|
On July 15 2017 18:11 emperorchampion wrote:
Something maybe kinda stupid that I was thinking about: how genuine is koshi's read of damdred based off of damdred 's read of geript. I assume there was some bullshit in damdy's read since he knew they were town based on masons.
Rayns seemed more genuine but idk
On July 15 2017 18:25 emperorchampion wrote:Show nested quote +On July 13 2017 19:23 Koshi wrote:
Damdred tried to explain why geript is town and gave that read to the thread. =good stuff. Trying to convince somebody is town with reasoning that another person can understand is a townie treat. Him being extremely confident about it is also more likely town over mafia because mafia is afraid of showing TMI.
Damdred is town.
People who pretend to have a lot of reads but are not sharing them with the thread:
rsoultin
PS to rayn: he is talking about ruxxar Like this post is exactly wrong, maybe damdy can chime in more, but I assume there was some tmi in the read. Mafia motivation is to fit in, buddy rayn for same reads.
Did Koshi really know that Damdred / geript were masons at the time he wrote that post ? If yes then it's really damning
|
On July 20 2017 03:09 Rels wrote:Show nested quote +On July 15 2017 18:11 emperorchampion wrote:
Something maybe kinda stupid that I was thinking about: how genuine is koshi's read of damdred based off of damdred 's read of geript. I assume there was some bullshit in damdy's read since he knew they were town based on masons.
Rayns seemed more genuine but idk Show nested quote +On July 15 2017 18:25 emperorchampion wrote:On July 13 2017 19:23 Koshi wrote:
Damdred tried to explain why geript is town and gave that read to the thread. =good stuff. Trying to convince somebody is town with reasoning that another person can understand is a townie treat. Him being extremely confident about it is also more likely town over mafia because mafia is afraid of showing TMI.
Damdred is town.
People who pretend to have a lot of reads but are not sharing them with the thread:
rsoultin
PS to rayn: he is talking about ruxxar Like this post is exactly wrong, maybe damdy can chime in more, but I assume there was some tmi in the read. Mafia motivation is to fit in, buddy rayn for same reads. Did Koshi really know that Damdred / geript were masons at the time he wrote that post ? If yes then it's really damning
But he didn't ? It's during the first 24 hours of the game. Why are you saying Koshi knew Damdred was mason ?
|
On July 20 2017 03:13 Holyflare wrote:Show nested quote +On July 20 2017 03:12 Rels wrote:On July 20 2017 03:09 Rels wrote:On July 15 2017 18:11 emperorchampion wrote:
Something maybe kinda stupid that I was thinking about: how genuine is koshi's read of damdred based off of damdred 's read of geript. I assume there was some bullshit in damdy's read since he knew they were town based on masons.
Rayns seemed more genuine but idk On July 15 2017 18:25 emperorchampion wrote:On July 13 2017 19:23 Koshi wrote:
Damdred tried to explain why geript is town and gave that read to the thread. =good stuff. Trying to convince somebody is town with reasoning that another person can understand is a townie treat. Him being extremely confident about it is also more likely town over mafia because mafia is afraid of showing TMI.
Damdred is town.
People who pretend to have a lot of reads but are not sharing them with the thread:
rsoultin
PS to rayn: he is talking about ruxxar Like this post is exactly wrong, maybe damdy can chime in more, but I assume there was some tmi in the read. Mafia motivation is to fit in, buddy rayn for same reads. Did Koshi really know that Damdred / geript were masons at the time he wrote that post ? If yes then it's really damning But he didn't ? It's during the first 24 hours of the game. Why are you saying Koshi knew Damdred was mason ? he's saying that Koshi knows Damdred is town and has tmi so koshi made that read to fit that
Then what does this sentence mean ?
"I assume there was some bullshit in damdy's read since he knew they were town based on masons. "
|
oh I get it now. He's saying Damdred's read on geript was bad, and Koshi thinking the read was good is scummy.
|
weird thing to say. EC did you find Damdred's read of geript bad ? It's not BS just because it's fabricated. Actually it's not fabricated since he knows geript is town, he can find stuff that makes him town with less doubts. So what made you think Damdred's read was bad ?
|
On July 20 2017 03:18 emperorchampion wrote:Show nested quote +On July 20 2017 03:14 Holyflare wrote:On July 20 2017 03:13 emperorchampion wrote:On July 20 2017 03:08 Holyflare wrote:
My two wagon choices are EC and Vivax What reasons do you have for thinking rels is town? his sl read just now seemed out of the blue and honest and I liked it and the fact that he's still trying to solve the game when there's literally just us three in the thread he's also scum reading vivax which is the correct thing to do and voting him which you're not even sticking to because you're mafia D: Idk about you, but it's just too coincidental that three players with poor filters, also happen to save each other, then come around on town reads on each other out of the blue. None of them have as primary lynch targets. It was looking for a while like rels was gonna get bussed. When I try interacting with sl and tumble about rels: not a single thing.
mafia doesn't work like that. Scum team is not likely to show face like that. It can happen. But more likely than not it doesn't.
