[M][T] Haunted Mansion 3 - Page 104

On September 14 2016 04:33 fuba wrote:

I'm tempted to, because I'm completely unsure of damdred. Dunno if I've tried to go through too much too fast, but I can't even seem to think enough to make a decision on him. Calix's case had me going into his filter seeing him as scum already, and then I tried to pick it out myself on a readthrough and I couldn't do it. Maybe I was trying too hard to discount bias, maybe I'm letting myself be buddied, maybe I'm just too tired to focus after about 8 hours of (attempted) critical reading.

It's down to either sheeping calix, NU, and scott, or going with my own scumread despite the fact that I have 4-5 other people to read still.

Ugh, sticking with Damdred. The three I mentioned were able to read him in real time in the context of what was going on in the thread and come to an agreement. Class has already basically started, I can't think about it anymore today.

On September 14 2016 04:35 Holyflare wrote:
Let's kill sky

On September 14 2016 04:36 Skynx wrote:
I like Vivax as usual, will prolly won't ever lynch him this game. I don't like Super.

On September 14 2016 04:37 Damdred wrote:
Answer the questions I posed to you skynx

On September 13 2016 13:11 Tumblewood wrote:
Welcome to The Scum Pool. I'm your host, Tumblewood von Trapp, and here are your contestants:

Holyflare
Claim to Fame:

• has cased town for almost his entire filter
  
• pisses me off constantly
  
• believes (or pretends to believe) with absurd confidence that he has found scum!tictock based off of literally 5 posts. does not sell it as a plynch even though it is nothing more
  
• more concerned with pushing his lynches than thinking about them
  

Other Notes
(this is the section where I temper my expectations)
I am no longer 100% certain that hf is scum. I think the fact that I couldn't case him reasonably is not just a reflection on my casing ability / his skill at shitting up the thread as scum but possibly caused in part by the fact that he is maybe not scum. This might be one of those shitty tunnels like on rels in names are hard or even moreso jat game where by the end I had nearly forgotten why he was scum. the more I think about it the more I want to lynch shape or damdred over him. don't misinterpret this as me thinking he is town though because I don't.

Shapelog
Claim to Fame:

• doing almost nothing the entire game
  
• no one seems to want to call him out or push him for it. constantly rests in the spot of "scummy but not important right now". (this reason is twofold: first, if he were town he would more likely be pushed by scum; second, studies suggest that if shapelog ever doesn't get votes all game he is almost always scum. this is a real thing and imo valid to base reads off of.)
  

Other Notes
I have no real reason to believe shapelog is town besides whatever I said at the start of the game, and that read no longer holds water 5 days and 1700 posts later.

Damdred
Claim to Fame:

• being really disappointing overall. more,explanation in notes
  
• being everyone's second,scumread besides nu who is town,and doesn't count (yes shut up this is a legitimate read)
  
• has not,evaluated anyone on their mindset at all. tsk
  

Other Notes
no I haven't read his filter since early D1 when I felt compelled to make a reads list but you have to admit damdred has been really disappointing this game. in,his town game he tries to step up and form a town,circle and,you can-- or at least I do-- usually identify him as town if he looks really town or if,he has his head way up his ass. this game he has been going through the motions but seemingly unmotivated to actually do anything.

Palmar
Claim to Fame:

• being a lazy shit
  
• and an idiot
  
• and really annoys me by calling me useless and ignoring the hypocrisy of that given how little he and several others have done in comparison to me.
  

Other Notes
obviously not conclusive evidence given how lazy and idiotic palmar can be as either alignment, but it's still scum-indicative and really quite accurate.

Superbia
Claim to Fame:

• *does nothing. comes back for 15 minutes every once in a while and posts 5 times with a combined 20 words. leaves*
  
• stupid bad push on calix after deadline. this read applies to holyflare too to a lesser extent.
  

Other Notes
besides fuba who I have made a mental note to look at again and vivax who I will not, superbia rounds out our list of background-y players. I don't have very much to say about him because he has done very little to give me an opinion on him.

---

wow this post looks very pretty. I will do this more often. these are the five people within whom I think there are three scum. the top three are the most likely scum team. say stuff about it if you want

On September 14 2016 03:17 Damdred wrote:
@Skynx a couple questions,

1) You originally had shape in as a potential lynch target.

You then go into,the lynch read his filter and go nvm guys he's fine filter wasn't so,bad.

As night starts you then say oh nvm shape/Damdred +1. (You were also light defending me during the day and saying you might lynch me)

What caused this change on shape, (this was before shape thought you looked scummy)

Also why are you asking people about,me when you clearly had a s um read on me earlier in the day?

(this was before shape thought you looked scummy)

On September 14 2016 04:42 Superbia wrote:
Shape's filter is pretty townie. =/

On September 14 2016 04:46 Tumblewood wrote:

how are you evaluating that? literally every time I evaluated shape's filter for towniness I have been wrong. about 0/7. not sure how to accurately do it.