If oo is confirmed town, you're wrong on at least 1 of your POE. Instead of trying to reconsider, or make any sort of case for why onegu or myself are scum, you resort to suggesting a plynch late in the game, then backtrack and say you're not serious. You think. So what do you gain from posting any of that?

You scummed me after our interaction d1/n1, can't remember, but it was Damn early and only recently started to waffle between exo and myself. But I've been in a bunch of your poe lately, which makes me wonder why you'd mention a plynch instead of casing scum.

And you rushing me to respond to you is trash, since my last response was to Damdred and was a post before yours. I'm phone posting, I'm not going to immediately respond to everything at once.

you need to chill out bro. We can be friends and still be on opposite alignments, right?
ya sorry I rushed you. I thought you ignored me.

Yes I realize my PoE from earlier is wrong. You wanted me to post another one right away? That would have made me look townier?
"let's plynch onegu" - You are implying that I was serious. Can you think a few levels deep on this one and reconsider?
You ask, what do I gain from posting that? Nothing. But what do I gain as scum? Also nothing.
Obviously people aren't going to want to "plynch" this late in the game. So that wording had to be snarky and not genuine. Do I want to lynch onegu over you or exo? I don't know. Right now I'm thinking you are the best lynch and I might have to hard defend exo today. But I'm not sure before I filter dive or talk to you guys more.

nooniansoong

1538 Posts

January 09 2016 00:27 GMT

#4598

On January 09 2016 09:25 ExO_ wrote:
Onegu
Kush
Damdred -- Town
OO -- Town
ExO -- Town
Ritoky
OWS -- Town
Shining -- Town
Palmar

3 scum slots for 4 players: Palmar/Ritoky/Kush/Onegu Out of these 3 names, there are 4 scum. And I guess there's an incredibly off chance Damdred is scum. If he is scum, he fooled me well.

WHy is shining for likely town than damdred?

nooniansoong

1538 Posts

January 09 2016 00:28 GMT

#4600

*why is shining more likely scum than damdred?

nooniansoong

1538 Posts

January 09 2016 00:34 GMT

#4602

On January 09 2016 09:28 The Shining wrote:
(1)Why are you concerned with what would make you look townier if you think I'm scum?
(2)You also didn't say plynching was a joke until you were called on it. It could very well have been a temperature check to see if anyone would roll onboard with it and lynch onegu. That's what you gain as scum.

And no, nothing is obvious when I've seen town do pretty dumb things before. I guess we can talk more after you filter dive, or have anything else to add.
(3)I do find it interesting that you don't comment on me being right about you claiming I was scum since our first interaction, though, then subsequently waffling.

I added numbers to your quote.

1 I am concerned with what YOU think would make me look townier because I am concerned with what YOU think would makes me look scummy. I am trying to see if your reads look genuine or made up.
So why is it scummy that I did not list a PoE right after flip? is what im trying to get at. Why would it have been townier if I had?

2 In your experience, do people usually label their jokes?
"Let's plynch onegu."
"BTW guys that was a joke lol"

3 that is a completely accurate description of my read towards you this game. It makes me scummy how?

nooniansoong

1538 Posts

January 09 2016 00:35 GMT

#4605

omg i fucked up saying this 2 times lol.

Why is shining more likely town than damdred?

nooniansoong

1538 Posts

January 09 2016 00:44 GMT

#4613

oh god i hope i don't have to hard defend exo lol. that's liek giving a porcupine a blowjob.

nooniansoong

1538 Posts

January 09 2016 01:49 GMT

#4623

yo shining. I'm thinking you are probably town, too. Just from how carefully you are considering your reads and shit. My case on you? I don'tknow. Just things I've commented on throughout the game. Like remmeber all that shit I said to you? Put that together and that's my case. But yeah I've never even filtered you.
Exo has said a lot of shit that has made me think he's town, too, though. You want specifics? I cant really give them atm.

So who the fuck is scum them... palmar or ritoky or some shit. but i townread them too. so basically I'm lost until I put some more time into this game. I should probably shut up until I do that but im drunk.

nooniansoong

1538 Posts

January 09 2016 03:14 GMT

#4625

On January 09 2016 11:57 ritoky wrote:
oo, why did you claim 4 minutes before the phase change? why threaten your own safety if the mafia team is paying attention at the deadline when you can claim 4 minutes later and not risk death/town losing the chance to extend the game?

how can the claim be false?

nooniansoong

1538 Posts

January 09 2016 04:11 GMT

#4628

On January 09 2016 13:01 ritoky wrote:
what does he have to lose in that scenario? he is getting lynched, so he claims jk (maybe as rc). if everyone buys it and jk doesn't cc's (which they shouldn't) the mafia pulls their teammate who was going to get lynched off the table. if the jk ccs they identify and eliminate the only way town can extend the game. you should not be blindly buying that claim.

jk should deifnitely CC. we don't need a jk as much as we need to hit scum.

nooniansoong

1538 Posts

January 09 2016 04:13 GMT

#4629

nvm it's not lylo right. you're right jk shouldn't CC. but oo is still off the table.

nooniansoong

1538 Posts

January 09 2016 04:14 GMT

#4630

JK ccs when
1 lylo
2 JK might get lynched.

And we kill OO only whne
1 JK ccs
2 JK gets nked

nooniansoong

1538 Posts

January 09 2016 04:15 GMT

#4632

either way, what is the point of pushing him like this?
nothing says or does matters anymore

nooniansoong

1538 Posts

January 09 2016 20:01 GMT

#4650

onegu, that is actually some very townie paranoia.
Although I think OWS is a check. It's not just that one quote.

obi- your just gonna have to trust me on this one. I have played alot of games with him and for him his contributions are huge and knowledgeable

And we both know OWS's contributions aren't huge and knowledgeable so this must be a check.

nooniansoong

1538 Posts

January 10 2016 16:37 GMT

#4712

I'd feel a lot better about palmar's case if it had quotes in it. I feel like a case like that is often prone to misunderstanding or maybe exo is just a bad scumhunter.

I really need to filter exo before I can put my vote on him. It might be pretty close to EoD though.

I'm in three games right now, two on this site, which was a terrible idea. It's fine during the week because most days at work I have time to fuck around but during the weekend I'm always doing shit so it's hard for me to participate in even one.

nooniansoong

1538 Posts

January 10 2016 21:10 GMT

#4779

im going to placeholder Exo. I might not get a chance to filter.

Exo ritoky maybe as scum.

nooniansoong

1538 Posts

January 10 2016 21:11 GMT

#4785

oh there's a cc?

nooniansoong

1538 Posts