Student Mafia XV

On October 11 2015 03:48 Vivax wrote:
I hope you are not actually VT.

Anyway I don't really get what Eversince is saying. I posted that stuff and I'm apparently mafia, but how is it useless compared to anything else in this game? It's the first read someone busted out.

On October 11 2015 03:53 MoosyDoosy wrote:
Oh yeah and before I forget.

##vote sicklucker

I'm guessing we're using Xatalos's votecount and not a separate voting thread.

On October 11 2015 03:55 Vivax wrote:


And why is mafia likely to do what I did?

@ Onegu

Cause it's a shitty claim if it is real.

On October 11 2015 04:19 MoosyDoosy wrote:

Just a tiny question. What's with your abrupt mood change? Earlier you were so interrogative and now you seem more lighthearted.

On October 11 2015 04:28 KelsierSC wrote:


wow, I liked you and obvious

moosy and vivax i didn't like

is that enough? i can't give more.

On October 11 2015 04:32 KelsierSC wrote:


maybe in like 30 pages I can write up on everyone but for now it will look like dick

"moosy made this post that was sorta weird...so im not a fan" such insight mant detective inspector clause

On October 11 2015 04:38 KelsierSC wrote:


no

On October 11 2015 04:47 MoosyDoosy wrote:
kSC, Vivax, and Kels all look town for now.

On October 11 2015 04:31 KelsierSC wrote:


just an initial feeling.

worst case scenario i'm wrong and you are town?

fuck i dont care

On October 11 2015 04:51 KelsierSC wrote:


let's just wait at this point and let things develop i'll check back in like...15 hours and give some more thoughts

On October 11 2015 05:00 MoosyDoosy wrote:

No, he just said he was an older player so I was wondering if you knew him since I'm relatively new myself

hm...

On October 11 2015 05:11 Onegu wrote:
Last quick thought before bed. The town read on eversince getting more firm. I mean harder. I mean oh nevermind, just a town read.


Also that is one long ass haircut for marv. He needs to do work in this game.

Dunno what to think of moosey. Kinda weird how he jumped on my gum read after kel agreed with it.

Also vivax doesnt know what he is talking about. That claim is legit in how on point it is. Like 360 no scope legit.

On October 11 2015 09:21 Eversince wrote:
What's going on about you read on Moosy?

Also everyone on your scum list except for Vivax seems to be there for lurkin'...
Are they just there for lurkin'?

On October 11 2015 09:47 Vivax wrote:
Eversince the fact that you think everyone who does controverstial stuff is mafia is acceptable for a newbie but it's mostly the other way around.

Mafia doesn't care about having fun or solving the game for the majority of players, Ha. what? The primary goal of mafia is for them to get town to lynch eachother. they just see their shitty PM and know they have to hide something and start trying to play as appeasing as they can without rustling anyone's jimmies

On October 11 2015 10:19 Vivax wrote:


Christ it's not even what I said, she edited the quote

On October 11 2015 10:57 -Celestial- wrote:


Sorry but I can't help but comment on this because I can't get this thought out of my head: all I can think is that you're saying I'm a pirate. X-D

On October 11 2015 10:34 Fecalfeast wrote:

We have many hours until that will happen, what has made you so gung-ho right now?

On October 12 2015 01:26 Onegu wrote:



Or you could just give it but you just vote someone when you don't even mention them in your filter.

On October 10 2015 03:40 Onegu wrote:
FML Marv joined this game. Didn't realize this when I promised him a serious game.

Alright all. Game face on. Prepare yourselves.

On October 11 2015 05:11 Onegu wrote:
Last quick thought before bed. The town read on eversince getting more firm. I mean harder. I mean oh nevermind, just a town read.


Also that is one long ass haircut for marv. He needs to do work in this game.

Dunno what to think of moosey. Kinda weird how he jumped on my gum read after kel agreed with it.

Also vivax doesnt know what he is talking about. That claim is legit in how on point it is. Like 360 no scope legit.

On October 11 2015 17:21 Onegu wrote:



Why does scum OO lie about that though. Unless your point is being he is just making shit up, but from the rest of his post I don't get that sense.

Celestial is looking townie for that huge post but why it has KSC as more town than myself I will never know.

