|
United Kingdom36161 Posts
On November 27 2015 21:58 GlowingBear wrote:Show nested quote +On November 27 2015 21:49 marvellosity wrote:
like, when Koshi came back to the thread at some point yesterday.
If koshi is mafia with Tictock. koshi knows tictock is leading the votes and has a good chance of being lynched.
sees a couple of votes on Vivax.
expresses some sadness that Vivax has votes.
doesn't seem very likely.
also Koshi got quite obnoxious about people voting Vivax on the back of what I said. So even though he ended up voting for Vivax, i think it's a really weird way to go about things in the Koshi/TT mafia Vivax town scenario If I got what you said, it's basically too scum to be scum? Because, marv, it also doesn't make sense as town to be sad that Vivax is getting votes but to vote him anyway for all the reasons I've said + he even said before that TT was a slightly better lynch than others It is pretty suicidal as Mafia, yes But it doesn't follow a clear thought process as Town, either. Is your argument that it is a very suicidal play as Mafia?
what koshi just wrote in his post is right though
"it doesn't make sense for either mafia or town so town is more likely"
that's very often true as a general heuristic. townies do do silly things all the time. you should know this, you do silly things :p
whereas mafia know exactly what's up. mafia koshi knows mafia TT is on the block and mafia koshi knows vivax is town. it's much less explainable how bizarre his actions when he is mafia. because he knows everything already.
|
On November 27 2015 21:58 Koshi wrote:
Koshi will be Koshi bois.
But seriously... marv can't be mafia or I will be sad.
No.
I remember two games where Onegu hammered a partner in a similar way you did and I hard defended a partner before he got lynched and got away with the too scummy to be scum.
It wouldn't be the first time someone did that
Anyway, no use discussing this
It's kinda hard to believe that you forgot Chrom was on Tictock when I constantly reminded you of this.
|
United Kingdom36161 Posts
On November 27 2015 22:02 GlowingBear wrote:Show nested quote +On November 27 2015 21:58 Koshi wrote:
Koshi will be Koshi bois.
But seriously... marv can't be mafia or I will be sad. No. I remember two games where Onegu hammered a partner in a similar way you did and I hard defended a partner before he got lynched and got away with the too scummy to be scum. It wouldn't be the first time someone did that Anyway, no use discussing this It's kinda hard to believe that you forgot Chrom was on Tictock when I constantly reminded you of this.
but those examples don't compare well to here
because we're comparing koshi's whole body of play throughout the 2nd 24 hours
but whatever, i don't think i will convince you of this so for now i will stop trying :>
|
On November 27 2015 22:01 marvellosity wrote:Show nested quote +On November 27 2015 21:58 GlowingBear wrote:On November 27 2015 21:49 marvellosity wrote:
like, when Koshi came back to the thread at some point yesterday.
If koshi is mafia with Tictock. koshi knows tictock is leading the votes and has a good chance of being lynched.
sees a couple of votes on Vivax.
expresses some sadness that Vivax has votes.
doesn't seem very likely.
also Koshi got quite obnoxious about people voting Vivax on the back of what I said. So even though he ended up voting for Vivax, i think it's a really weird way to go about things in the Koshi/TT mafia Vivax town scenario If I got what you said, it's basically too scum to be scum? Because, marv, it also doesn't make sense as town to be sad that Vivax is getting votes but to vote him anyway for all the reasons I've said + he even said before that TT was a slightly better lynch than others It is pretty suicidal as Mafia, yes But it doesn't follow a clear thought process as Town, either. Is your argument that it is a very suicidal play as Mafia? what koshi just wrote in his post is right though "it doesn't make sense for either mafia or town so town is more likely" that's very often true as a general heuristic. townies do do silly things all the time. you should know this, you do silly things :pwhereas mafia know exactly what's up. mafia koshi knows mafia TT is on the block and mafia koshi knows vivax is town. it's much less explainable how bizarre his actions when he is mafia. because he knows everything already.
Alright, alright. I'll roll with this
Although I pretty much understand the bolded, I really think these guys shouldn't be spared or you give Mafia a chance to be scummy without being compromised.
But okay for now
+ Show Spoiler + By the way I'm pretty sure I've stopped doing silly things lately 
|
On November 27 2015 22:05 marvellosity wrote:Show nested quote +On November 27 2015 22:02 GlowingBear wrote:On November 27 2015 21:58 Koshi wrote:
Koshi will be Koshi bois.
But seriously... marv can't be mafia or I will be sad. No. I remember two games where Onegu hammered a partner in a similar way you did and I hard defended a partner before he got lynched and got away with the too scummy to be scum. It wouldn't be the first time someone did that Anyway, no use discussing this It's kinda hard to believe that you forgot Chrom was on Tictock when I constantly reminded you of this. but those examples don't compare well to here because we're comparing koshi's whole body of play throughout the 2nd 24 hours but whatever, i don't think i will convince you of this so for now i will stop trying :>
Nah, it's okay, I'm not fully convinced but I can understabd where you're coming from and I'll settle this for now, as there are way better targets anyway
|
United Kingdom36161 Posts
On November 27 2015 22:05 GlowingBear wrote:Show nested quote +On November 27 2015 22:01 marvellosity wrote:On November 27 2015 21:58 GlowingBear wrote:On November 27 2015 21:49 marvellosity wrote:
like, when Koshi came back to the thread at some point yesterday.
