A normal game just for JAT <3 - Page 16

On April 23 2016 07:14 gumshoe wrote:


Cause I still think tumble is town, based off that day 1, you never convinced me otherwise and you never will,

I said that shit about onegu bieng tumbles partner because in your world, onegu is the most likely other scummer if you give it half a brains thought.

Which means onegu was the best bet regardless of which one of us was right.

On April 23 2016 07:33 gumshoe wrote:
Shitty jat fact 132: one time jat made it to 3p Lylo and couldn't make up his mind about who was scum, so he just lynched them both.

On April 23 2016 07:22 gumshoe wrote:


I wish you had all this apathy 10 minutes ago when I was begging you to sheep me. Now it's just salt in the wound.

On April 23 2016 07:42 gumshoe wrote:

Yeah, I realized that ) : still really nice to have someone to be mad at besides myself.

Shitty jat fact 425: jat once made a case so awesome, that everyone who read it instantly conceded. Unfortunately jat also lost that game because he was jester.

On April 23 2016 07:07 Tumblewood wrote:
Wtf
How does mafia even work
I thought I was dead and Shape was somehow going to win
Nope
Shape is VT and dead
Wtf

On April 23 2016 12:26 gumshoe wrote:
I believed in obi sl because it was beautiful, perfect even, was I wrong to want for perfection? but I see the truth of this game now, and it is as ugly as jats opinion of everyone who isn't him.

On April 24 2016 00:46 gumshoe wrote:
We've both analyzed the events of that lynch, we've both put together complex cases on it, you have jats vouch but that doesnt count for much as sl has been far more on point this game then him. This isnt a case of your right im wrong.

Both our views our valid, they simply differ, possibly because they must.

Which is all irrelevant for tomorrows lynch. Onegu is dying, do you have a problem with that?

On April 24 2016 00:55 gumshoe wrote:
I refuse to believe that super would claim with a tumble lynch on the table, especially if his team mates were onegu and tumble, because that flat out means he had no control over the lynch.

If tumble had been lynched, super would die the next day, onegu soon after.

It is an awful play that makes no sense no matter how much you insult me.

On April 24 2016 01:05 gumshoe wrote:


I feel the same way about what I'm saying XD I see what your saying, just as you evidently see what I'm saying and dont find it that compelling.

I dont think a scum tumble would waffle on super in that spot just to save rb, that seems like a huge self sacrifice for someone who clearly wanted to play the game, just to save a role that could very well be worthless.

I especially dont think super would claim in that spot if onegu is his team mate, as tumble getting lynched would spell gg for them.

You have points, but I simply dont agree, I see them, I just can easily interpret other reasons for tumbles behavior as he was acting derpy anyways regardless of alignment.

There is enough doubt regarding him he is def worth saving for lylo, where things will be easier to interpret. Which is why I am pushing 1gu so hard / :

On April 24 2016 01:07 gumshoe wrote:

I did not say SL looks bad. And how on earth would you know we lose if you follow me when you do not even know what I will be pushing? What's the point of constantly shitting on my play? Why don't you complain about Obi or SL who both also voted shape and never switched?
Lynch me for it if it bothers you, may as well, well lose if we do what you say anyways.

sl jumping on rb that early is townie actually now that I view it without theory goggles. And I went into a few of his scum games and they are very different from this.

Sl does not look bad at all / :

On April 24 2016 01:11 justanothertownie wrote:

I did not say SL looks bad. And how on earth would you know we lose if you follow me when you do not even know what I will be pushing? What's the point of constantly shitting on my play? Why don't you complain about Obi or SL who both also voted shape and never switched?

On April 24 2016 01:16 gumshoe wrote:


I'll stop shitting, your right, theres no point, but I am fairly sure you'll be pushing tumble, so yeah from my view that would mean gg.

I've given obi and sl a break, they deserve it after escaping from the ruins of my case.

On April 24 2016 01:22 gumshoe wrote:


I am 100 percent tumble is town.

On April 24 2016 01:25 gumshoe wrote:


This is a case of a hole bieng used to bring down a dam, did it introduce a possibility of it not confirming tumble? Yes, was it a large one? Absolutely not.

scum claim with any chance of tumble dying is not a viable move.

With an onegu tumble super scum team, they had no control over the lynch, so even if they thought gb was going to die (which ive shown isnt all that likely) the chance of tumble dying makes it totally not worthwhile.