|
On August 14 2017 06:22 geript wrote:Show nested quote +On August 14 2017 06:15 raynpelikoneet wrote:On August 14 2017 05:59 geript wrote:
To be specific:
Judges nominate 3 people for a power-up. But instead of choosing 3 people they think are town, they choose only 2 people they think are town and 1 guy they think is scum. Then, they nominate the guy they think is scum for lynch with 2 other people they think are scum so we get an outside opinion on things. Even if they can't make an argument. Judges - as far as i know - decide who gets the "power up". I think judges should always nominate the dude they give the power up also up for lynch, so instead of 3 people we have only 2 people to decide from (unless the judges are shit ofc). Show nested quote +The Rules
Judges (3): The judges win when all saboteurs have been eliminated from the contest. Saboteurs cheating to win MS Paint-Off Mafia would reflect poorly on them and the producers. They cannot be lynched or killed. They will have a separate QT and may not post in the game thread. The judges will select 3 top artists, and 2-3 bottom artists to be voted between each day phase.
Honest Contestants (10-16): The honest contestants win when all saboteurs have been eliminated from the contest. There are no power roles in this game. Basically, Judges choose 2 different groups: a group of 3 one of which gets a power-up and a group of 3 one of which gets lynched. Town votes on both groups. The judges can include a person in both groups as a way of saying "I think this guy is scum." Plus, since they'll be less likely to give scum a powerup if they are only 'nominating' 2 people instead of 3. It's kinda mediocre on D1 since in hours 25-48 we vote for the powerup and don't get the lynch list until hour 49 (if i'm reading it correctly). But it should be pretty obvious that 2 guys are way townier than the third. Kinda like the old nomination game.
yes, what i underlined was what i was thinking.
|
|
|
why is NAI "probably scum"?
|
I mean you just said so in three words...
|
On August 14 2017 06:23 geript wrote:
NIA. Probably scum...
|
![[image loading]](http://i.imgur.com/Ur5BNAh.jpg)
goodnighty guys.
|
Holyflare i dont think ritoky is mafia.
|
Actually i am playing sleep and work until 5pm or so.
Tumblewood made the worst post in the game.
|
Reading the setup is a useful talent toi have before making setup analysis, or especially before accusing other people for making bad plans.
|
Koshi read this; here is what you guys need to do. whoever will win the prize you guys nominate them also for lynch target. That way we know there is someone who will not be lynched and instead of 3 possible wagons we only have 2. Chances of lynching mafia are better that way and there is less chaos that way.
|
Ofc it's not bad. I wonder where you got the "no mafia nk's" you were so proud of. Ah, seems like i was too tired to properly read what Artanis posted yesterday. 
But seriously your reads are based on terrible things that don't make anyone anything and i won't play your annoyance game. I am going to think if what i read earlier makes Tumblewood mafia or not and just that you can keep shouting the crap you are doing atm not post anything until tonight.
|
On August 14 2017 21:42 Holyflare wrote:
Now if I ever get vig you will die. There's nothing you can actually do to change my mind at this point. You've had more than adequate time to shape up and have done nothing.
Look how much i care.
|
On August 14 2017 21:49 Holyflare wrote:
Does this do anything to solve the game rayn? Why are you more concerned with Koshi giving us a mafia read (which is what them putting people up for lynch is???) than actually having a single read in the entire game?
Why do you care, you have decided i am mafia already so just keep telling that to people. Maybe you should read what i was trying to plan before you start yelling about it, i never asked Koshi to give us a mafia read (except that one post where i misread what geript wrote -- i wasn't actually saying what geript was).
I have reads, a couple of town reads. Unlike you i don't make up mafia reads based on garbage. Funnily enough i just realized you catch me in every game we play nowadays on D1, regardless of what alignment either of us is. 
|
Initially you said so we'd have one person to lynch. Which I think is stupid. Vote count analysis is the basic mafia game.
No i didn't, i said "the idea is the judges will nominate 2 ppl and the one they give the power so we have one dude noone is gonna vote." which is 2 lynch wagons instead of 3. It's not stupid, in fact it is so OP Artanis decided to remove it from the game.... That in itself should probably tell you something about if it is stupid or not...
Because me not giving reads doesn't make me anything. It is that fucking simple. I have until tomorrow night to decide who i think is mafia. Your read on ritoky is also garbage because the Jealous thing was obviously at least a half joke and "he got mad over being a clock in someone's picture" is a terrible reason to call anyone mafia. In fact ritoky's, what to call it... un-tryhardness probably makes him town. geript can also be town for now since he tried to break the game.
