I did read your filter and it's not obvious what you think. I mean you just said I am being bad, so I must be wrong on most of my reads according to you, not just on yourself if you are town. You were questioning LS a bit earlier, was it based on his responses that you concluded he is "pretty much town"?
Also I don't know how tubesock made into your least of lynches, I guess just by not posting much? And you did like one of his posts, but you chose to vote him to preserve rsoul who wasn't even here defending herself, so I figured you must have had a good town read on her?

Also I don't understand your last sentence.

sandroba

Canada4998 Posts

March 26 2016 14:31 GMT

#1367

Anyway your rels read kinda got me digging more into him and not liking what i saw, so you have that going for ya.

sandroba

Canada4998 Posts

March 26 2016 14:44 GMT

#1370

That's one way of looking at it. Another way is I wasn't here so I couldn't push it harder but I was on her, "top town by many" superbia was on her, "top town by many" jat was considering switching to her and no one had a real reason for lynching tube, but despite all of that she ended up not being lynched.

Also what do you make of the strong hint of I'm blue don't shoot me in her last post? Do you think that's likely a townie mentality at this juncture?

sandroba

Canada4998 Posts

March 26 2016 14:49 GMT

#1371

@vivax what happened to I will lynch rsoul, I might sheep sandroba, just to end up avoiding doing either? Why did you drop off so much after being town read by many based on your entrance?

sandroba

Canada4998 Posts

March 26 2016 15:13 GMT

#1377

no u.

sandroba

Canada4998 Posts

March 26 2016 15:20 GMT

#1381

On March 27 2016 00:15 justanothertownie wrote:

Show nested quote +

Just pretend he doesn't exist.

Are you completely caught up?

Yes, why do you ask?

sandroba

Canada4998 Posts

March 26 2016 15:32 GMT

#1385

@rels nope I found it manually. Most hosts don't update their front post that quickly so I never really bother to use it.

@jat ? I had limited time with day 1 and honestly I'm not underwhelmed by my content even disregarding that. I don't always have an awesome case day1, nor my analysis is always clever, but I think it has a good chance of being right regardless. I see no reason to change my angle just yet. I've tried looking at things from different angles and they don't seem to fit as nicely as my current thoughts, so i don't see a reason to post thoughts that I don't think are correct.

sandroba

Canada4998 Posts

March 26 2016 15:44 GMT

#1388

koshi you are the only person I see calling rsoul obvious town. And vivax did drop off and what I pointed out is 100% correct and if you are town you should be concerned about his alignment. second sentence is just straight out a lie, I am trying to solve the game and I did give reads on pretty much everyone in this game. Dunno wtf you mean by "only gives info away".
And I do believe ritoky to be town almost 100% and rsoul made it clear she believed ritoky to be almost sure mafia and somehow you are not picking on that.
Only problem is I think you are so bad at this game and has some sort of beef with me I'm not sure you are mafia based of this post.

sandroba

Canada4998 Posts

March 26 2016 16:06 GMT

#1391

I have a bit of meta on kurumi. He used to be very trolly as town and not so much as mafia, but he made a change in his last games as town. His behavior here reminds me of how he behaved in merc mini mafia and he got a bit of flak for it. Anyway the actual content of his posts is actually pretty decent, he has some well thought out points, despite being his tone coming of as a bit more serious than the situation calls for at some parts, but from what I remember that is just his style. I don't see anyl reason to consider him for lynching so far.

sandroba

Canada4998 Posts

March 26 2016 16:08 GMT

#1392

I added a random "being" in a sentence after reformulating it many times sigh

sandroba

Canada4998 Posts

March 26 2016 22:20 GMT

#1453

-_-
I shot stutters. Apparently mafia made no kills or they got blocked / protected.

sandroba

Canada4998 Posts

March 26 2016 22:30 GMT

#1461

Because I pussied out. Also because there are no activity requirements and people are not going to get modkilled, so I figured spending the day lynching rsoul would be more productive than lynching one random inactive.

sandroba

Canada4998 Posts

March 26 2016 23:33 GMT

#1506

I think it's unlikely SL is lying about the vet thing here. Even if let's suppose mafia witheld their shot so sicklucker could claim vet, it's very risky that town has a vet and finds SL claims suspicious and then he would be fucked for no benefit. Most likely mafia did shoot and their target didn't die, so if SL is mafia it's even riskier to claim because they know for a fact one or more people survived a shot somehow, so vet is very likely.
SL is very very likely town unless some sort of cc happens.

sandroba

Canada4998 Posts

March 26 2016 23:34 GMT

#1507

@TT the reason I didn't shoot you instead was because you said you were page 45 and catching up, I'm interested in hearing your thoughts.

sandroba

Canada4998 Posts

March 26 2016 23:38 GMT

#1510

@LS since you seem so sure rsoul is town it should be easier for you to come up with some sort of mafia team that doesn't include her, or even a single person you suspect of being mafia instead. I can't find any clue on your filter of who you think is mafia.

sandroba

Canada4998 Posts

March 26 2016 23:45 GMT

#1511

I really like points 6 and 7.

sandroba

Canada4998 Posts

March 27 2016 00:53 GMT

#1528

@rsoul if you are town we are in a really bad spot, since I really think you are mafia and multiple people I think are town do as well. Also your assertion that ritoky is scum is getting old and needs to be more substanciated if you are going to insist on it. Honestly this short rebutal post helps with nothing, if you are town you need to be doing a ton of work and shitting rainbows. Probably claiming as well.

sandroba

Canada4998 Posts

March 27 2016 01:11 GMT

#1532

His plan is too stupid to come from mafia, he seemed too proud of it to be mafia, him coming out and bragging about his plan after a townie just got shot is too balsy to be mafia, multiple posts from him I find thoughtfull and none sound fake to me.
What makes you so sure he is mafia? All I can read is that you think he could do that plan thing as mafia, which doesn't make him mafia at all. He is right that you are not considering anything else and is tunneled on this idea without adding any other value to the thread. You can't say he is mafia for having a scum read on you because I'm town and I do as well, calling it BS doesn't make it go away.
Suppose you are wrong about ritoky, who is mafia?
If you are town you should be in a unique position to analyse day 1 wagons, should maybe start with that?

sandroba

Canada4998 Posts

March 27 2016 01:30 GMT

#1534

That comment is precious coming from someone who said:

On March 27 2016 09:10 Tumblewood wrote:
My inner contrarian wants to think "come on, this is too perfect, this can't be right" but last time I saw a case as good as ritoky's was when Trfel nailed me as scum. I am actually totally okay with sheeping that read.

It looks like the kind of hypocrisy present on your comments last game questioning my motives when I was lynching FF last game and you were scum.