[M][N] H O L Y F * * * E mafia!! - Page 2

On May 25 2016 02:00 Damdred wrote:
Idk what I was expecting in the game but kinda meh about it.

Could Lynch Palmar, super, tumble today.

Fight me

On May 25 2016 02:16 Superbia wrote:
Kay I'm here.

HF/JAT. Explain how that point is relevant.

On May 25 2016 02:23 Superbia wrote:


I find it hard to believe that you are this short-sighted as town.

Why am I asking that question?

On May 25 2016 02:41 Superbia wrote:


The grand problem with HF's 'push' is that it assumes I am asking for LS's read because I think LS is town and I want to know his opinion on kush because I don't have a good read on him. It could not be more ass backwards.

I thought LS was sort of kinda-ish on the scummy side, and him calling two people town (both questionable reads imo) and questioning a third (kush) in the same post indicates to me that he was not reading kush town (someone whom I believe is likely town at this point) seemed to traverse him more in that direction, so I asked him for a hard read on kush (the read he gave was sort of meh). That being said, I have a decent meta-read on LS (I think), so I'm not drawing any conclusion of this yet. Just means he's starting off in the poor side of town (shitty suburbs).

Now this what I do all the time as town, and I have never (iirc) asked for a genuine opinion on someone to become more informed. The question is always to get to know more about the person questioned, rather than the subject. This is like standard 101 townplay, which I why I am very confused as to why a good 'town' player would jump on this with this utterly absurd and simplistic point of view.

Hence why I am skeptical of HF, as this is his second garbage push. And he's (supposed to be) a good player.

And even more skeptical of you, because you have been buddying up to HF early on, even though I don't think anyone should have a town read on HF. And you're a very anal town player.

On May 25 2016 03:23 Superbia wrote:
How are you reading HF, jat?

On May 25 2016 03:16 Superbia wrote:
That's some 101 buddying.

On May 25 2016 03:46 Superbia wrote:


Why?

On May 25 2016 03:51 Superbia wrote:


If you're town, and you find yourself agreeing to someone else's posts. Does not not make that person likely to have a town mindset as well, and thereby likely town?

Why are you not reading him town?

It feels like you're backing out because I'm calling you out.

On May 25 2016 03:55 LightningStrike wrote:
Damdred, JAT, and Superbia you guys should vote Palmar with me and Koshi. I pretty sure that he's scum at this point.

On May 25 2016 03:58 Superbia wrote:


Am I wrong? Having a similar mindset is one of the strongest town tells if applied well.

On May 25 2016 04:06 LightningStrike wrote:

Wrong person I forgot that was bats. Man I wish bats was still playing lol.

Why not now? If he's town all these votes will actually make him do stuff. If he's scum he will roll over and die.

On May 25 2016 04:12 Superbia wrote:


Ok, so I see where we disagree here, and I'm talking about a different kind of "agreement", on a more subconscious level. Where your line of thought lines up with the other. That being said:

I know you as a (town-)player that's non-positive (for lack of better word, someone who is not positive) and gives no credit or props or whatever. You don't pander to people as town. This is why I knew you were the last mafia in the last game you played (I skim-obsed it a bit, though I get no credit because I didn't tell anyone lolol). The fact that you call something a "good post" as town already raises my eye-brow. To add to that the fact that you're not even reading the poster town is really fucking weird, and rings my alarm bells.

Can others give some input on this?

On May 25 2016 04:15 justanothertownie wrote:

I find it extremely hard to believe that anyone who ever saw me play town would genuinely think this.

On May 25 2016 04:17 Palmar wrote:
Ls 100% mafua

On May 25 2016 04:19 Superbia wrote:


Lolll what? Not in the games I was in.

On May 25 2016 04:21 Superbia wrote:
You are the last person I expect to agree with anyone as town. Idk. I don't think I've ever seen you agree with someone as town. Maybe a slight nod towards something.

On May 25 2016 04:25 Superbia wrote:


I think I have a pretty decent grasp on how you play town though, imo. Maybe I'm not wording it correctly, or we see things (i.e. you) differently, but I'm pretty sure I know the difference between your town and mafia play.

That being said, I haven't reached a conclusion yet (ironic). Probably a mix between being tired and people I expected to show up not showing up. Which also probably both lead to having a small town circle.

On May 25 2016 04:28 LightningStrike wrote:

Why you don't think voting him will make him do anything regardless of his alignment?