I don't like moosy right now, his jump on gumdrop felt really opportunistic to me.

I still don't like gumdrops entrance at all, and KSC follow up vote was fine for pressure but when mossy jumped on it it just felt wrong to me.

Marv has until 24 hours to impress me before my vote goes on him for being lazy which is something town marv wouldn't do in a newbie game.

Also @celestial didn't we just play in a game and I claimed VT and we went through the same thing.

On October 11 2015 17:39 Onegu wrote:



Oh yeah this for sure I think town but am not listening to her at all about who to Lynch.

On October 12 2015 01:17 Onegu wrote:
Ok moosy is scum.

He goes from

"Kels can you read OO?"

Then OO is in is scum list for no reason

Then a vote for no reason.


Add this to the quick jump on gumdrop after KSC and me was really weird.

##UNVOTE

##Vote: Moosydoosy

On October 12 2015 01:26 Onegu wrote:



Or you could just give it but you just vote someone when you don't even mention them in your filter.

On October 10 2015 19:54 ObviousOne wrote:
Good morning from the east coast of the United States. It has been quite some time since that last time I played mafia here. I'm going to try to write fewer, longer posts for two reasons this game: 1) the conversational style necessitates checking the thread very often and I just bought Cities: Skylines which literally makes hours disappear into the void, and 2) I literally don't want to further encourage entire pages of single line posts that end up with 200+ page games.

With all that out of the way, I would like to say hello again to some, and to welcome newer players.

On October 10 2015 19:56 ObviousOne wrote:
As a side note I just wrote literally twice, and that's now bothering me. That's what I get for writing without coffee or nicotine in me.

On October 10 2015 20:41 ObviousOne wrote:

I will indulge of course when I return to analyse and contribute if the question is still relevant at the time, but will include the response as part of the one or two posts I make at that time. Posting less often but with more content should help to both consolidate my thoughts and continue to take the long view of the game over time. It plays well into my typical starting strategy which relies more heavily process of elimination and goes through many iterations.

Regarding my break, I stopped playing because I wasn't having fun. The threads get really long and reading them was tedious. Also, I used to be able to participate conversationally when I would go outside for a cigarette and I no longer smoke, meaning fewer check-ins. Coincidentally quitting cigarettes also kind of changed who I was a little bit, in a way that was real but also inexplicable, and I stopped enjoying some of the things I use to love and vice versa. I did play a few games on another site in the interim but the activity there is borderline (think maybe 200 posts for a day 1) which is really easy to keep up with and was a decent place to utilize my POE strategy without feeling like I couldn't contribute.

On October 10 2015 22:21 ObviousOne wrote:

It's the first sentence of my response. You didn't even have to read the whole wall of text you could just have read the first sentence. Spooky. "When I return" + "one or two posts at that time". Unless you're asking me when I'm coming back to the thread, in which case I can give you a detailed schedule and link you to my google calendar so you can know when I'm at the movies or masturbating, if that's what you want. Heh.

On October 11 2015 03:05 ObviousOne wrote:

A long time ago when I first started playing here, Vivax had quite the silly streak. That went away after a while. Maybe he's just having a bit of silly-mode in the vein of meta-game, this being a game with coaches. In any case, I agree it's not alignment indicative but I appreciate the thought you've given it.


Prickly seems to be my natural state. It's also something that happens when people come at me when I'm town.

Obviously if you dislike my activity levels you might try to have me lynched for it as is your right to suggest, but I'm not sure why it's a topic of discussion mere hours into the game. You could just wait and see. Promising that I'm going to post X amount of times is quite silly.

On October 11 2015 10:08 ObviousOne wrote:
Just gonna pop through four filters in order on the list.

Onegu: liking how comfortable he seems with the thread. Can possibly agree with gumdrop lynch but willing to extend benefit of the doubt regarding gumdrop to see what is said. Would not lynch.

Gumdrop: waiting for the return of the jedi. Could lynch.

Eversince: I understand the confusion with vivax she has. Vivax has seemed to finally switched off his troll mode from speed reading the thread. Thinking that Vivax was intentionally trying to disrupt things by saying nothing is natural for someone not familiar with him. Let's see where Vivax goes from here. Would not lynch.

TheShining: AWOL

Okay, I guess I'll do a few more this is easy.