If koshi is mafia with Tictock. koshi knows tictock is leading the votes and has a good chance of being lynched.
sees a couple of votes on Vivax.
expresses some sadness that Vivax has votes.
doesn't seem very likely.
also Koshi got quite obnoxious about people voting Vivax on the back of what I said. So even though he ended up voting for Vivax, i think it's a really weird way to go about things in the Koshi/TT mafia Vivax town scenario If I got what you said, it's basically too scum to be scum? Because, marv, it also doesn't make sense as town to be sad that Vivax is getting votes but to vote him anyway for all the reasons I've said + he even said before that TT was a slightly better lynch than others It is pretty suicidal as Mafia, yes But it doesn't follow a clear thought process as Town, either. Is your argument that it is a very suicidal play as Mafia? what koshi just wrote in his post is right though "it doesn't make sense for either mafia or town so town is more likely" that's very often true as a general heuristic. townies do do silly things all the time. you should know this, you do silly things :pwhereas mafia know exactly what's up. mafia koshi knows mafia TT is on the block and mafia koshi knows vivax is town. it's much less explainable how bizarre his actions when he is mafia. because he knows everything already. Alright, alright. I'll roll with this Although I pretty much understand the bolded, I really think these guys shouldn't be spared or you give Mafia a chance to be scummy without being compromised.But okay for now + Show Spoiler + By the way I'm pretty sure I've stopped doing silly things lately
no i agree with you
sometimes scummy things are just, well, scummy
i just think in this particular instance, the way he goes about it. like if you read through his filter from when he made his first post yesterday (Detective Vivax is getting votes  ) and onwards - i just find it hard to believe the scenario you're proposing. in this instance.
|
I shall read my own filter. It sounds interesting.
|
|
|
On November 27 2015 22:08 marvellosity wrote:Show nested quote +On November 27 2015 22:05 GlowingBear wrote:On November 27 2015 22:01 marvellosity wrote:On November 27 2015 21:58 GlowingBear wrote:On November 27 2015 21:49 marvellosity wrote:
like, when Koshi came back to the thread at some point yesterday.
If koshi is mafia with Tictock. koshi knows tictock is leading the votes and has a good chance of being lynched.
sees a couple of votes on Vivax.
expresses some sadness that Vivax has votes.
doesn't seem very likely.
also Koshi got quite obnoxious about people voting Vivax on the back of what I said. So even though he ended up voting for Vivax, i think it's a really weird way to go about things in the Koshi/TT mafia Vivax town scenario If I got what you said, it's basically too scum to be scum? Because, marv, it also doesn't make sense as town to be sad that Vivax is getting votes but to vote him anyway for all the reasons I've said + he even said before that TT was a slightly better lynch than others It is pretty suicidal as Mafia, yes But it doesn't follow a clear thought process as Town, either. Is your argument that it is a very suicidal play as Mafia? what koshi just wrote in his post is right though "it doesn't make sense for either mafia or town so town is more likely" that's very often true as a general heuristic. townies do do silly things all the time. you should know this, you do silly things :pwhereas mafia know exactly what's up. mafia koshi knows mafia TT is on the block and mafia koshi knows vivax is town. it's much less explainable how bizarre his actions when he is mafia. because he knows everything already. Alright, alright. I'll roll with this Although I pretty much understand the bolded, I really think these guys shouldn't be spared or you give Mafia a chance to be scummy without being compromised.But okay for now + Show Spoiler + By the way I'm pretty sure I've stopped doing silly things lately no i agree with you sometimes scummy things are just, well, scummy i just think in this particular instance, the way he goes about it. like if you read through his filter from when he made his first post yesterday (Detective Vivax is getting votes ) and onwards - i just find it hard to believe the scenario you're proposing. in this instance.
Fair enough
|
btw. would be nice if people follow the game after they died for 1 more phase and give like a big post to try to help.
|
I agree that koshi is more likely an idiot
|
Like I have been getting these weird senses that gb is mafia and koshi is town all game. I cant really explain the koshi one because hes an idiot but gb has been so negative and quick to scumread me for small things. I have played so much against gbs mafia and he always does this
|
But gbs actions near deadline makes him the third scum i will catch
|
On November 27 2015 22:35 sicklucker wrote:
Like I have been getting these weird senses that gb is mafia and koshi is town all game. I cant really explain the koshi one because hes an idiot but gb has been so negative and quick to scumread me for small things. I have played so much against gbs mafia and he always does this
Yeah but no, I have fair reasons to scumread you
|
United Kingdom36161 Posts
On November 27 2015 22:29 Koshi wrote:
btw. would be nice if people follow the game after they died for 1 more phase and give like a big post to try to help.
i was gonna write some gay erotica
|
I agree gb might be mafia.
|
United Kingdom36161 Posts
On November 27 2015 22:37 sicklucker wrote:
But gbs actions near deadline makes him the third scum i will catch
what?
which actions?
|
On November 27 2015 22:40 marvellosity wrote:Show nested quote +On November 27 2015 22:29 Koshi wrote:
btw. would be nice if people follow the game after they died for 1 more phase and give like a big post to try to help. i was gonna write some gay erotica
I can read between the lines.
|
United Kingdom36161 Posts
On November 27 2015 22:41 Koshi wrote:Show nested quote +On November 27 2015 22:40 marvellosity wrote:On November 27 2015 22:29 Koshi wrote:
btw. would be nice if people follow the game after they died for 1 more phase and give like a big post to try to help. i was gonna write some gay erotica I can read between the lines.
deal 
|
On November 27 2015 22:40 Koshi wrote:
I agree gb might be mafia.
ROFL
Tell me you aren't serious here.
|
|
|
|
|
|
EPT
