Newbie Student Mafia XIX - Page 28

On January 28 2016 18:18 PepperMintTea wrote:
At this point I am fairly happy with these people in my town house. Darth,Shapelog,MexicanAlien,Alur,Eden.

Then I have nooniansong who honestly I haven't tried to read so far. I was aware that I may not be objective trying to read him as they were pushing me. Either way unlikely to get lynched and I have no reason to so just going to ignore that today.

Yesterday I listed who I would potentially lynch but I want to refine that list somewhat and give some more detailed reasoning.

Onegu - I mentioned early on that I was wary reading Onegu one way or the other. What struck out to me was an inconsistency on his read of me and the follow up. The relevant posts are given here.

+ Show Spoiler +

Essentially he calls me "scummy as hell" based on the points raised by nooniansong but actually noon only raised one , pretty weak , point that Onegu agreed with.
Onegu also didn't read correctly, I had Shapelog as town and he said I was calling Shapelog scummy.

I want to read him one more time and see cases against him but ... i'd be ok lynching him at this point.


Tumblewood - I typically don't like early list posts the main thing is the Onegu read switch he came up with and how it came about. Essentially I find it hard to understand that he saw onegu do some towny stuff early, and make a good case but calls him scum. ..perhaps just sheeping thread opinion.
When you compare it to people he calls town and the reasons he gave there...

@Tumblewood - Can you explain what it is you didn't like about Onegu's big post, give some examples.

I need to read over his responses and I am aware that it is tempting to lynch someone you "caught out" just to seem clever... but at this point I would lynch Tumblewood,

Trefl - I liked Eden's catch about his flip flop on Tumble ... but I have nothing by myself and again I want to read things more carefully...I probably wouldn't lynch trefl though over anyone else in this list

The rest of the pack are basically inactives who I would happily lynch

JesusIncarnate - Superficial list posts early on with surface reads. No explanations or follow up. Woefully inactive
LYNCH

Kuragari - Inactive, got himself into a horrible mess trying to pressure darth which was just terrible. Felt like "talking just to talk"
Hasn't done anything else so would lynch

Iki - inactive for ever, then big list post. Seems to contain a lot of backdoors as pointed out by eden, played the newbie card. would Lynch.

I'm going to go over this at lunch, reading tumble and onegu and will give updates then

If you feel strongly about any of these or have further cases I would like to read them.

I have about 15 mins for questions.

On January 29 2016 00:22 PepperMintTea wrote:




The best thing the two of you can do is convince us you are town rather than just sitting there waiting to answer questions.

On February 10 2016 03:48 _MexicanAlien wrote:
Just a tip for next time @Shape
Maybe you've already worked this out now, but even if she got modkilled, it wouldn't change anything. It would be the same as if we lynched her. She would either be town or scum. Same as lynch.