Kelsiersc: Sheeping Onegu on the gumdrop thing entirely. Gumdrop would definitely be a convenient target for scum in this scenario and sheeping keeps any potential backlash off KSC. Also the Moosy feel for his other scum read is basically a reply to my post regarding activity. Seems picked out at random and the post overall has very little conviction. Potential lynch candidate.

Celestial: voting the AWOL guy. Has a big paragraph by my name that could have just said NAI. [association based on unflipped players ahead has KSC, the other guy I find scummy, in his leaning town list. Potential lynch candidate.

Fecal: unremarkable at this moment other than the obvious vivax stuff. Probably not a lynch candidate.

Marv: being marv, not ready to say anything just yet.

Sicklucker: seems pretty happy with himself and situation. Spouting off. I like it. Not a lynch candidate.

Stoicism: seemed pretty interested in me, really wanted to interact with me but hasn't shown up since our little scuffle. Seemed like he was trying to have a conversation about nothing with me. Potential lynch candidate.

Moosy: actually some good feels, though potential helpful-townie-scummer vibe but not really likely. Not a lynch candidate.

So there you go. Scumreads: KSC/Celestial and one of stoic/shining/gumdrop. If I were to vote right now it would be KSC so I will do just that.

##vote KelsierSC

Okay that's what I got. Gonna watch some TV now.

You're welcome.

On October 11 2015 10:21 ObviousOne wrote:

In what way do you mean. If youre talking about my comment regarding stoic it's that he was pretty up in my face about me being accessible to him, which of course stemmed from him not being to read my post properly in the first place, and ended up not being here all day anyway.

On October 12 2015 01:48 ObviousOne wrote:

Scum OO tries very hard to be accurate as possible so there's no blowback early. I was in a rush to get around to watching a backlog of TV episodes so one "mistake" which relates to looking at things outside the context of the thread is the opposite of a scum tell for me.

In any case, Stoic is off my list for possible candidates for today.

I don't like excuses like "I was drunk" like if you can't just play when you're sober then you're mafia covering for your inactivity. KSC vote stays.

Agree that Marv's working his way to candidacy today.

On October 12 2015 04:22 The Shining wrote:
Hi I'm here. The BIGBANG concert was awesome, KPop is life, but I got home way too late to do anything but sleep last night before work.

I'm prob gonna be useless for the next couple hours while I catch up and check filters but I'll be here all day since I get to play from work. Also, "Hi and welcome" to the newbies and "hello I'm probably going to want to lynch you" to the people I've played with before lol

On October 10 2015 20:39 marvellosity wrote:

i foolishly booked a haircut for soon so gonna miss a ton as well :/

On October 11 2015 06:20 marvellosity wrote:
page 14 and i don't think much of anything, except i'm slightly in love with Eversince

On October 11 2015 06:27 marvellosity wrote:

he is not.

but gumdrop does gumdrop things.

On October 11 2015 06:30 marvellosity wrote:
oh yeah, for those who are curious about my extremely long haircut, that was a haircut into a long lunch into coffee into workout into dinner into shower into sitting here talking about what i did today.

and obviously i don't use a barber

On October 11 2015 06:32 marvellosity wrote:

^ this wasn't actually an answer to moosy, only just saw his post because it got quoted.

when i have opinions other than what i've written i'll proffer them

i'm good like that

On October 11 2015 09:30 -Celestial- wrote:
No...like I said: Gumdrop is there for making something of a promise to do something and then doing jack all (if you want to call that lurking then fine, but I tend to identify lurking as just not saying anything, not making a grand positive statement and then sitting back as if you've done your job already).

marvellosity on the other hand actually has something of a filter, but there's sod all in it. His entire filter amounts to this:
I'm going for a haircut, I'll miss stuff.
Don't think of anything so far except I love Eversince.
Lol, nice one, Eversince.
Lol, Gumdrop.
I don't like sicklucker going on Eversince for basically nothing (which I agree with but whatever, its an easy comment to make).
My haircut stuff!
Moosy challenged me about my Gumdrop comment so I'll back down.
I don't have any more opinions.
Random stuff.

On October 12 2015 05:25 -Celestial- wrote:


Because he's been AWOL for 22 hours now with his last post being "wibble".