Andyou saying I have a poor filter when 90% of yours is targeted on questions that doesn't do anything + dumb reasons to scumread me is funny
|
On July 20 2017 03:33 emperorchampion wrote:
2. Rels clearly thinks he looks good by changing his vote at the last second, so I think your point is moot on that.
You have to be kidding.
On July 20 2017 02:54 Rels wrote:
like, in no ways that proves I'm town. But in no ways it proves I'm scum neither
|
On July 20 2017 03:34 Vivax wrote:
I don't feel that strongly about emc mafia after reading a bit of his filter. There was one thing I didn't like in particular but the bigger picture suggests town to me atm.
I think mafia can be anywhere in HF/Koshi/TW/Rels/Skynx atm. And I think Koshi is the best shot for today literally just for D1 with his minion stuff and followup lacking koshi passion even though in his later posts he starts putting in more effort.
I made a mistake replacing into the game cause I have things going on more important than mafia atm and I overestimated my will to catch up in the little time I'm not doing something else.
Why HF ? He wasn't in your last list post.
Why is Tumble more likely to be scum than before ? He aasn't in your last list post.
|
On July 20 2017 03:40 emperorchampion wrote:Show nested quote +On July 20 2017 03:35 Rels wrote:On July 20 2017 03:33 emperorchampion wrote:
2. Rels clearly thinks he looks good by changing his vote at the last second, so I think your point is moot on that. You have to be kidding. On July 20 2017 02:54 Rels wrote:
like, in no ways that proves I'm town. But in no ways it proves I'm scum neither Last night you were defending your reasons for not voting sl by saying you voted him last minute. So a good thing in your mind.
yes, I was defending against yours and HF idea that I DIDNT try to vote TW over ruxxar. I never argued out of the blue that it looked good
|
On July 20 2017 04:05 emperorchampion wrote:
I understand that association seems like a big part, but it's mostly corroborative. sl and tumble look super weak, and maybe to others rels doesn't look too bad. But from my perspective, I know his arguments are off, and he looks super scum to me.
No it doesn't make sense.
I'm not scum because I scumread Tumble but didn't vote him until the last second. It doesn't make anyone scum.
I'm not scum because of some master plan wher the scum team show face all at the same time. It almost never happens.
You say you're keeping an open mind. But I come and make good posts on Koshi and SL. Your top townread thinks you're scum because your reasons are so bad. But you're not changing. You're rigid. Probably 'cause you're scum.
|
On July 20 2017 03:21 emperorchampion wrote:Show nested quote +On July 20 2017 03:18 Rels wrote:
weird thing to say. EC did you find Damdred's read of geript bad ? It's not BS just because it's fabricated. Actually it's not fabricated since he knows geript is town, he can find stuff that makes him town with less doubts. So what made you think Damdred's read was bad ? I remember it being weird to have such a strong read early in the game off so little. The read itself is totally inconsequential to my point on koshi.
Yes it is totally consequential to your point on Koshi. It is BECAUSE you found Damdred's read weird that you found Koshi's weird scummy.
|
On July 20 2017 04:45 emperorchampion wrote:Show nested quote +On July 20 2017 02:43 emperorchampion wrote:On July 20 2017 02:40 Rels wrote:On July 20 2017 02:38 emperorchampion wrote:On July 20 2017 02:23 Rels wrote:
well seems like the game is becoming easy
SL is underwhelming but I have two things that makes me think he's town. The fact that he insta believed HF claim, when he's a scum player that tries to do sneaky stuff; I think as scum he tries to buddy HF by roleplaying the fakeclaim. And the fact that he doesn't have a read on me, he has a very hard time reading me. What do you mean by roleplaying the scum claim? I would think that believing it the easiest way to buddy. So hf is locked town for you also? I mean showing to HF hints that he knows he's fakeclaiming to appear smart. HF rapid change of reads over the last days make me think he's town How does he know it's a fake claim? Closed set up right. Rels I still don't understand this point on sl
On July 20 2017 02:45 Rels wrote:Show nested quote +On July 20 2017 02:43 emperorchampion wrote:On July 20 2017 02:40 Rels wrote:On July 20 2017 02:38 emperorchampion wrote:On July 20 2017 02:23 Rels wrote:
well seems like the game is becoming easy
SL is underwhelming but I have two things that makes me think he's town. The fact that he insta believed HF claim, when he's a scum player that tries to do sneaky stuff; I think as scum he tries to buddy HF by roleplaying the fakeclaim. And the fact that he doesn't have a read on me, he has a very hard time reading me. What do you mean by roleplaying the scum claim? I would think that believing it the easiest way to buddy. So hf is locked town for you also? I mean showing to HF hints that he knows he's fakeclaiming to appear smart. HF rapid change of reads over the last days make me think he's town How does he know it's a fake claim? Closed set up right. mmmmmmm because I'm town maybe ?
