He told the FFA picks to grab a role ahead of them that was already picked.

So for instance, koshi picks Link to make sure geript picked Link. kita picks arrow to make sure palmar is arrow, and damdred picks house to make sure breshke is house.

In 99% of cases, koshi, kita, and damdred are now mysterious challengers because Occam's razor tells us that they're going to pick what they say.

I suggest that we grab three super power roles instead that were omitted from his list and suddenly I'm undermining his plan.

This post is boring.

ObiWanShinobi

United States8089 Posts

January 21 2016 00:18 GMT

#1417

Sorry for the role steal Damdred - I actually think you're more likely town after all that craziness.
:/

ObiWanShinobi

United States8089 Posts

January 21 2016 00:24 GMT

#1425

On January 21 2016 09:20 Damdred wrote:
Its ok someone stole doc from me to -_-

ObiWanShinobi

United States8089 Posts

January 21 2016 00:25 GMT

#1427

Alright, so a quick recap of where I stand readswise and where we should move from here:

Scum - Glowingbear: I don't think GB would be this apathetic as town so I can only assume that he's mafia. I simply don't see him looking at this game and going "I'll just pick whatever and town will do whatever," especially considering his forceful personality. I expect more from him.

Cephiro - Moved down a notch behind glowingbear. Still seems relatively useless and irrelevant, even with his supposed cooperation earlier.

Kita - Could be scum. His constant attack of Palmar over things rather than trying to push his plan forward reeks of scum motivation - looks like scum trying to unsettle our town leader instead of trying to move us in a positive direction.

Damdred - The only reason I put Damdred on this list is because I had him as scum earlier. He probably isn't - I think his backtrack on his role choice (which was abrupt and would have infuriated anyone) was relatively townie, and his decision to move to doctor seemed very natural based on what was happening.

This is currently where I'm at scumwise.

ObiWanShinobi

United States8089 Posts

January 21 2016 00:26 GMT

#1429

On January 21 2016 09:25 Damdred wrote:
I'm just joking I'm normal doctor.

Now I'll start getting reads formatively anyway

-.-

ObiWanShinobi

United States8089 Posts

January 21 2016 00:27 GMT

#1430

I'm aware that scum!Damdred could have theoretically swapped to doctor at the last second for whatever reason, but I see no reason to believe that anyway.

ObiWanShinobi

United States8089 Posts

January 21 2016 00:34 GMT

#1433

On January 21 2016 09:29 Keirathi wrote:

Show nested quote +

I mean, what would you expect him to do if he is scum? If you're already picking his role, he can either play nice and switch, or random into mysterious and be vengeful and probably get lynched for it. The smart thing to do as town OR scum would be to switch I think.

Let me elaborate a bit since this seems skin deep:
I think Damdred's emotions were far more telling wrt his alignment rather than what he, on the surface, did.

His demeanor changed rather dramatically when people started reigning him in and telling him why doctor was a good pick for him, which seemed townie. I don't think scum!Damdred would change his outlook like that that quickly - it seemed like a real person reacting to a situation in exactly how I would expect him to act.

ObiWanShinobi

United States8089 Posts

January 21 2016 00:36 GMT

#1440

So Damdred is off my list for the moment.
I'm also relatively confident in my kita read so that's also something for all of us to consider.

ObiWanShinobi

United States8089 Posts

January 21 2016 00:39 GMT

#1444

On January 21 2016 09:35 kitaman27 wrote:

Show nested quote +

Umm after Palmar posted his plan, I explained why I thought it could work and what I would suggest to make it better. It was only until later when Palmar made his nonsense response that I started going after it. Your narrative really doesn't fit here.

Let me put it this way - we were scrambling around and talking about who should get what and you're busy talking about a lynch that isn't happening for another 48 hours.

My biggest concern was that we had a last minute scramble and you were just kind of walling up about Palmar being mafia where we were concerned about losing access to several power roles.