Haunted Mansion Mini Mafia - Page 9

Post a Reply

Prev 1 7 8 9 10 11 28 Next All

Koshi

Belgium38799 Posts

November 27 2015 12:23 GMT

#854

Like a team as Chrom/OO/Evil snowman is still possible. And then we got Onegu/boxerfred/scott as replacements.

Koshi

Belgium38799 Posts

November 27 2015 12:24 GMT

#855

I have no filters here, but I think they could be mafia. bf would play mafia pretty hilariously though.

Koshi

Belgium38799 Posts

November 27 2015 12:47 GMT

#868

On November 27 2015 21:45 GlowingBear wrote:

Show nested quote +

Stop me from lynching who? Koshi or TT?

Because I think that nobody {Koshi} that votes with his scumread {Chrom} and kills a guy that had the exact scumteam as him {Vivax} and let's the Mafia counterwagon to survive {TT} (even tho this very second wagon {TT} has been refused to be voted by the main scumread{Chrom}) should be spared.

Poorly phrased but my bad english isn't on the level where explain this properly, sorry.

In my defense:

I was play Diablo III, Dota 2 and nobody cared about my Chrom push.

Koshi

Belgium38799 Posts

November 27 2015 12:52 GMT

#876

I will somehow try to explain my actions though, cuz in retrospect it was pretty retarded:

When Chrom didn't happen and the votes were 4 vs 4 I just looked at the names Vivax and TT and didn't look at who voted for them, even though I knew Chrom voted Vivax, I forgot it in the moment.

So I thought by myself, who should I kill? And I almost solely based me on the fact marv looked inexplicable townie enough to follow. Even though I yelled he was possible mafia for like a couple hours during the day. So in my head I believed that following marv would lead to more success than to follow the 4 guys on TT.

But like I said, my scumreads were more Chrom, maybe OO and then a shitton of others could be mafia, like TT. I was a HUGE DEFENDER of Vivax during the day as well, so why I voted him away... I don't know. It is almost solely based on the fact I wanted to give marv his flip and the fact TT and Vivax were equals to me in my head at that moment.

...

If TT is mafia and Vivax is town I look pretty bad. Totes agree.
But I wonder if I am lynchable in like 3 days if mafia keeps me alive.
Rarely is the case.

Koshi

Belgium38799 Posts

November 27 2015 12:56 GMT

#877

Yes that is a good point by marv. I was actually trying to push people away from Vivax at some point, so if TT is mafia with me that would not be smart. I think at that point it was obvious my preference was Chrom > TT > Vivax. Even though I didn't talk at all about TT.

Koshi

Belgium38799 Posts

November 27 2015 12:57 GMT

#878

My play actually doesn't make sense as either alignment. So most of the time I am town then.

Koshi

Belgium38799 Posts

November 27 2015 12:58 GMT

#880

Koshi will be Koshi bois.

But seriously... marv can't be mafia or I will be sad.

Koshi

Belgium38799 Posts

November 27 2015 13:19 GMT

#887

I shall read my own filter. It sounds interesting.

Koshi

Belgium38799 Posts

November 27 2015 13:20 GMT

#888

nvm I can't here.

Koshi

Belgium38799 Posts

November 27 2015 13:29 GMT

#890

btw. would be nice if people follow the game after they died for 1 more phase and give like a big post to try to help.

Koshi

Belgium38799 Posts

November 27 2015 13:40 GMT

#896

I agree gb might be mafia.

Koshi

Belgium38799 Posts

November 27 2015 13:41 GMT

#898

On November 27 2015 22:40 marvellosity wrote:

Show nested quote +

i was gonna write some gay erotica

I can read between the lines.

Koshi

Belgium38799 Posts

November 27 2015 14:15 GMT

#904

On November 27 2015 22:59 GlowingBear wrote:
Koshi why am I mafia?

Because you are way to final/certain in your posting already. If I had to give a reason. Too much drama? I can't nail it.

I am far from convinced TT is mafia. Could be though. I should really look who voted Vivax and at what times. Chrom/TT scumteam might be possible, Chrom did lose track of his own game (OO) and went for the vote on Vivax while he had TT and marv as suspicious.