Cake always thinks i am mafia when she is town so i don't see a reason why she wouldn't do that as mafia. It's actually quite annoying especially when the reasoning is something she didn't even properly read in the first place. It's like Xatalos annoying. For the record there are probably 0 games where Cake has read the OP as any alignment so there goes that dumbtell theory, i don't even know what the Jealous one is.
I agree with whoever said Jealous should post properly. I don't care if he is posting reads in the pictures, posting reads doesn't make people town, because almost any mafia nowadays is not stupid enough to not post reads or do anything and get caught by it. At least i can't figure out motivation of post from a picture in a same way than i can from written text, and i would like him to play properly.
Then there is Tumblewood who started questioning Cake (which i liked) and then ended up with "well i didn't even think that makes you anything" which i hated. Into "let's be town everyone" post. I have seen Tumblewood do the same sort of questioning before and it didn't end like that. rn i am too lazy and sleepy to dig up more into that, gotta eat and sleep first.
I almost have a read on Hopelesswonder but i don't. I most likely will though when he posts more.
You can be anything and i tend to not really care unless you do something scummy. You will probably die early anyways in case you are town. But you won't bully me into doing something i don't want to do, I will talk to you when you have something i don't find badly reasoned.
Everyone else has not done anything i can make something of.
|
I always assumed it was 3 and every post of mine implies so.
|
On August 14 2017 22:53 Holyflare wrote:
Ritoky not giving a shit does not make him town at all. THAT is a terrible read.
I am not saying he is not givng a shit, because i think he gives a shit.
On August 14 2017 22:53 Conversion wrote:Show nested quote +On August 14 2017 22:45 raynpelikoneet wrote: Initially you said so we'd have one person to lynch. Which I think is stupid. Vote count analysis is the basic mafia game. No i didn't, i said "the idea is the judges will nominate 2 ppl and the one they give the power so we have one dude noone is gonna vote." which is 2 lynch wagons instead of 3. It's not stupid, in fact it is so OP Artanis decided to remove it from the game.... That in itself should probably tell you something about if it is stupid or not... Because me not giving reads doesn't make me anything. It is that fucking simple. I have until tomorrow night to decide who i think is mafia. Your read on ritoky is also garbage because the Jealous thing was obviously at least a half joke and "he got mad over being a clock in someone's picture" is a terrible reason to call anyone mafia. In fact ritoky's, what to call it... un-tryhardness probably makes him town. geript can also be town for now since he tried to break the game. Cake always thinks i am mafia when she is town so i don't see a reason why she wouldn't do that as mafia. It's actually quite annoying especially when the reasoning is something she didn't even properly read in the first place. It's like Xatalos annoying. For the record there are probably 0 games where Cake has read the OP as any alignment so there goes that dumbtell theory, i don't even know what the Jealous one is. I agree with whoever said Jealous should post properly. I don't care if he is posting reads in the pictures, posting reads doesn't make people town, because almost any mafia nowadays is not stupid enough to not post reads or do anything and get caught by it. At least i can't figure out motivation of post from a picture in a same way than i can from written text, and i would like him to play properly. Then there is Tumblewood who started questioning Cake (which i liked) and then ended up with "well i didn't even think that makes you anything" which i hated. Into "let's be town everyone" post. I have seen Tumblewood do the same sort of questioning before and it didn't end like that. rn i am too lazy and sleepy to dig up more into that, gotta eat and sleep first. I almost have a read on Hopelesswonder but i don't. I most likely will though when he posts more.
You can be anything and i tend to not really care unless you do something scummy. You will probably die early anyways in case you are town. But you won't bully me into doing something i don't want to do, I will talk to you when you have something i don't find badly reasoned. Everyone else has not done anything i can make something of. do you mind me asking how you almost have a read on someone who only has two posts? just curious
I think i have a good grasp in how he approaches the game.
|
On August 14 2017 22:55 Holyflare wrote:
I also think your reads don't make any sense at all. You effectively say this is mafia tw but don't call him mafia.
You say you don't like his conclusion that it makes cake nothing but your read on cake is also NOTHING. You liked his questioning and read it and have no conclusion on her for it but then say it's bad that someone else doesn't have a conclusion on it. Then you think a baddy mafia ditches all his reads and calls everyone blindly town just after?
No.
It just doesn't add up rayn.
bla bla stop twisting my words it's fucking annoying. Go do something else now. I'm gonna take a nap.
|
On August 15 2017 05:39 ritoky wrote:
my top 3 would have always had hopeless and geript.
Yes. Also holyflare is mafia.
|
Koshi if you put me into the lynch pule i will lynch myself to prove my point but Holyflare is always mafia.
|
Not yet, cant quote on phone. I am abusing the gamd mechanics and fuck the hosts.
|
|
|
|
|
|
EPT
