[M][N] Murder on the Cruise Trip Mafia - Page 31

On October 14 2016 00:16 justanothertownie wrote:

That's because you are notoriously bad.

On October 11 2016 07:21 Palmar wrote:

yes

I know not everyone is this good.

throw me a bone here guys. One of you mention wanting to kill marv who:

a) voted a terrible lynch on day 1, where BOTH ME AND HF noticed bats saying shit that didn't sound like mafia. We both said so. Marv is even better than us two at this tonal townie thing, and he flat out ignored it.

b) he voted me on day 2, then became less convinced I was mafia because I don't sound like damn mafia because I'm not one, but instead of doing anything, he just... went afk

c) killed hf, which is the obvious marv kill when hf suspected him and everyone thought hf was town.

Someone please, put votes on him.

I'm moving my vote to marv, and I'm going to see what happens.

On October 11 2016 07:23 Palmar wrote:

well show me.

He is 100% mafia this game, so all you have to do is go vote him.

There is no universe where this is town marv.

On October 11 2016 07:44 Palmar wrote:

you know how I feel about everyone else

and I'm behind on the game.

NU can't concoct all this stupidity as scum so he's town
Calix is unnaturally bad, but still, sounded kinda sincere at points so town

Koshi, scott and damdred can fall either way. Koshi sounds slightly mafia and scott, maybe. Damdred sounds slightly town

marv is scum.

On October 09 2016 05:47 Palmar wrote:
Superbia is gonna flip town.

Scum team is a combination of JAT koshi Marv Scott damdred

On October 10 2016 02:01 Palmar wrote:
I don't even care about my cred anymore. If I'm fucking wrong I'll just accept it. I keep hedging (Iike calling superbia not the worst lynch out of spite for his lack of effort last night, I then turned around and said he was town, of course).

Calix is 100% town
NU is 100% town
Oats is 100% town

Grack is 80% town

Damdred is 50% town
Koshi is 50% town
Scott is 40% town

Jag is 5% town
Marv is 0% town

two free mafia. gg wp

On October 10 2016 02:02 Palmar wrote:

and marv

On October 11 2016 03:41 Palmar wrote:

You said the same thing about superbia

I am voting obvious mafia JAT. I'm not caught up and will not catch up until day 4 if I'm still alive.

I am also willing to vote the other obvious mafia, marv.

On October 11 2016 06:23 Palmar wrote:

Lol

On October 14 2016 02:49 justanothertownie wrote:

Ok, I've had enough of this shit.

Why the fuck is oats town? Explain it to me.

I am mafia for not noticing bats is town? I WAS NOT AROUND.
For superbia? He played like shit/his mafia meta demonstrably. You even liked my case.
Oats isn't town.
Palmar was not obvious town. And marv was willing to lynch him which is usually a good argument for killing him.

On October 14 2016 02:57 marvellosity wrote:

your viewpoint is scum's viewpoint though

On October 14 2016 03:01 marvellosity wrote:
i also don't think (from a personal point of view) that you would even come close to think i am mafia right now due to

1. how easily you townread me at the beginning of the game
2. the fact that after i went afk i came back and have been playing (i don't do this as mafia)
3. due to 1&2, you should be townreading me for the same reasons
4. you also know that yolo lynching Palmar is so far away from my style as mafia
5. this dichotomy you've been pushing that one or the other of Palmar and me is mafia isn't logical.

none of these are convincing to anyone else particularly, but there we go

On October 14 2016 03:05 marvellosity wrote:

did i miss something?

On October 14 2016 03:05 marvellosity wrote:

did i miss something?

On October 12 2016 08:24 Damdred wrote:


Thats just dumb because even if i discount oats I have two people I think coudl be scum in the third position. Calix is just acting to sure of herself at this point to be town unless shes cop with a red check with me. We are in triple lylo you can't go into that with your thoughts set in stone.

Its dumb and loses you the game.

On October 14 2016 03:09 justanothertownie wrote:

He "crumbed" the check? Where is the mafia motivation here.

On October 14 2016 03:19 Damdred wrote:
So here's the question could koshi or nu be playing the most awesome game as scum so far?

On October 14 2016 03:21 marvellosity wrote:
certainly 1 person (at least) is playing a very excellent scumgame. kinda hoping we manage to lynch the other 2 and then 3 way lylo is like a whole different game (if town play it right)

On October 14 2016 03:22 marvellosity wrote:
in all seriousness - why did Grackaroni die?

personally as mafia (in my first 2 years of playing when i was actually amazing at scum) i would sometimes kill unexpected targets so that later in the game it would be less surprising that i was alive. i'd say there's a good chance that's the case here (not that you didn't deserve to be nk or anything Grack <3)

On October 14 2016 03:30 Damdred wrote:
In any case if that happens and you and nu are town which I'm leaning more towards now the game,is,over anyway.

And we know Scott will vote me today anyway so just takes one to kill me anyway unless the scum team is nu, jat, Scott. Which I kinda doubt

On October 12 2016 05:51 Koshi wrote:

HE IS 100% MAFIA.

On October 12 2016 06:18 Calix wrote:
It's impossible for there to be a world where Koshi/ NU are both town and town!JAT and town!Damdred switched away from town!Scott to lynch town!Palmar with THREE FUCKING MINUTES TO SPARE.