Frankly if he actually turns up and doesn't get some damn good things done I'd be very tempted to drop my vote on him. If he DOESN'T turn up then he'll probably get modkilled at this rate.

On October 12 2015 06:06 The Shining wrote:
I hate doing list posts but it is what it is. This is what I get for starting late, I guess.

Town
Eversince - pretty active in the game with a clear train of thought in every direction she's going. Especially that WoT. I would be very surprised if newbie scum is taking notes and making point after point and being transparent in their reads. She also addresses almost everyone so far, and wants to lynch a few, so there's no buddying or pocketing from what I can see. I would like her to give a read on Stoicism, though, I don't remember seeing that.

Moosy - Town, methinks. I'm not really sure where Onegu got the idea that he was voting for OO for no reason after reading Moosys filter. It seemed to follow a solid train of thought and he mentioned OO and questioned him before voting him. I don't really like him admitting to actively lurking but its something I'll let slide for now because I agree with his OO read and I don't think scum would set themselves up to be scrutinized hard by admitting that.

Probably town
Kels - its mostly a toneread tbh but his honesty and willingness to answer ES even when he didn't have much to go off of just reads as townie to me. And his later post giving reads and giving thoughts on the Vivax - SL interaction looked good, and most of the reads correlate with mine.

Celestial - again I hate list posts but I know its her(are you a girl or did I make a fool of myself? o.o) style and the reads were actually fleshed out, both in the list post and the few posts afterwards. She also picked up on some of the same things from Moody's filter that I did, although admittedly some of that goes out the window once Moosy himself said he wasn't actively in the thread the way his filter made it seem. (Speaking of which, how the hell did he even do that? That's some voodoo or some shyt)

Null
Sicklucker - I felt like he was townie at times last game when I rolled scum with him lol. I've never been able to read him. If I read his filter on any other player, I'd probably lean slightly town but since it's SL, I'd much rather someone better than I could help me flesh this one out. I do like that he caught Vivaxs weird read on him but someone said last game that his reads were very SL-centric, which seems to be the case here, and he was scum.

Vivax - the SL are you drunk thing was weird and I found myself agreeing with ES's request to post something of value. However, he stepped it up a bit after and considering I think both OO and Fecal could be scum, I have trouble thinking he'd be bussing either. I need to see more from him, though, before I can town him.

Onegu - somewhat bare filter. His VT claim is nai, he does it every game. He calls ES an RSoul smurf so he's aware of how ES is playing but I saw no read on ES. Then he tunnels into Moosy after hinting at not liking him early, then invites him for Marv. And comes back with a post saying he has nothing to comment on. But he hasn't commented on much to begin with. Moar reads a d do moar stuff pls, or this will shift into scum territory.

Stoicism - short filter with a few questions and poking at the thread, which I like. But he asked SL to discuss his Moosy read with him and was never heard from again. I need to see more from him.

Possible scum
FecalFeast - Super underwhelming. I found his joke post of "worried about appearance obvious mafia" kind of ironic since he states in his very next post that Vivax is as underwhelming as he is, which shows he is quite aware of how he looks in-thread. Also, most of his reads don't seem to lean very strongly either way which leaves a lot of wiggle room. Gums opening is awkward but not screaming scummy, wants OO to come back to confirm suspicion, Moosy is posting fine things but has the ability to play scum well. His eye is on vivax but he's just as bad. That's scumming yourself by default lol. And believing Vivaxs scum claim is just bad. I've seen vivax just roll over and die as scum but I haven't seen him outright claim it.

ObviousOne - I really hate self-meta so that's a negative for me. He isn't reading or paying attention, or he would've realized Celestials vote on me was pregame as a joke. Instead he misrepresents Celestial by saying she's voting the AWOL guy. His list post looked pretty yucky and he landed on Kelsier, one of my probtowns after making an unflipped association note between him and Celestial. But why is Kelsier a better lynch than Celestial? He doesn't say. And he says he could lynch Gumdrop waiting on reurn of the Jedi? But Marv is gone too but he's just being Marv. His reads just don't add up to me.

