On November 02 2017 03:54 darthfoley wrote:On November 02 2017 03:53 ruXxar wrote:On November 02 2017 03:49 darthfoley wrote:On November 01 2017 23:57 ruXxar wrote:
[quote]
I agree about DF.
About conversion... the jury is still out.
He was never this edgy as town. This game and the last is not how I remember town conversion playing. Conversion wasn't edgy at all last game. He was wishy washy and non-committal as hell which is how I caught him. His play from last game and this game are much different. Different, yet not similar to how I remember town conversion playing. Doesn't matter either way, I don't think the guy is mafia. The jury is still out but you don't think the guy is mafia? So the jury is in? lolwat Yes, the bickering between him and shockey was enough for me. Either they're both scum or theyre both town. tell me why you think that ticktoc is confirmed town? On November 01 2017 23:44 ruXxar wrote:
Tick tock - I like tick tock. His string of posts shows he’s interested in having an opinion.
His thoughts are flowing well.
He’s a town lean.
I like his tone. Light hearted and jovial, the same way I play when I'm excited to roll town. His reads are good and consistent on HF and Shockey. Reads the game pretty much the same way I do, which makes it look like he doesn't have a whacky agenda. Explains his reads so that you can see where he's coming from with his thought process. You don't see lighthearted or jovial On November 02 2017 04:13 Conversion wrote:On November 02 2017 04:10 darthfoley wrote:On November 02 2017 04:09 ruXxar wrote:On November 02 2017 03:59 Oatsmaster wrote:On November 02 2017 03:59 ruXxar wrote:On November 02 2017 03:54 darthfoley wrote:On November 02 2017 03:53 ruXxar wrote:On November 02 2017 03:49 darthfoley wrote:
[quote]
Conversion wasn't edgy at all last game. He was wishy washy and non-committal as hell which is how I caught him. His play from last game and this game are much different. Different, yet not similar to how I remember town conversion playing. Doesn't matter either way, I don't think the guy is mafia. The jury is still out but you don't think the guy is mafia? So the jury is in? lolwat Yes, the bickering between him and shockey was enough for me. Either they're both scum or theyre both town. tell me why you think that ticktoc is confirmed town? On November 01 2017 23:44 ruXxar wrote:
Tick tock - I like tick tock. His string of posts shows he’s interested in having an opinion.
His thoughts are flowing well.
He’s a town lean.
I like his tone. Light hearted and jovial, the same way I play when I'm excited to roll town. His reads are good and consistent on HF and Shockey. Reads the game pretty much the same way I do, which makes it look like he doesn't have a whacky agenda. Explains his reads so that you can see where he's coming from with his thought process. You don't see lighthearted or jovial agreed. your entire back and forth with me was anything but lighthearted or jovial also telling someone you're going to vote them until they admit they were wrong seems the opposite of that as well.. I invite you to read the first 2 pages of my filter. Yeah dude, the first 2 hours of the game totally means your entire game.
What's your point?
|
On November 02 2017 04:21 Oatsmaster wrote:Show nested quote +On November 02 2017 04:14 ruXxar wrote:On November 02 2017 04:12 ShoCkeyy wrote:On November 02 2017 03:59 ruXxar wrote:On November 02 2017 03:54 darthfoley wrote:On November 02 2017 03:53 ruXxar wrote:On November 02 2017 03:49 darthfoley wrote:On November 01 2017 23:57 ruXxar wrote:On November 01 2017 23:51 Damdred wrote:
If there is someone I dont like, df put together a string of posts that I just didnt feel good about at points.
I do think that the auicidal nature that conversion is approaching every conversation right now hes probably just going to be town.
Like rayn and I had this talk maybe a year ago? there is this point where you just basically tell town to go fuck thwmselves and it comes off as town.
and conversion is coming off that way to me.
But I got way off track with that post meh I agree about DF. About conversion... the jury is still out. He was never this edgy as town. This game and the last is not how I remember town conversion playing. Conversion wasn't edgy at all last game. He was wishy washy and non-committal as hell which is how I caught him. His play from last game and this game are much different. Different, yet not similar to how I remember town conversion playing. Doesn't matter either way, I don't think the guy is mafia. The jury is still out but you don't think the guy is mafia? So the jury is in? lolwat Yes, the bickering between him and shockey was enough for me. Either they're both scum or theyre both town. I read this as "I still haven't made a decision, so let me claim both". What makes the bickering between us aligned some how? lol I've called you town, and I'm now calling conversion town. It means you're both town. What I mean by my "both scum" statement is that the only time I've seen people attack each other like that in that manner where is when the both are scum, not as Scum v Town. Pretty much what it was like when I and rsoul bussed each other as scum. Wait wait wait. Didn't you say you agreed with tick tocks read on shockey's? Ticktock thinks shockey's is mafia but you think he's town.
