|
On January 30 2017 19:34 RtaniSoul wrote:Show nested quote +On January 30 2017 17:56 Superbia wrote:
TW are you still mafia reading me?
I love how pretty much everyone is townreading both TW and myself and nobody gives a shit that we're scumreading each other.
Nice ANALysis. We figure you'll get your head out of your ass eventually xP Tumble is pretty damn town. He's just on it this game with lots of bretty good observations.
He feels very floaty. Nothing he says seems solid and I have a feeling he has no actual reads.
His interaction with vivax feels pockety at best.
I find it weird that you townread him so hard even though he has put a lot of doubt (imo) on both myself and wolf, both of whom are your other townreads. He also put doubt on yourself.
And then he mafia-reads into consensus reads + myself.
|
oh scum = spy
I kept wondering why you guys call me names (scum) but in fact you only meant to label me a spy.
|
On January 30 2017 19:34 RtaniSoul wrote:Show nested quote +On January 30 2017 17:56 Superbia wrote:
TW are you still mafia reading me?
I love how pretty much everyone is townreading both TW and myself and nobody gives a shit that we're scumreading each other.
Nice ANALysis. We figure you'll get your head out of your ass eventually xP Tumble is pretty damn town. He's just on it this game with lots of bretty good observations.
Please give me some quotes or something that shows he's made good observations. Are you o.k. with the fact he pretty much shit all over the original team that you made, including you, and then made an entirely different one besides the fact most wanted at least 2 of the originals still on it. I also have seen no deep observations whatsoever. They've all been surface level stuff. If you really have this deep of a townread on this slot, you need to convince others, because I don't see it. If you can't, I'm gonna assume he's on your team and you are both spies at this point.
~SilverWolf77
|
On January 30 2017 19:43 Superbia wrote:Show nested quote +On January 30 2017 19:34 RtaniSoul wrote:On January 30 2017 17:56 Superbia wrote:
TW are you still mafia reading me?
I love how pretty much everyone is townreading both TW and myself and nobody gives a shit that we're scumreading each other.
Nice ANALysis. We figure you'll get your head out of your ass eventually xP Tumble is pretty damn town. He's just on it this game with lots of bretty good observations. He feels very floaty. Nothing he says seems solid and I have a feeling he has no actual reads. His interaction with vivax feels pockety at best. I find it weird that you townread him so hard even though he has put a lot of doubt (imo) on both myself and wolf, both of whom are your other townreads. He also put doubt on yourself. And then he mafia-reads into consensus reads + myself.
This is probably my strongest townread this game. They have pretty much mirrored my thoughts and concerns this game. The fact that both of us were knocked off the team by Tumblewood should give anyone that's town some concern and anyone strong townreading TW needs to give a good reasons besides "making great points" because he's not.
~SilverWolf77
|
I'd also be interested in hearing which good Tumblewood points Artisoul was referring to. From what I remember Tumble had a reason to town lean on me/vivacious (I'm writing on my phone and now I'm keeping that) as well as some reason to distrust Superbia. But none of Tumblewoods ideas seemed to be reflected in Artisoul's reads list.
|
Also Silver, Tumble knocking you/superbia off the team in favor of his own reads isn't "cause for concern." If he was scum he could add any 2 players and himself and still sabotage the mission.
Don't scum read people for having different reads than you.
|
And I'm not trying to say that Tumblewood can't be scum.
He just isn't more likely to be scum because of his team choice.
|
On January 31 2017 00:05 Grackaroni wrote:
Also Silver, Tumble knocking you/superbia off the team in favor of his own reads isn't "cause for concern." If he was scum he could add any 2 players and himself and still sabotage the mission.
Don't scum read people for having different reads than you.
This is true. I have a feeling it was a reaction to me predicting he would take himself + rtso + wolf though.
I regret saying that. 
|
On January 30 2017 17:56 Superbia wrote:
TW are you still mafia reading me?
I love how pretty much everyone is townreading both TW and myself and nobody gives a shit that we're scumreading each other.
Nice ANALysis.
not scumreading you per se but I would not vote for a team with you in it
|
at this point I would not accept a team with any of super, sl, calix, or sharkie. other than that I would accept any team, except maybe the corner case of my three lowest townreads. hope this clears things up for you
|
On January 30 2017 04:40 Vivax wrote:
I'm rejecting the team cuz superbia and silverika aren't on it. They are my strongest reads.
I'm requesting calix and SL to step up activity, I can't read them for crap like this.