Marv - one page filter Marv in a newbie game is not town Marv. Super underwhelming and nothing of substance in his filter. He once asked if I was so unmotivated to solve the game as town and the answer was no becasue I was scum. Now I'm asking the same question. Why is he so unmotivated this late into a newbie game if he's town?

Plynch
Gumdrop - this one is pretty obvious and has been talk of the town so I won't go too much into it. Scum has trouble entering and participating in the thread, but from the game I played with Gumdrop, that one post isn't enough to be scum. It's more policy territory for me but I'd like to see if Gum actually gives us something to work with before jumping on that wagon.

On October 11 2015 10:14 Fecalfeast wrote:


A list post featuring boring indications of thinking too hard about how you're perceived. Honestly I think your 'new tactic' is just an easy way to pay less attention. You initially made it seem like you were going to use your fewer posts to portray more complex ideas but so far they have all contained filler and snippets from your real life. Your list here is exactly what a cursory look at everyone's filter would provide without any context whatsoever as though you haven't actually read the thread in order but felt the need to post.

I'm not a fan so far

On October 12 2015 07:39 The Shining wrote:


Because you didn't say heya. You said my post has many things wrong and up to this point, still haven't explained how,outside of stating some of it is reiterations or summaries. Which is pretty ironic because if theyre reiterations, that makes them right, not wrong. It implies I read the thread. Lmao keep it up.

And this continued misrepresentation of my anger and the reasons for it and acting like you're some saint that can do no wrong is really starting to piss me off. Vivax calling you town pain in the ass is 100% correct.

On October 12 2015 06:55 Eversince wrote:


So many thing wrong with this post.
I volunteer myself for much conversation with the propagator.

On October 12 2015 08:05 The Shining wrote:
Yup my concert was much more important and more fun than this game.
I posted my reads and got attacked for them. When you asked me to discuss them, you did so very vaguely while calling my post bad. Instead of telling me WHICH reads you want me to explain(since they all have nice little paragraphs next to them), you decide to just keep saying "explain your reads, explain your reads.". EXPLAIN WHAT ABOUT MY READS? WTF DO YOU WANT TO KNOW ABOUT THEM? THEYRE THERE. PICK SOMETHING AND ASK ABOUT IT INSTEAD OF JUST TALKING ME AROUND IN FUCKING CIRCLES.

I HAVE BEEN TALKING TO YOU. THIS ENTIRE TIME. YOU HAVENT ASKED ME A SINGLE GAME RELATED THING. YOU JUST SAY MY POST IS BAD AND MY READS ARE STRANGE BUT DONT ASK ANYTHING ABOUT THEM. YOU KEEP HARPING ON MY ANGER, WHICH I FEEL IS JUSTIFIED OVER HOW USELESS YOUR LINE OF questioning is since you're going absolutely nowhere with it and now you vote me. And my caps lock button got stuck there but I don't feel like retyping this post so w.e.

Vote me, lynch me, idgaf. I sincerely hope I'm wrong and you're not town because you're going to get blamed for this mislynch if I get lynched. And quite frankly, getting me out of this game is a blessing so w.e

On October 12 2015 08:24 The Shining wrote:
Last post was towards OO.

Moosy, yeh. I'm a VIP fanboy.

ES, I reread all of my posts before I post them for typos. No regrets here. I don't actually care if I'm lynched because survival isn't my wincon. I do hope I'm wrong in my townread of you if you do get me lynched because if I'm right, and you are town as well, scum will set you up by blaming you for my mislynch. And yes, getting me out of this newbie game is a blessing for me because I don't want to play with someone who calls my post bad but refuses to ask anything about it or be specific at all. In essence, you asking me to explain my reads without asking for which reads to explain means you want me to re do my entire reads post. That is redundant. But you didn't care enough to ask me to do so from the beginning so I have a low opinion of you now. It is what it is.

On October 12 2015 09:08 The Shining wrote:
I've never been a fan of day one or particularly good at it in these types of setups. I prefer VCAs and filter dives after the first flip. Unfortunately not playing D1 puts me at risk of being mislynched so I've tried to play but every time I do so, someone calls my posts bad so I resort to one liners and quips. I'm sorry if that's taking a toll on you, OO.

ES, I'm torn. On the one hand, I'm starting to get a sick satisfaction from your tunnel on me but on the other hand, Marv is one of my actual scumread. Why u do this to me??

