EPTOn July 29 2016 01:23 Rels wrote:
GG folks. A few thoughts.
A lot of people played well but the scum team played a very, very good and clean game. We managed to get a lot of towncred from 1 member being bused, and managed to keep that towncred by never throwing shade at each other during the rest of the game.
Tumble in particular pulled a GB. He played a pretty bad game at the beginning, got scumread for that pretty early on, but managed to make the bus look like a very natural thing and bought Grab and I a lot of cred. Very good play during D2.
Grac's push on kush D1 was super good, it's hard to be a town leader as scum and Grac just took town by the hand after Kruppe claimed very naturally. Very strong play, kush was a perfect, perfect D1 lynch for scum: strong player that was AFK, no info gained at all. I managed to do that on sicklucker D3 too, and on prp D4. Overall we played very good. Grac also had a good read on Koshi being cop, roleblocking N2 and killing him N3.
About what could town have done better:
Lunatic, stop posting sometimes and just think. A mafia game is almost always not as simple as it looks. Your vote on DC at the end is a good example: this is LYLO with instant hammer, if you're wrong the game is lost instantly. There is nothing wrong with taking the full day to reread and talk about things. You obviously put a lot of effort in this game so I know it's hard to be crushed like that. I would recommand you to play a newbie game with a coach to improve.
prp, you played a good game up until that sicklucker hammer. That was super retarded. When sicklucker left the thread he wasn't the lynch; when he got back he was lynched. It was a super good move for scum to hammer him early, before he could say anything. After that during D4 I understand that you were tired of being scumread all the time and just wanted out of this game. But there was a reason my case on you was super bad and I was the only one not talking about a 2 scum team and was only focusing on you: I was scum and I wanted you to be lynched so the game was over. You could have pressured me on it.
DC, your posts weren't bad at all for a first game of mafia, but you just didn't have the time commitment to play an hard game. Like Lunatic, I would recommend playing a newbie game with a coach.
Finally, Race Bannon. If you ever host again, take it seriously. A host should be invisible to the players and not give any info he has. It's easy to host slip, and you did when you quoted that Shape post from his QT where he called me "scummy". You introduced info to the game that wasn't suppose to be in it.
You can joke around as a player, not as a host. I don't want you to ever host or cohost a game if you don't swear somewhere that you accept being banned from this website if you don't try to be a good host/cohost.
I have nothing but praise to say to the rest. You all played well. Especially Skynx and emperor, you proved that you passed the newb stage. You two played a strong game, sometimes you lose even when playing as good as possible.
You all played well. But the scum played better. ^^
GG folks. A few thoughts.
A lot of people played well but the scum team played a very, very good and clean game. We managed to get a lot of towncred from 1 member being bused, and managed to keep that towncred by never throwing shade at each other during the rest of the game.
Tumble in particular pulled a GB. He played a pretty bad game at the beginning, got scumread for that pretty early on, but managed to make the bus look like a very natural thing and bought Grab and I a lot of cred. Very good play during D2.
Grac's push on kush D1 was super good, it's hard to be a town leader as scum and Grac just took town by the hand after Kruppe claimed very naturally. Very strong play, kush was a perfect, perfect D1 lynch for scum: strong player that was AFK, no info gained at all. I managed to do that on sicklucker D3 too, and on prp D4. Overall we played very good. Grac also had a good read on Koshi being cop, roleblocking N2 and killing him N3.
About what could town have done better:
Lunatic, stop posting sometimes and just think. A mafia game is almost always not as simple as it looks. Your vote on DC at the end is a good example: this is LYLO with instant hammer, if you're wrong the game is lost instantly. There is nothing wrong with taking the full day to reread and talk about things. You obviously put a lot of effort in this game so I know it's hard to be crushed like that. I would recommand you to play a newbie game with a coach to improve.
prp, you played a good game up until that sicklucker hammer. That was super retarded. When sicklucker left the thread he wasn't the lynch; when he got back he was lynched. It was a super good move for scum to hammer him early, before he could say anything. After that during D4 I understand that you were tired of being scumread all the time and just wanted out of this game. But there was a reason my case on you was super bad and I was the only one not talking about a 2 scum team and was only focusing on you: I was scum and I wanted you to be lynched so the game was over. You could have pressured me on it.
DC, your posts weren't bad at all for a first game of mafia, but you just didn't have the time commitment to play an hard game. Like Lunatic, I would recommend playing a newbie game with a coach.
Finally, Race Bannon. If you ever host again, take it seriously. A host should be invisible to the players and not give any info he has. It's easy to host slip, and you did when you quoted that Shape post from his QT where he called me "scummy". You introduced info to the game that wasn't suppose to be in it.
You can joke around as a player, not as a host. I don't want you to ever host or cohost a game if you don't swear somewhere that you accept being banned from this website if you don't try to be a good host/cohost.
I have nothing but praise to say to the rest. You all played well. Especially Skynx and emperor, you proved that you passed the newb stage. You two played a strong game, sometimes you lose even when playing as good as possible.
You all played well. But the scum played better. ^^
Yes I agree, and EC had a great point on that there was no mafia on the grac lynch should have suggested Grac was mafia himself.