So dnu. It is possible. It's not something I am going to be hunting any time soon. If TT flips mafia I am coolio, but if he will be able to proof himself coming days there is nothing much left of your play tbh.

Koshi

Belgium38799 Posts

November 27 2015 14:17 GMT

#905

"not much left" might be an exaggeration. I don't really know your filter. Like... just from top of my head in 1 phrase:

It seems your play has a very distinct direction. While I don't see how that is possible this game.

Koshi

Belgium38799 Posts

November 27 2015 14:17 GMT

#906

Would be impressive to push mafia agenda this hard though.

Koshi

Belgium38799 Posts

November 27 2015 14:33 GMT

#909

On November 27 2015 06:47 GlowingBear wrote:

Show nested quote +

On November 27 2015 06:43 ANickelDrink wrote:
You're correct sn0 I never said that in as many words.

On November 27 2015 06:30 Koshi wrote:

On November 27 2015 06:13 ANickelDrink wrote:
Koshi can you point out things I've missed on chrome?

-Tictock avoids talking about him even though he does the same thing as GB and vivax

-marv doesn't talk about chrome

-OO gives chrome an easy town read? More of an agreement with GB

-your scumteam in marv/TT/chrome are all on vivax

-Chrome votes with two of his suspects

That's not a bad list tbh but I think it relies too heavily on association.

I'm more uncomfortable about BF being on vivax than anything at this point

On November 27 2015 05:13 Koshi wrote:
Chrom has way more of those really unspoken reads:

On November 25 2015 12:42 Chromatically wrote:

On November 25 2015 12:27 ANickelDrink wrote:
like if it's not alignment indicative then he can't really push the discussion anywhere since there's nowhere for it to go.

If he had just said "I see what you mean but..." instead of "You have a point" it would be saying the same thing, no?

besides he actually said

On November 25 2015 09:04 Tictock wrote:

Gunna put this down as slightly suspect but possibly NAI for now.

I guess my problem with the post is more of the fact that it says nothing at all in so many lines. It's not so much that it's a contradiction -> "gg ez scum", but more of the fact that he says "you might have a point" and then waffles for a while and then says "possibly NAI".

That is mafia knowing he is talking bullshit and then goes "I guess it could be this" (but in practice he knows it isn't)

On November 25 2015 12:37 Chromatically wrote:
sicklucker I'm not sure about. I agree he could be mafia for his push over something which I agree wasn't alignment indicative, but I liked that he didn't back down about it when he came under pressure.

Ticktock I agree with your point, plus he just kind of came in and posted those non-opinions on FF and then peaced out.

Koshi I don't have a read on.

Look at how he talks about sl, same shit again: I can see your point BUT yabbyabbayabba. A townie would not always see 2 sides of the story like Chrom seems to do. Especially at the start of the game.

dnu, looks like he is pushing an agenda with the TT/Vivax stuff as well. Suddenly he jumps on that topic and NOTHING IS LEFT ABOUT HIS OO READ? He doesn't even mention it.

What is your opinion on this?

I see what you mean. I think your first point about him knowing he's talking shit is a better point than him having seen both sides of the story in your second quote. I get that townies don't have info and seeing both sides of the story could be born of extra info but just that he is considering both sides isn't scum indicative imo.

His dropping of OO is kinda odd but it's not like OO is being at all consequential this game. His vote in on a plynch AFKer and he hasn't really brought anything to the table. Either chrome forgot about him or I see your point about those two being partners.

I have to go to work and I start exatcly at deadline.

Koshi you and your 8 page filter have my sword.

##unvote
##vote chromatically

For all the good it will do anyway

At least hammer Tictock first since if chrom is mafia you can associate him with Tictock and Vivax is probably town.

I totally understand why you are upset though. I do see the posts now but I actually kinda skimmed over them because I was so busy playing Diablo.

Let's say I shall not consider the option you are mafia till TT flipped. I will even respect and read all your opinions as it would come from town. And I will obviously follow you and lynch TT if it is ever close tomorrow. Xcept if it between Chrom and TT.