Marv with a one page filter is not town Marv. He has the potential to lead and carry town when he actually cares about the game. He even raised suspicion on me when no one else would early in my last scum game. At the risk of you telling me I'm just reiterating what's already been said(Celestials post), it just doesn't look like town Marv.

His entrance is weak. His catch up post gets us nowhere(he's in love with you apparently) and he defends Gumdrop strangely, I.e. gumdrop does Gumdrop things when literally everyone else has Gum as scum or plynch. He says SLs reaction to you was totally beyond him, but doesn't say whether that makes SL scum or not. So another useless post.

And he apparently doesn't have any opinions outside of what I've just summarized, or else he would have offered them, which means he's not interested in solving the game. Not interested in solving the game = scum. He even said so himself last game.

On October 12 2015 09:23 sicklucker wrote:


lol still waiting. so I think its better to lynch this guy and give marv another 24 hours. as the game stands

On October 12 2015 09:55 The Shining wrote:
Actually, ES, give me a holler when you're back. I want to know how you went from this:



Where you are agreeing with me to me being refuse again. Make up your mind, ya?

And rereading it, i dont get why you would say you don't care about pursuing opinions from me right after you ask me for one and even agree with it. This makes absolutely no sense. If I'm trash or scum, you shouldn't agree with me, nor should you be asking my opinion and then subsequently saying you don't care about my opinion.

TLDR: "give me opinion on Marv->I agree about Marv->I don't care about pursuing your opinions->Shining you're refuse"

???????

On October 12 2015 10:27 -Celestial- wrote:


Don't worry about it. I bet I'd look great in a frilly dress anyway, so call me what you want.

On October 12 2015 11:54 MoosyDoosy wrote:

Would it be too obvious that I'm trying to get you to lynch Shining if I called you beautiful? o:

On October 12 2015 07:58 Eversince wrote:
How much more clear can I possibly make myself?
You've been gone for 'extended period of time'
You post very, very very! generic reads that literally have nothin' new to add to the game.
I then prod you about it.
You get super upset that I did that and proceed to drive burnin' cattle prod's down on my back.
and you still are.

For no reason. It's so damned much bloody work that you can't talk to me for an hour?
No? That's far to much. You can, however, waste an hour plus fightin' over nothin' with me just to cluster the thread.

Bleh. This guy is obviously scum. I want to lynch him.

##vote The Shining

On October 12 2015 12:19 Fecalfeast wrote:
I mean, don't get me wrong, I like where your case is going moose. Shining's explanation of marv's meta being damning but his weak read on me being based on this game isn't terrible.

I don't like the rage coming from him though. IDK people say getting mad is a towny thing but I disagree

On October 12 2015 12:22 The Shining wrote:
I have nothing to flesh out. Have fun lynching town, baddies and scummers. You've earned it because I'm tilt as fuck and won't be around again.

Deuces.

On October 12 2015 12:35 The Shining wrote:
Nah yall pissed me off, I'm just gonna troll out

ES says if you flip town pls don't then says lynching 100% right after. The bipolarity is outstanding. Make up your mind. You think I'm scum, you shouldn't be telling me what to do "if I'm town" you sound like you don't believe your own scumread

Bad baddie is bad

On October 12 2015 12:40 -Celestial- wrote:


Hey...you're going to make me blush.


Anyway...to play devil's advocate here a bit I have one question to ask about this case against Shining: to what end? What would be the point of Shining's play here? Marv is totally dead in the water. He's not here. He might even get modkilled or replaced if he's not back in time to vote. Its a very, very easy bus to get on as mafia and if he's really not about he's not worth going out of your way to save...better to get the towncred for being on a correct lynch and let everyone WIFOM all over the VCA during night time.

What's the best case scenario here for scumShining and scumMarv with that play? Shining gets FF mislynched and marv either comes back or gets replaced. But because Shining was central to the FF lynch he's under heavy scrutiny and marv (or replacement) is under equal suspicion for doing bugger all for most of D1. They end up as top two high-priority lynch candidates for D2 and when one flips red I think the next gets lynched the day after. Its a hugely risky play.

I mean correct my logic if I'm wrong here, by all means. If you're all certain I guess I'll review Shining's filter tomorrow before the deadline.