I also very much like rtanisouls list except that superbia would be higher in mine, and grack is more of a null for the point he made about tumblewood which seemed perceptive to me, but can come from spies as well I guess.
Here's my suggestion that doesn't have me in it.
superbia/silverika/tumble
My next step would be to ask rtanisoul if they're fine with this.
plz this is my standard day 1 get bent
|
On January 31 2017 01:20 sicklucker wrote:Show nested quote +On January 30 2017 04:40 Vivax wrote:
I'm rejecting the team cuz superbia and silverika aren't on it. They are my strongest reads.
I'm requesting calix and SL to step up activity, I can't read them for crap like this.
I also very much like rtanisouls list except that superbia would be higher in mine, and grack is more of a null for the point he made about tumblewood which seemed perceptive to me, but can come from spies as well I guess.
Here's my suggestion that doesn't have me in it.
superbia/silverika/tumble
My next step would be to ask rtanisoul if they're fine with this. plz this is my standard day 1 get bent
yeah why vote in a team with a null read on it
|
On January 31 2017 00:05 Grackaroni wrote:
Also Silver, Tumble knocking you/superbia off the team in favor of his own reads isn't "cause for concern." If he was scum he could add any 2 players and himself and still sabotage the mission.
Don't scum read people for having different reads than you.
we arent scum reading him for the diffrent reads, we scum read him becasue jsut about everyone was fine with the first team but he goes out and disregards the entire thing.
|
the fact im not trying early is a town read for me tbh. like is this my mafia game? where i blantantly try not to be town read??
|
I don't think any player has done anything to be labelled as a spy so far...
Most of your "reads" can be used for either side. Also apart from Silverika (who actually voted for the team unlike the spies who did not want the team), no one has done anything to call himself rebel either.
|
On January 30 2017 19:43 Superbia wrote:Show nested quote +On January 30 2017 19:34 RtaniSoul wrote:On January 30 2017 17:56 Superbia wrote:
TW are you still mafia reading me?
I love how pretty much everyone is townreading both TW and myself and nobody gives a shit that we're scumreading each other.
Nice ANALysis. We figure you'll get your head out of your ass eventually xP Tumble is pretty damn town. He's just on it this game with lots of bretty good observations. He feels very floaty. Nothing he says seems solid and I have a feeling he has no actual reads. His interaction with vivax feels pockety at best. I find it weird that you townread him so hard even though he has put a lot of doubt (imo) on both myself and wolf, both of whom are your other townreads. He also put doubt on yourself. And then he mafia-reads into consensus reads + myself.
I don't have to agree with his reads to see a town thought process in them. He's just gotten to the bottom of things a lot. Pointing out Vivax was throwing shade on us for a null point, consistent with it regarding silver, actually townreads vivax despite giving reasons he could potentially use to scumread him making me feel like he's really not worried about 'fabricating' reads/using everything to the max.
Superbia got a lot of TR's early on but he doesn't feel pressured to go with the flow. If TW's a spy here and Superbia is town I really don't see him going after Superbia without anyone backing him up.
TW doesn't afraid of anything this game and goes beneath the surface. I very much like him.
|
Basically we find it hard to imagine Tumblewood went, as Vivax briefly pointed out, "I'm going to hammer on this point Vivax is trying to make on Rtani, then step back and not use this argument to scumread him" as a pre-planned idea to get town reads. Padding to that is the fact that he's been going against thread consensus and isn't trying to make friends at all, which is suicide as either alignment, but Spies would be much more concerned about it.
|
On January 31 2017 03:36 sicklucker wrote:
the fact im not trying early is a town read for me tbh. like is this my mafia game? where i blantantly try not to be town read??
Yeah, your self meta doesn't help me townread you. The fact that you aren't trying means you could be either a spy or resistance but you are doing absolutely nothing to help me get a decent read on you and at the very least, it's anti-town. I don't care if that's your standard play in mafia games. This isn't a regular mafia game and if you continue like this, you'll simply be kept off the missions and make it easier for spies to get on a mission in your place is you are indeed resistance.
~SilverWolf7
|
|
|
The team consisting of Grackaroni, Tumblewood, Vivax has been rejected.
Votes for: Tumblewood.
Votes against: Grackaroni, RtaniSoul, sharkie, sicklucker, Silverika, Superbia, Vivax.
Calix did not vote (counted as reject).
Calix has been replaced be emperorchampion.
Team Leader emperorchampion will now make Attempt #3 to nominate a team for Mission #1. The nomination will be locked Tuesday, Jan 31 10:00pm GMT (GMT+00:00), in .
|
|
|
|
|
|
EPT
