EPTIf you ask shitty questions you get shitty answers
Newbie Student Mafia XXV - Page 2
| Forum Index > TL Mafia |
|
Vivax
22408 Posts
If you ask shitty questions you get shitty answers | ||
|
Vivax
22408 Posts
Anyway. I keep thinking it'd be cool if more people posted, this feels a lot like a clash between overeager townies which is what happens 80 % of the time in the average game of mafia. I also feel a bit troubled by ika and Silver actually living together cause they had little interaction at the start of the game, but then it wore off quickly. And Silver was very eager to jump at me for apparently defending ika. And ika brought ahead a similar argument where he said I was too sure of him being town. Point being, they might have a common playstyle being a couple or whatever, and I don't really know how that plays out since they're new here. It did kinda feel concertated how they were bombarding me with accusations back there. But it's just feels | ||
|
Vivax
22408 Posts
On January 07 2017 02:33 darthfoley wrote: I'd be interested to see Kelsier's take on this Vivax/ika/SW thing when he gets a chance. And more from Grack And yours? | ||
|
Vivax
22408 Posts
On January 07 2017 02:46 darthfoley wrote: Of the three of you, I liked SW's responses the best. They seem natural and attentive without being scared of making conclusions. I am town reading her I understand your initial questioning, but I don't like how you play semantics over the B0ston thing. Your first sentence is clearly more than a read imo It's understandable why people think you're answering for him, indirectly with the "I guess" qualifier. So I don't like that you deflected and then kind of pulled an "OMGUS, the questions I got weren't up to my liking!" Yea I checked his answers to the questionnaire and figured he was a newbie. And as newbie one tends to strictly pay attention to how useful or compliant a person looks, so only obvious he'd go after 1gu. That's where my guess comes from. | ||
|
Vivax
22408 Posts
On January 07 2017 03:02 Kmatt wrote: I actually had read up about an hour ago but have been eating lunch and what not. I'll be back with a wall of text don't you worry. But yeah, between Squishy/Michael/Boston/Onegu there's a good number of afk this game. And of course Btdt. He had to have confirmed the game start message from Kita so he can't be too far off. You won't be read just based upon the amount of words you cram into a single post but if you like writing huge texts I won't stop you. | ||
|
Vivax
22408 Posts
| ||
|
Vivax
22408 Posts
I don't think we should lynch Grack today, but I'm going to take a look at the arguments against him. | ||
|
Vivax
22408 Posts
On January 08 2017 03:22 Grackaroni wrote: It's because I annoyed a bunch of people. Yes I have noticed it too that some people here will lynch you if they think you are snarky or whatever. I thought I signed up for mafia. | ||
|
Vivax
22408 Posts
Reps I think is town so it's kinda sad he's voting for Grack who I also think is town. Will explain why on request Next hard to read guy would be 1gu and I believe he's town actually, last time I saw him mafia was in the game where BH bussed him, and he tried much harder to look useful in that game. Here he just seems calm and unpressured. Filter if you want to compare: http://www.teamliquid.net/forum/mafia/496215-mini-mafia-the-kinda-vanilla-experience?user=Onegu&view=all | ||
|
Vivax
22408 Posts
Boston has this thing bugging me: On January 07 2017 07:32 B0stonSC wrote: Okay, so after catching up, I have a few things to respond on. First, as to why I am not more active, is that I have not a whole lot of time to play mafia during the week, so what I am doing is catching up, responding to everything I feel needs a response, giving my reads, then getting back off. You may flame me for this, but unless it's the weekend this will be how I play. I do have a life you know, but mafia is a lot of fun (which is why I wanted to play it). As to why I voted Onegu (asked three times, by my count), he has made a claim (with the first post of the game) and then posted a non informative post. That's all he has done. I wanted to see what happens if he gets a bit of pressure on him, but after this amount of time I feel that he is just inactive. On to my reads, Kmatt feels very much a scummy player to me becuase he is posting quite a bit now, but it doesn't feel like he is accomplishing anything. DarthFoley seems waaaay too defensive, so that seems odd, but I'll keep looking at him so I can get a more solid read. Vivax and MichaelEhrmantraut seem a bit off. Nothing suspicious, but just a bit not quite correct to me. This is more of a gut read than anything else, so I'll be doing a reread (probably today) for just them to see what's up. Now it's weekend and he should be playing according to himself. | ||