No I don't agree, but I understand his reasoning.
|
TT thinks shockey is scum.
I think shockey is lynch bait.
|
If I had no prior experience with shockey I would most likely also call him scum.
|
On November 02 2017 04:31 Oatsmaster wrote:Show nested quote +On November 02 2017 04:25 ruXxar wrote:
If I had no prior experience with shockey I would most likely also call him scum. Not relevant. 1. You claim to be "light-hearted and jovial" when in fact since this game got outta the honeymoon phase you have been anything but. 2. Town read of ticktock doesn't have a good basis 3. List of useless townreads halfway into day 1 that doesn't engage anyone or actually advance the thread but still looks useful
1) I did not claim otherwise.
2) That's your opinion. I disagree.
3) Again you're picking one post and ignoring my engagement with conversion.
|
On November 02 2017 04:41 Oatsmaster wrote:Show nested quote +On November 02 2017 04:34 ruXxar wrote:On November 02 2017 04:31 Oatsmaster wrote:On November 02 2017 04:25 ruXxar wrote:
If I had no prior experience with shockey I would most likely also call him scum. Not relevant. 1. You claim to be "light-hearted and jovial" when in fact since this game got outta the honeymoon phase you have been anything but. 2. Town read of ticktock doesn't have a good basis 3. List of useless townreads halfway into day 1 that doesn't engage anyone or actually advance the thread but still looks useful 1) I did not claim otherwise. 2) That's your opinion. I disagree. 3) Again you're picking one post and ignoring my engagement with conversion. ????? Why do I care about your engagement with conversion when he did something extremely stupid? And your conclusion is that hes town. Where are the scum reads?
Because you love taking thing out of context and blowing it up.
You're clamoring for a leg to stand on to call me mafia, and ignoring everything else I've done.
Thats bad scum hunting by every standard.
The post you chose to point out is not even mafia indicative as many people have posted lists.
Besides, your accusation is flat out wrong, I have engaged with multiple people.
I would take you more seriously if you had some credible arguments, but right now you're just grasping at straws.
|
On November 02 2017 04:48 darthfoley wrote:
Yea I wanna hear who ruxx thinks is scum. And other people if possible
Sure. Right now you are my top scum read.
1) You're being wishy washy trying to coast by. Casting shade and town reads around you pretty lightly.
You're keeping every option open, snaking your way around from read to read.
2) This post is incredibly nitpicky and trying to infuse meaning where there is none. One of the worst posts in the game.
It's very over explainy and trying to siphon meaning out of very word instead of trying to understand the overall message of the post.
On November 01 2017 11:10 darthfoley wrote:
I dislike ruxxar's early game filter. Super fluff with no substance. Yea, sure, lots of people are posting fluff kinda. But ruxxar's gives me the vibes of feigning activity to seem interested. It's pretty easy to do early game especially, when people are dicking about.
Besides that, I have no idea why he feels the need to dictate how Damerion votes, the aggressiveness of his vote, and the subsequent commentary
Let me break down the bolded sentence for you
1) "Don't get me wrong" = apologetic, not trying to tread on anyone's toes, like scumversion last game
2) "I like your more confident approach" implies a town lean of some sort, with buddy potential
3) So he likes the confident approach, BUT it's throwing him off because it's so different from last game. So you like it... but it's throwing you off?
4) It's also "a bit too much over the top and feels forced" implying it's scummy.
So to conclude, Ruxxar likes Damerion's aggressive and confident play even though it's throwing him off but it's over the top and feels forced. So why do you like the approach if you are going to call it scummy one line later? This is a whole lot of nothing burger
Besides you there's a few people on my to watch list:
Oats - for the same reason of also blowing things up and putting emphasis on worthless fact as if they were gold and had some divine scum meaning.
Damerion - I detected a change in meta behavior, need more posts to evaluate.
Shockey - I know I'm biased due to meta. The threshold for where that meta no longer holds is very thin. But still resides as town. Also the bickering with conversion tips in his favor.
HF - His damerion vote with no explanation was a red flag, but his later followup was ok. He's awfully quiet this game, but he has an excuse. Otherwise keeping an eye on him as his meta is different from last game. A bit more laid back.
Not sure how to interpret it, will need to wait until he makes a real push.
|
|
|
|
|
|
EPT