|
On July 20 2017 04:56 emperorchampion wrote:Show nested quote +On July 20 2017 04:51 Rels wrote:On July 20 2017 04:45 emperorchampion wrote:On July 20 2017 02:43 emperorchampion wrote:On July 20 2017 02:40 Rels wrote:On July 20 2017 02:38 emperorchampion wrote:On July 20 2017 02:23 Rels wrote:
well seems like the game is becoming easy
SL is underwhelming but I have two things that makes me think he's town. The fact that he insta believed HF claim, when he's a scum player that tries to do sneaky stuff; I think as scum he tries to buddy HF by roleplaying the fakeclaim. And the fact that he doesn't have a read on me, he has a very hard time reading me. What do you mean by roleplaying the scum claim? I would think that believing it the easiest way to buddy. So hf is locked town for you also? I mean showing to HF hints that he knows he's fakeclaiming to appear smart. HF rapid change of reads over the last days make me think he's town How does he know it's a fake claim? Closed set up right. Rels I still don't understand this point on sl On July 20 2017 02:45 Rels wrote:On July 20 2017 02:43 emperorchampion wrote:On July 20 2017 02:40 Rels wrote:On July 20 2017 02:38 emperorchampion wrote:On July 20 2017 02:23 Rels wrote:
well seems like the game is becoming easy
SL is underwhelming but I have two things that makes me think he's town. The fact that he insta believed HF claim, when he's a scum player that tries to do sneaky stuff; I think as scum he tries to buddy HF by roleplaying the fakeclaim. And the fact that he doesn't have a read on me, he has a very hard time reading me. What do you mean by roleplaying the scum claim? I would think that believing it the easiest way to buddy. So hf is locked town for you also? I mean showing to HF hints that he knows he's fakeclaiming to appear smart. HF rapid change of reads over the last days make me think he's town How does he know it's a fake claim? Closed set up right. mmmmmmm because I'm town maybe ? How does sl know it's a fake claim?
Because he would know it's a red check on a townie.
|
On July 20 2017 04:58 emperorchampion wrote:
ok I get it know lol, but I don't think it's a great point
you can not know if it's a great point unless you've played with SL and me enough or unless you do a meta analysis. Since I assume you did neither what you think doesn't matter
|
it's like when you said I'm scummy because my VA read was just "sheep rayn". If you had played with rayn enough you would know he has (had =D) a perfect read on VA. So sheeping him is not something scummy
|
half truth and narratives and rigid
|
On July 20 2017 10:48 Tumblewood wrote:Show nested quote +On July 20 2017 09:11 Holyflare wrote:
Rsoultin was town because she complained about sexism while still giving reads and then replaced out. Aka she felt harassed enough to make it a big thread thing and leave. Don't think she'd do that as mafia but there's always a new low to reach on this website. i don't think her leaving was at all related to her alignment, just based on frustration with thread behavior. as in nai and not a tactic
disagree, ragequit is more likely to come from town than from scum. Not here it seems though
|
Vivax / Koshi are very very likely.
EC I'm having doubts. The way he's so stubborn makes me think of ruxxar last game. Dunno if he does that as scum. Gonna add that to the things I have to meta check
|
On July 20 2017 16:56 emperorchampion wrote:
I'm getting cold sweats, way too similar to the last game I payed with rels where he was scum
lol not at all. I was town leader in that game. Actually it was a perfect example of a well done bus on TW that got me endless towncred. Totally different from this current game
|
On July 20 2017 19:08 Holyflare wrote:Show nested quote +On July 19 2017 08:54 Tumblewood wrote:
skynx, vivax, sl, and rels are all realistic 2nd/3rd scummers, in roughly that order. everyone else i am 90% sure i can write off. and if koshi is town i might as well give up Show nested quote +On July 20 2017 03:27 Tumblewood wrote:
well this is holyf***e mafia all over again.
but hf, i don't think ec is scum just for doubting whether vivax is scum. it's inconsistent and all that, but i'd give him the benefit of the doubt. if it were a solid, veteran player maybe not, but i think ec has the potential to do weird flips like that as town. Show nested quote +On July 20 2017 03:38 Tumblewood wrote:On July 20 2017 03:32 Holyflare wrote:On July 20 2017 03:27 Tumblewood wrote:
well this is holyf***e mafia all over again.
but hf, i don't think ec is scum just for doubting whether vivax is scum. it's inconsistent and all that, but i'd give him the benefit of the doubt. if it were a solid, veteran player maybe not, but i think ec has the potential to do weird flips like that as town. what's this supposed to mean? in that game, vivax replaced in for superbia d3, made a couple WoT catching-up posts, and then hardly interacted with the game afterwards. a little more active than this game but not by much. Why are you voting off wagon with your scum read then?
I think he was saying Vivax was town and lackluster in the Holyflare mafia ? Or did I read that wrong. Gonna check the game
|
|
|
|
|
|
EPT