|
Vivax
22408 Posts
| ||
|
Vivax
22408 Posts
So it's a thought on hold maybe I'll find something positive to take from her posts at some point. For now she doesn't look sheepable to me. I think for today I would be content with a PL on ME, otherwise I still have my eyes on Kelsier and DF mostly as I might have been onto something at the start of the day, but today I feel like shit and am lazy to go dig for something and make a case, to be completely honest. | ||
|
Vivax
22408 Posts
On January 08 2017 04:06 Calix wrote: What makes you think that? It would be good if you could expand on your reads at some point. Kelsier for not seeming to care at this point and his negative comment about the game at the beginning. It's the sort of thing I saw Palmar going after people for and successfully catching mafia with it. So I think it could be a nice heuristic for catching mafia. Foley for what I posted about him. Doesn't need expanding as it's in my filter. As for you, I said I don't want to pursue that thought for now as you are still one of the most active players if not the most active player. | ||
|
Vivax
22408 Posts
On January 08 2017 04:29 beentheredonethat wrote: ksc most likely town for this. he hates playing scum afaik. That's a bad read and you should know that | ||
|
Vivax
22408 Posts
On January 08 2017 04:38 Calix wrote: Is this implying a scum-read? Also when are you going to respond to my post? I just figured you had fucked off. Yea no I have plenty of content going and all you do is focus on the one I don't decide on expanding on and won't for my own reasons which are explained. You could talk about anything in my filter but if you only ever choose to pick the stuff I don't want to talk about, you're not going to get a reply. | ||
|
Vivax
22408 Posts
On January 08 2017 04:39 beentheredonethat wrote: Explain it to me then? Maybe I should not apply meta reads with people I haven't played with  Cause anyone can pretend to come in swinging with a good mood at the beginning of the game, simples. | ||
|
Vivax
22408 Posts
On January 08 2017 04:46 Calix wrote: If you don't want to expand on it then why bring it up in the first place? You've already seen how well that worked when Grack did something similar. FMPOV it looks like you made that read on me to doubt-cast given that it was posted after BTDT gave me a town-read and then you said that his KSC read was bad also. That's why I want to know your reasoning. Yes you see some sort of connection in why I'm bringing it up but don't want to also consider the possibility that it's simply a thought that occurred to me during the game. You might have noticed how in my analysis of DFs post I paid attention to also seeing his post as coming from a town PoV, then explained why I thought it was the more unlikely point of view. Like right now you are seeing my post as only coming from a mafia point of view where I want to cast doubt on you. But it could as well simply be true that I genuinely thought that and wanted to get the thought into the game. | ||
|
Vivax
22408 Posts
On January 08 2017 04:56 Calix wrote: That's how I play. I look for shit that makes sense from mafia POV and push that. I don't think it's a bad thing and don't need a lecture on how to play as town. You say it's a genuine read but I don't get why town would bring up a read that they think and then be reluctant to expand on it. If you could explain that to me so I can factor that into how I read you then that would be great. In the earlier post I said that it could make me tinfoil that one of the more active players is mafia. There have been past instances where I created a whole lot of fuss over nothing cause the super active player I was sure was some mastermind mafia turned out to be simply town. There's a reason I have a bunch of people quoting me as insane in my profile and that's probably the biggest. I used to like to go after very active players, completely disregarding everyone's opinion, so now I'm more conscious about that aspect and that's why I try to suppress the thought that you could be mafia this early. | ||
|
Vivax
22408 Posts
On January 08 2017 05:01 darthfoley wrote: I think KSC, Vivax, ME or Boston should all be up for lynch before Grack. Grack shouldn't be up for lynch at all imo. Why do you even think in order of priorities? | ||
|
Vivax
22408 Posts
On January 08 2017 05:14 darthfoley wrote: Huh? My point is that there are 4 scummier people than Grack which for D1 is more than enough to shelve a Grack lynch IMO. Why are you questioning me wanting to lynch my scum reads? Nah I misread that as you wanting to lynch Grack. Quick glance over your filter shows you aren't scumreading him though. | ||
| ||
