|
I think I played this game once were I was sure artanis was a spy. but then I had to negotiate with the other towns and send him anyway and we lost =[. never send artanis/rstoulin guys
|
|
|
On January 27 2017 09:07 Half the Sky wrote:Evening lovelies, I’m resistance too, but surely someone in this bunch is capable of saying that, or frankly anything posted so far, as either alignment.  And LOL Tina, sleep is for the weak To add to the setup discussion, as someone who has played resistance before in forum and real life, I do agree with the points made by Ray, but for people new to this game, should mission 1 pass, do not assume that all three members on mission 1 are part of the resistance. At least in my experience, there’s been far too many times where people don’t re-examine the first three people and then for mission 2, they hyper-focus on player 4 that becomes the add-on.
Shit I was just about to claim cop.
Thanks for the heads up!
|
On January 27 2017 10:43 sicklucker wrote:Show nested quote +On January 27 2017 07:38 Chairman Ray wrote:On January 27 2017 07:19 Silverika wrote:
Hi all!! Who has played before? I have one time online and the first mission passed. I'd like to go on the mission since we are members of the Resistance so I'm volunteering. Also, I'll sign my posts, ika42 likely will not. Any high level missions-ones with higher numbers of people that we aren't on will be rejected by us because if one Town voice isn't there, the chances of it being all Town is not high enough to take the risk.
~SilverWolf77 I've played a few hundred games of this live, and I think I played once on TL. Yeah, if you are town, please reject mission 5 if you are not on that mission and most of the time reject mission 4 as well, but for the first three, please use your best judgement. Reason being that in mission 5, even if you think everyone on it is town, they can all just approve it and the mission goes ahead, but on the chance that at least one of them rejects, and people outside the group approves, you need to reject it. For the first three missions, if you are not in the group, please use your best judgement and approve missions you think will pass, because if you reject groups that you are not on, then mafia get to pick which mission passes. I've definitely had a lot of games thrown where town was being too cynical early game or too optimistic late game. I dont see how rejecting missions ever is a good idea for newbs
Why not?
~SilverWolf77
|
hi hello it is me
I haven't played in a resistance setup before but it seems pretty simple? seems like a pretty poor risk/reward for mafia to let a mission pass just for town cred, unless all the players are town-of-salem-tier scrubs.
btw grack that joke was pretty lame
|
On January 27 2017 11:57 Silverika wrote:Show nested quote +On January 27 2017 10:43 sicklucker wrote:On January 27 2017 07:38 Chairman Ray wrote:On January 27 2017 07:19 Silverika wrote:
Hi all!! Who has played before? I have one time online and the first mission passed. I'd like to go on the mission since we are members of the Resistance so I'm volunteering. Also, I'll sign my posts, ika42 likely will not. Any high level missions-ones with higher numbers of people that we aren't on will be rejected by us because if one Town voice isn't there, the chances of it being all Town is not high enough to take the risk.
~SilverWolf77 I've played a few hundred games of this live, and I think I played once on TL. Yeah, if you are town, please reject mission 5 if you are not on that mission and most of the time reject mission 4 as well, but for the first three, please use your best judgement. Reason being that in mission 5, even if you think everyone on it is town, they can all just approve it and the mission goes ahead, but on the chance that at least one of them rejects, and people outside the group approves, you need to reject it. For the first three missions, if you are not in the group, please use your best judgement and approve missions you think will pass, because if you reject groups that you are not on, then mafia get to pick which mission passes. I've definitely had a lot of games thrown where town was being too cynical early game or too optimistic late game. I dont see how rejecting missions ever is a good idea for newbs Why not? ~SilverWolf77
because you need to complete missions to win? wtf
|
On January 27 2017 15:46 sicklucker wrote:Show nested quote +On January 27 2017 11:57 Silverika wrote:On January 27 2017 10:43 sicklucker wrote:On January 27 2017 07:38 Chairman Ray wrote:On January 27 2017 07:19 Silverika wrote:
Hi all!! Who has played before? I have one time online and the first mission passed. I'd like to go on the mission since we are members of the Resistance so I'm volunteering. Also, I'll sign my posts, ika42 likely will not. Any high level missions-ones with higher numbers of people that we aren't on will be rejected by us because if one Town voice isn't there, the chances of it being all Town is not high enough to take the risk.