I have to go to bed in a minute, its approaching 5am here. We got just over 21 hours before the vote ends by my reckoning so...we'll see what happens. Also a vote count would be great about now so we can see where we are.

On October 12 2015 13:22 The Shining wrote:

.because im just that bad apparently.

OO is probably town or just pocketing me but why pocket prime lynch bait. He can't be scum bcuz the same logic applies to me as ff. He could just pile onto my mislynch but he's taking the analytical approach like he did with ff.

Im pissed because if Moosy is actually town and tunneling, which I'm having trouble believing right now, and ES is town, it means i have 2 votes with ff considering a 3rd. If I'm right on ff and wrong on moosy, it means at least 2 more scum will pile on me for the mislynch, since town Is doing the work for them. That's a potential 5 on me and vivax, onegu, stoic, gum, marv, none of them have been around to comment on me at all.

Good point about the ES antagonism, though, that's Something to look into if/when i flip

On October 12 2015 06:06 The Shining wrote:
I hate doing list posts but it is what it is. This is what I get for starting late, I guess.

Hate it but still doin' it. Intentionally. And he dun' even really hate it. Because he elected to go to said event. (did this later too).

Town
Eversince - pretty active in the game with a clear train of thought in every direction she's going. Especially that WoT. I would be very surprised if newbie scum is taking notes and making point after point and being transparent in their reads. She also addresses almost everyone so far, and wants to lynch a few, so there's no buddying or pocketing from what I can see. I would like her to give a read on Stoicism, though, I don't remember seeing that.

If I'm not the easiest person to place right now, I wanna' be burnt. My "train of thought" has been spread between Toronto and Miami.

Moosy - Town, methinks. I'm not really sure where Onegu got the idea that he was voting for OO for no reason after reading Moosys filter. It seemed to follow a solid train of thought and he mentioned OO and questioned him before voting him. I don't really like him admitting to actively lurking but its something I'll let slide for now because I agree with his OO read and I don't think scum would set themselves up to be scrutinized hard by admitting that.

I've been twistin' my mind over this I voice, but I'm pretty sure he's not dirty. The point is your offer on the topic of Onegu and Obvious, completely recyclable from my own post among others'.

Probably town
Kels - its mostly a toneread tbh but his honesty and willingness to answer ES even when he didn't have much to go off of just reads as townie to me. And his later post giving reads and giving thoughts on the Vivax - SL interaction looked good, and most of the reads correlate with mine.

"Mostly a toneread" I went interpret; you have no actual place for em''? Somebodies offer to chat with me? Bleh friend, that's playin' the game. Followin' with ' playin' it some more'

Celestial - again I hate list posts but I know its her(are you a girl or did I make a fool of myself? o.o) style and the reads were actually fleshed out, both in the list post and the few posts afterwards. She also picked up on some of the same things from Moody's filter that I did, although admittedly some of that goes out the window once Moosy himself said he wasn't actively in the thread the way his filter made it seem. (Speaking of which, how the hell did he even do that? That's some voodoo or some shyt)

'Hates' style o' post "again" Still replied to it. Followin' with a outright claim to be followin' on seemin'ly scraps. You place Moosy over pretense? "Wasnt' actively around the way his filter made to seem?" Argue over this later, you did have a post verifyin' in in this same quote.

Null
Sicklucker - I felt like he was townie at times last game when I rolled scum with him lol. I've never been able to read him. If I read his filter on any other player, I'd probably lean slightly town but since it's SL, I'd much rather someone better than I could help me flesh this one out. I do like that he caught Vivaxs weird read on him but someone said last game that his reads were very SL-centric, which seems to be the case here, and he was scum.

"Bleh, I think he might be any alignment this game, per standard, but just because." "If this was nother' fellow I'd say he's good. But cuz' I know, I think he's real dirty" I really like the end of it (Middle, I ponder,this ; "I'd much rather someone better than I could help me flesh this one out. " is blonkin' gold. So happen', I attempted to do just so, and got I wildly drastic sponse'. I went for a Polar bear and got a pherret. Rats!

Vivax - the SL are you drunk thing was weird and I found myself agreeing with ES's request to post something of value. However, he stepped it up a bit after and considering I think both OO and Fecal could be scum, I have trouble thinking he'd be bussing either. I need to see more from him, though, before I can town him.

