Liquidmania Qualifier #2 - Page 3

On January 18 2017 02:12 Bill Murray wrote:

this follows what u said earlier that in mylo hf would nail mafia and i agree but i dont want to lose u because i have a town read on you so why cant we find someone other than EITHER of u

On January 18 2017 02:23 Damdred wrote:
Ls vote on hf is so bad and is scrum indicative of him I think, lure she do for no reason

On January 18 2017 02:24 Holyflare wrote:
##unvote
##vote ls

maybe a bit late but I read hapa's scum games :D

On January 18 2017 05:44 Hapahauli wrote:
Onegu

Partly scummy, partly lynchbait.

From how the lynch went down, I'd argue Onegu looks the worst.

Why Onegu is mafia:


Firstly, this case is a very typical mafia case. It looks all nice and pretty, but it doesn't hold up to a closer look. The entire post reads as a way for Onegu to take a stance, without actually providing any useful things to town.
1) The analysis is useless. His case boils down to "I think Rels play looks forced", which is unhelpful to say the least. It's a completely subjective tell. Hell, 75% of the post talks about people other than his main scum-read.
2) Onegu talks about Vivax being top town, and "seeing the same thing as Vivax saw about Rels." But it doesn't make a lot of sense for him to do this. Vivax's case on Rels was based on not understanding that Rels was actively catching up in thread and updating his reads while he was posting. Onegu did the same thing this game, and mentions that he does it frequently. Yet for some reason, Onegu doesn't understand what's wrong with vivax's read.
3) The timing is weird. It's a very typical mafia play to bomb a case on a player that no one is really talking about to create chaos. At this point, I had just posted my case on Holyflare, and HF/Vivax votes were on Damdred.


This is just a weird martyr post that feels very forced. It's like he's trying to play up his desire not to lynch HF, knowing full well that he himself (Onegu) wasn't at risk of being lynched.

Why he could be Lynchbait?
Onegu is notoriously hard to read, and somewhat of an inactive player. He also has molded his playstyle to be unreadable on meta, or so he has said in the past.

On balance? Mafia
Onegu seems to be pushing mafia objectives. His push of Rels was very useless. The Holyflare martyr stuff seems very fake. It's one of those things that looks like you're sticking your neck out, but you're really not.

On January 18 2017 02:05 Rels wrote:
The only other lynch I could do is Onegu. But I prefer HF

On January 20 2017 00:09 Vivax wrote:
Why are you so sure that HF is town?

On January 20 2017 01:06 Vivax wrote:


I don't understand the last sentence, what did they not need to do?

And why does Hapa look worse?

On January 20 2017 01:19 Holyflare wrote:
And why do you keep not town reading me but effectively calling me town?

On January 20 2017 01:18 Holyflare wrote:


But that's what I don't get that both you and slam keep perpetuating, why does there have to be a choice between me/hapa?

On January 20 2017 01:14 Vivax wrote:


This is so extremely naive I don't even know

On January 20 2017 02:26 Hapahauli wrote:
Damdred I think is with my margin of error. I do have that "genuine thought process" read on him, but his EoD does look very very bad. Bad enough to reconsider things. Margin for error here because he could just be legit inactive.

Onegu is lynchbaity I guess, but I also feel he's pushing mafia objectives. He's active but not contributing. His Rels case was pretty shit.


Him voting Damdred currently for these reasons is pretty silly. I don't' care how LS and Damdred pitched it - getting a read wrong does not make someone mafia. Also, Rels' death equally implicates Onegu.

On January 20 2017 02:35 Vivax wrote:


You know, the big shiny posts don't a town make. You don't see what I see, you only see what you have to do in order to win the game for your faction, and that gives you away.

I currently believe this game is a shitshow.

Damdred is MIA and I'm starting to believe for good reason cause he's a good hearted guy. Only you and HF -the scum- play this game like it's supposed to be played.

Slam comes in shouting Gollum gollum, Onegu probably didn't read 90 % of the game and just does his thing, but doesn't take the game seriously, I applaude him for trying to though.

BM also probably just skimmed some shit and does his thing a bit like 1gu.

And all of this never affects you emotionally in your posts and that's a giveaway.

But whatever. This isn't a championship game, it's a fucking farce. I'm tilted and I'm not hiding it. I just now know EXACTLY how rayn felt when he quit the forum.