Who needs 72 hours anyway! [M][T] - Page 135

On July 27 2016 19:57 Lunaticman wrote:


If we assume EC and Grac are the cop checks because I think that's logical and smart. Can we put them in green in the day votes too please?

On July 27 2016 19:58 Skynx wrote:
I'll hammer if you guys are fine with it, DC should be next.

I'm ready to go lylo with Luna if all goes wrong.

On July 27 2016 20:03 Rels wrote:
Day recaps colored with flips

With D3 votecount fixed and Koshi's cop checks colored!

+ Show Spoiler [Day 1 final votecount] +

+ Show Spoiler [Day 2 final votecount] +

+ Show Spoiler [Day 3 final votecount] +

On July 27 2016 20:05 Skynx wrote:
Where did these cop checks came from lol

On July 27 2016 00:13 emperorchampion wrote:
Thinking about it on my walk here, I'm completely convinced that the team is lunaticman/prplhz.

I can't believe that I didn't piece together that koshi was cop yesterday, especially when he was posting about everybody needing to do the reads thing, since I had the exact same thought at the end of day 2 that we all need to post reads in order to hide our cop in the future since silent nights. His day 1 check was grack (really good check btw lol), and I was probably his day 2 check (likely due to the last minute vote). I know his day 1 check was grack because after grack posted about only towny people voting for tumble (great post btw), koshi switched there as well. He put 2 people as 0% mafia on his last list, grack and I. I am writing this part first to convince you that I'm town and not trying to deceive you at all in this. We should treat both grack and I confirmed town here.



The day 1 stuff with lunatic and tumble makes complete sense where tumble made his push on me and then lunatic was like "oh yeah I'm convinced", then "oh yeah he's town, but I'm still voting for him to put pressure", and tumble didn't call him out on it either (note: I didn't verify that tumble didn't call him out, but I'm pretty certain). Like if lunatic was town, that's sooo many good town points for jumping onto lunatic for some stupid posting. And there is no reason not too IF he is town, since a lynch is a lynch. One other thing, lunatic and tumble both do not seem like the type that would be likely to bus teammates. Other evidence is the "trap" stuff lunatic was posting about at the end of day 2, which was I guess just complete non-sense.

Like start reading from here: http://www.teamliquid.net/forum/mafia/511784-who-needs-72-hours-anyway?user=Koshi&page=12

Another thing I came across was the stuff from Kruppe, which I'll repost here:


More evidence against prpl here.




It honestly clicked like a puzzle or something on my walk here, I'm sure there is more evidence on prpl, but I'm totally convinced it's them at this point.

On July 27 2016 01:40 Grackaroni wrote:

This might have been the breadcrumb. I think he was the only one who was absolutely certain EC couldn't be mafia, at the very least.

On July 27 2016 19:35 Rels wrote:

Here Koshi says he read EC's filter "again". But he doesn't mention anything from his filter, just that he is confirmed not mafia. He does say "I'm not 100% sure", then in the same sentence "repeat after me: EC is not mafia".
I think he was trying to make the check obvious in case he was killed, while hiding it as long as nobody knew he was cop.

On July 27 2016 19:40 Rels wrote:

+ this, as mentionned already earlier today
2 checks, 2 people at 0%. It is super smart. It doesn't attract the attention, while giving info. Super super cool. (=
I'm 99% sure those were his green checks. If he had a red check we would have known.
The 1% chance is that he checked someone that was killed, but then I think he would have put only 1 person at 0% in this list.

On July 27 2016 20:06 Lunaticman wrote:


I dont think the mafia would vote on the same player day 1.

It's most likely DC/Skynx/Tumble or DC/Haze/Tumble using that logic.

On July 27 2016 20:10 Skynx wrote:
Man thats like pure speculation. But whatever they are both 100% town anyways.

On July 25 2016 21:16 Koshi wrote:
Lunatic is just pushing town into the wrong direction constantly and hasn't had a single decent game solving thought in his 17 page filter. The guy limits himself to just posting random scumteams without any decent logic behind it. But the most damning is that he yelled the entire D2 that there was mafia within Kruppe/Tumble/Koshi and then voted Grack. That is inconsistent and pushed mafia agenda.
Lunatic also only makes somewhat sense if he is defending himself, then suddenly it makes somewhat sense why he did things (even in our world). I do not believe that the guy is so clueless about finding mafia.

And let me explain once more: Clueless does not mean he doesn't know how mafia works, he knows, but he has never presented to this thread a real reason why somebody is mafia.

Also for 17 pages of filter. He never ever is convinced somebody is mafia ever. Like one moment he could say "Koshi is mafia" and the very next post he is trying to convince me that prplhz is not mafia and we should lynch Grack.

---

And for prplhz:
Only player this game that is flying under the radar. Received townreads in the start from literally everybody and is riding that townread to the sunset. Mafia or potential mafia never tries to put any suspicion on him, look at lunatic, never ever is prplhz in a scumteam, same for sicklucker, and probably also tumble, --> prplhz doesn't exist to these people. Yet EC is getting scumread 24/7. While the guy is town incarnated;

I showed that during the lynch he was with me to swap to DCWasabi, and after that didn't happen (why??? if we both are town) he moved back after me to Tumble (he had really no choice tbh or show serious face) but kept advocating to not lynch Tumble.

Other than that prplhz has not made enough posts that jump out. But I guess that is the flying under the radar part.

---

Not saying I am 100% certain. But I have shown that prplhz and Lunatic could have actual hidden agendas this game.
prplhz plays silent mafia that puts himself in a good position. Classic.
Lunatic I don't believe is town. What did the guy do that was solely town in his filter? Or really mafia? He would be very atypical mafia, and for this reason alone gets townread.


sicklucker is just super blunt and open, if he wanted to save Tumble so bad he could have went to DCW. I don't think DCW is mafia, I don't think sl is mafia. I have to be wrong on both. I don't believe that.

On July 27 2016 20:16 prplhz wrote:
not even the author of Koshi's case against me thought it was any good

On July 27 2016 20:21 Skynx wrote:

not even the lousiest blacksmith thought your hammer was any good

On July 27 2016 20:23 prplhz wrote:
eh just hammer me the reason not to hammer sicklucker was that he might have changed some people's opinions but that's not happening here

this game is boring me but i pretty much never join two at the same time and i wanna play onegu 2

i already gave my final reads