~SilverWolf77 I've played a few hundred games of this live, and I think I played once on TL. Yeah, if you are town, please reject mission 5 if you are not on that mission and most of the time reject mission 4 as well, but for the first three, please use your best judgement. Reason being that in mission 5, even if you think everyone on it is town, they can all just approve it and the mission goes ahead, but on the chance that at least one of them rejects, and people outside the group approves, you need to reject it. For the first three missions, if you are not in the group, please use your best judgement and approve missions you think will pass, because if you reject groups that you are not on, then mafia get to pick which mission passes. I've definitely had a lot of games thrown where town was being too cynical early game or too optimistic late game. I dont see how rejecting missions ever is a good idea for newbs Why not? ~SilverWolf77 because you need to complete missions to win? wtf
No shit Sherlock, but your basicly saying "have no dicussion and approve anything and everything"
So explain to me why any newbs should jsut blindly go "ok approve" without dicussion.
|
On January 27 2017 07:38 Chairman Ray wrote:Show nested quote +On January 27 2017 07:19 Silverika wrote:
Hi all!! Who has played before? I have one time online and the first mission passed. I'd like to go on the mission since we are members of the Resistance so I'm volunteering. Also, I'll sign my posts, ika42 likely will not. Any high level missions-ones with higher numbers of people that we aren't on will be rejected by us because if one Town voice isn't there, the chances of it being all Town is not high enough to take the risk.
~SilverWolf77 I've played a few hundred games of this live, and I think I played once on TL. Yeah, if you are town, please reject mission 5 if you are not on that mission and most of the time reject mission 4 as well, but for the first three, please use your best judgement. Reason being that in mission 5, even if you think everyone on it is town, they can all just approve it and the mission goes ahead, but on the chance that at least one of them rejects, and people outside the group approves, you need to reject it. For the first three missions, if you are not in the group, please use your best judgement and approve missions you think will pass, because if you reject groups that you are not on, then mafia get to pick which mission passes. I've definitely had a lot of games thrown where town was being too cynical early game or too optimistic late game.
Why do ty refer yourself as not town here?
|
On January 27 2017 15:46 sicklucker wrote:Show nested quote +On January 27 2017 11:57 Silverika wrote:On January 27 2017 10:43 sicklucker wrote:On January 27 2017 07:38 Chairman Ray wrote:On January 27 2017 07:19 Silverika wrote:
Hi all!! Who has played before? I have one time online and the first mission passed. I'd like to go on the mission since we are members of the Resistance so I'm volunteering. Also, I'll sign my posts, ika42 likely will not. Any high level missions-ones with higher numbers of people that we aren't on will be rejected by us because if one Town voice isn't there, the chances of it being all Town is not high enough to take the risk.
~SilverWolf77 I've played a few hundred games of this live, and I think I played once on TL. Yeah, if you are town, please reject mission 5 if you are not on that mission and most of the time reject mission 4 as well, but for the first three, please use your best judgement. Reason being that in mission 5, even if you think everyone on it is town, they can all just approve it and the mission goes ahead, but on the chance that at least one of them rejects, and people outside the group approves, you need to reject it. For the first three missions, if you are not in the group, please use your best judgement and approve missions you think will pass, because if you reject groups that you are not on, then mafia get to pick which mission passes. I've definitely had a lot of games thrown where town was being too cynical early game or too optimistic late game. I dont see how rejecting missions ever is a good idea for newbs Why not? ~SilverWolf77 because you need to complete missions to win? wtf
You definitely need to reject some missions if you are town.
If you are town and on a team that you think has mafia in it, or you want to see who votes it for more information, you should reject it.
If you are town not on a team, and you think there's mafia on it, or also want more information from votes, you should reject it.
If you are town on mission 5 and you are not in it, you should reject it, EVEN IF you are confident that the group is good.
|
On January 27 2017 17:08 Silverika wrote:Show nested quote +On January 27 2017 07:38 Chairman Ray wrote:On January 27 2017 07:19 Silverika wrote:
Hi all!! Who has played before? I have one time online and the first mission passed. I'd like to go on the mission since we are members of the Resistance so I'm volunteering. Also, I'll sign my posts, ika42 likely will not. Any high level missions-ones with higher numbers of people that we aren't on will be rejected by us because if one Town voice isn't there, the chances of it being all Town is not high enough to take the risk.