I fathom' the strike? I really hope I get to breathe daisies t'day.

Onegu - somewhat bare filter. His VT claim is nai, he does it every game. He calls ES an RSoul smurf so he's aware of how ES is playing but I saw no read on ES. Then he tunnels into Moosy after hinting at not liking him early, then invites him for Marv. And comes back with a post saying he has nothing to comment on. But he hasn't commented on much to begin with. Moar reads a d do moar stuff pls, or this will shift into scum territory.

Rats all to accomplish here. 'Onegu has issue 1, see ya' in room two.

Stoicism - short filter with a few questions and poking at the thread, which I like. But he asked SL to discuss his Moosy read with him and was never heard from again. I need to see more from him.

Possible scum

Panel of I dun' care to discuss. Check Obvious' post too, if I'm rememberin' this right, they through banter bout' for a spell.

FecalFeast - Super underwhelming. I found his joke post of "worried about appearance obvious mafia" kind of ironic since he states in his very next post that Vivax is as underwhelming as he is, which shows he is quite aware of how he looks in-thread. Also, most of his reads don't seem to lean very strongly either way which leaves a lot of wiggle room. Gums opening is awkward but not screaming scummy, wants OO to come back to confirm suspicion, Moosy is posting fine things but has the ability to play scum well. His eye is on vivax but he's just as bad. That's scumming yourself by default lol. And believing Vivaxs scum claim is just bad. I've seen vivax just roll over and die as scum but I haven't seen him outright claim it.

To be honest here, I need to re-write this. I Dun' mean to trip myself between shoelaces before the sun drops under.

ObviousOne - I really hate self-meta so that's a negative for me. He isn't reading or paying attention, or he would've realized Celestials vote on me was pregame as a joke. Instead he misrepresents Celestial by saying she's voting the AWOL guy. His list post looked pretty yucky and he landed on Kelsier, one of my probtowns after making an unflipped association note between him and Celestial. But why is Kelsier a better lynch than Celestial? He doesn't say. And he says he could lynch Gumdrop waiting on reurn of the Jedi? But Marv is gone too but he's just being Marv. His reads just don't add up to me.

I can't curb the desire to pressume 'I just posted a huge wall of everythin' you hap' to be sayin' at the chance!'

Marv - one page filter Marv in a newbie game is not town Marv. Super underwhelming and nothing of substance in his filter. He once asked if I was so unmotivated to solve the game as town and the answer was no becasue I was scum. Now I'm asking the same question. Why is he so unmotivated this late into a newbie game if he's town?

Yeh, and this is ctrl+c, ctrl+v material. "This friend Markus likes to plant his Ash's to the left side of the sunset. He did it on the right for sum' reason. He looks real dirty now for not doin' nothin', as all has said, so I'll voice the same. Add a whole bit' of squat.

Plynch
Gumdrop - this one is pretty obvious and has been talk of the town so I won't go too much into it. Scum has trouble entering and participating in the thread, but from the game I played with Gumdrop, that one post isn't enough to be scum. It's more policy territory for me but I'd like to see if Gum actually gives us something to work with before jumping on that wagon.

Hmph, ya' know my thoughts on Gummy's dance. All the blinkin' lights on 2'nd street should have company.

On October 13 2015 01:08 Vivax wrote:
Why are you talking like a Texan fac-simile or whatever that is.

On October 13 2015 01:10 The Shining wrote:
Am I the only one who can't stand ES's post style and indirect wording?

This is why I choose to ignore you. If you can't be clear and concise and resort to cowboy speak, all you're doing is shitting up the thread and you serve 0 purpose to town.

On October 13 2015 01:13 marvellosity wrote:

I'm slightly falling out of love with all the apostrophes tbh.

On October 12 2015 20:12 marvellosity wrote:

your push is at best shit and at worst scummy

On October 13 2015 02:17 Vivax wrote:


There's no evidence that gum is mafia, only that he is an afk something.

Shining was like one of the last people to start posting and now has 5 pages of filter and on top of it he sounds a lot like me when I feel really committed.

Marv nobody cares about cause lynching him on D1 is dumb when he's one of the top night kills on the forum.