~SilverWolf77 I've played a few hundred games of this live, and I think I played once on TL. Yeah, if you are town, please reject mission 5 if you are not on that mission and most of the time reject mission 4 as well, but for the first three, please use your best judgement. Reason being that in mission 5, even if you think everyone on it is town, they can all just approve it and the mission goes ahead, but on the chance that at least one of them rejects, and people outside the group approves, you need to reject it. For the first three missions, if you are not in the group, please use your best judgement and approve missions you think will pass, because if you reject groups that you are not on, then mafia get to pick which mission passes. I've definitely had a lot of games thrown where town was being too cynical early game or too optimistic late game. Why do ty refer yourself as not town here?
What do you mean?
|
On January 27 2017 17:08 Silverika wrote:Show nested quote +On January 27 2017 07:38 Chairman Ray wrote:On January 27 2017 07:19 Silverika wrote:
Hi all!! Who has played before? I have one time online and the first mission passed. I'd like to go on the mission since we are members of the Resistance so I'm volunteering. Also, I'll sign my posts, ika42 likely will not. Any high level missions-ones with higher numbers of people that we aren't on will be rejected by us because if one Town voice isn't there, the chances of it being all Town is not high enough to take the risk.
~SilverWolf77 I've played a few hundred games of this live, and I think I played once on TL. Yeah, if you are town, please reject mission 5 if you are not on that mission and most of the time reject mission 4 as well, but for the first three, please use your best judgement. Reason being that in mission 5, even if you think everyone on it is town, they can all just approve it and the mission goes ahead, but on the chance that at least one of them rejects, and people outside the group approves, you need to reject it. For the first three missions, if you are not in the group, please use your best judgement and approve missions you think will pass, because if you reject groups that you are not on, then mafia get to pick which mission passes. I've definitely had a lot of games thrown where town was being too cynical early game or too optimistic late game. Why do you refer yourself as not town here?
Silverwolf corrected me on my typo cus I'm mobile
|
On January 27 2017 12:47 Tumblewood wrote:
hi hello it is me
I haven't played in a resistance setup before but it seems pretty simple? seems like a pretty poor risk/reward for mafia to let a mission pass just for town cred, unless all the players are town-of-salem-tier scrubs.
btw grack that joke was pretty lame
That's not always true, but we can talk about it if it ever comes up.
|
Ok, let's try to figure out who we want to send on the mission.
Does anyone have any preference on who they want on the mission, besides themselves?
|
Are bystanders allowed to comment?
|
On January 27 2017 17:35 sharkie wrote:
Are bystanders allowed to comment?
Nope, can't talk about this game in this thread or any other thread until it's over. If there's an obs qt, you can ask the host for it.
|
On January 27 2017 17:35 sharkie wrote:
Are bystanders allowed to comment?
No. Please stay out of the thread if you are not playing. Do not discuss this game anywhere.
There is usually a separate chat for bystanders ("observers") to comment, but since you are standing by as a replacement, you are not eligible for that either.
If you have any further questions, please contact the hosts by PM.
|
On January 27 2017 07:49 RtaniSoul wrote:The first post didn't make you conf town but in combination with the second one, we have mindmelded and I am left with no option but to consider you part of the resistance.
Care to elaborate on this a little, Artanis(?)?
|
Also as obviously confirmed town I should be on every mission. Feel free to bring the heat and fight me if you disagree. :D
|
On January 27 2017 17:15 Chairman Ray wrote:
Ok, let's try to figure out who we want to send on the mission.
Does anyone have any preference on who they want on the mission, besides themselves?
Statistics say not you. (hahaha etc.)
|
Here's the format I suggest we take btw. We have 2 real days for the leader to decide a mission.
I strongly suggest That the leader of the mission comes up with a "draft" team halfway through the game day (i.e. within 24 hours of day start).
In that way, we have time to discuss the choices the leader wants to make and the leader can defend them (or perform changes and elaborate on them).
|
|
|
|
|
|
EPT![[image loading]](http://i.imgur.com/3jJ6QM1.jpg)
![[image loading]](http://i.imgur.com/00yigPG.jpg)
![[image loading]](http://i.imgur.com/4BSZknN.jpg)
![[image loading]](http://i.imgur.com/jJaqoAy.jpg)
![[image loading]](http://i.imgur.com/iJhjROU.jpg)
