On October 12 2015 11:04 MoosyDoosy wrote: So Shining is voting for marv because he thinks marv is more scummy than FF although he believes that both are scum.
And FF is voting for marv because he changed his read on ObviousOne.
@FecalFeast, just one last question.
On October 12 2015 10:56 Fecalfeast wrote: And to commit to a read I am now calling OO towny
What is with this post?
On October 12 2015 10:35 Fecalfeast wrote: In his post he said I was scummy with OO and marv. Both people I have said I'm ok with killing. I was saying that seems like a bad strategy.
I said previously that I would kill OO and marv, reads change. Which actually kinda fits shining's narrative where I can change my vote. Oh shit I'm thinking about how I appear again, better pretend I don't notice things like that or I'll get called scum
Meh you changed your vote from one possible scummer to another. Your sarcasm does you no favors, either.
I don't need any favours. I'm going to survive as a possible mislynch all game and end up in final 3 with sicklucker just like old times
I mean, don't get me wrong, I like where your case is going moose. Shining's explanation of marv's meta being damning but his weak read on me being based on this game isn't terrible.
I don't like the rage coming from him though. IDK people say getting mad is a towny thing but I disagree
On October 12 2015 12:22 The Shining wrote: I have nothing to flesh out. Have fun lynching town, baddies and scummers. You've earned it because I'm tilt as fuck and won't be around again.
On October 12 2015 13:34 The Shining wrote: lol I did do stuff. Stop telling everybody to do stuff in every fucking post and you do something yourself. Srsly. You've done nothing today but piss me off, tunnel me, throw random questions and pokes everywhere with no conclusion and make a pointless post about a dress, contradict yourself on "if I'm town" but "lynching 100%", so you're admitting you're 100% going to lynch town so I'll let town handle that when I flip.
How about you question somebody or something instead of making useless one liners and questions that lead nowhere?
Actually the more I analyze this game, the more I realize I'm a shitty D1er and always have been and my reads are usually always wrong. Now my top townreads are the scummiest out of the bunch IRT me and my scumreads are looking pretty good. Funny how shit works out.
On October 12 2015 13:38 Eversince wrote: Wells, a dead shot is as good as any other to me. But I hope to stumble the chance in talkin' bout' it tomorrow.
Do you speak like that or are you just doing an accent for fun?
I'm literally always down with killing SL, marv can frick off if he thinks I'm scum, Eversince's filter is so terrible to look at I can't even bring myself to read it.
Marv, you asked me about why I like OO's posts and I answered it already when moosy asked me the same thing.
On October 12 2015 09:13 Fecalfeast wrote: OO's recent posts are good and I like them. ##unvote ##vote marvellosity
might as well lynch the obvious... one wait that wasn't intentional
shining you just called me out for saying moosey bused his whole team, then you say that mafia's wincon is to survive? By that logic, town's wincon is also to survive because if enough townies die the game ends...
On October 11 2015 06:12 sicklucker wrote: You voted me . Scum will hold back from joke votes because it causes issues. you show you dont care about perception because a random vote in a newbie game will get many raised eyebrows.
Obviousone is gonna be mad idc about him
vivax stfu ill beat you up
Just been going back through the thread. Why would I be mad?
On October 11 2015 06:29 marvellosity wrote: The only curious thing I saw was sicklucker questioning eversince's motives or whatever. How he got any other impression than new around here and very earnest and enjoyable is totally beyond me
Interesting thing for a (town)marv to do, there was no pressure or threat of pressure towards Eversince. I could see him doing this as town if he's genuinely impressed or interested in playing more games with someone like Eversince.
I could see (scum) marv might use this as a basis for pushing a (town)sicklucker but there's been no further indication that marv is even reading/playing right now. sicklucker had a pretty townie response to this, in rereading.
Also anyone who thinks that I'm scum with vivax and didn't decide in the mafia QT to have a laugh in the thread together and in general make distractions town playing the game is goofy, I didn't realize he's brought back some of his trolling when I signed up for this game but that's pretty much how I'd get my kicks this game.
On October 12 2015 07:18 Fecalfeast wrote: For the record I'd like you to talk about the things wrong with the post, eversince, so I don't have to actually read it
Yeah me neither. Kind of reminds me of the posts I saw about Onegu and myself written by Eversince. Lotta summary shit. TL;DR
This post, the bolded shows that he is considering both worlds for marv, though obviously is ultimately tipped toward scum because lolmarv.
Not only that but he doesn't like vivax and I am coming around to the idea of a vivax/marv/X team based on the lack of playing.
On October 12 2015 07:26 Eversince wrote: Mhmm, I'm goin' to save myself some time.
90% of your post is reiterated stuff that's adding nothin'. I notice it, prod at you, and you proceed to get really mad.
Not the best picture we could of painted.
Except no one knew you noticed it until right now because you said absolutely nothing of worth or value regarding my post. And how is it adding nothing? It added a player with reads into the game that had absolutely no posts or thoughts beforehand. I'm sorry that most of what I would've caught in the process of the game, I couldn't because I wasn't around.
That was an amazing post regarding "so many things wrong" with my post. 10/10, would read again.
Since nobody else is doing it, I'll ask you to get a nice post regarding who you think is mafia and a vote if applicable.
Reads post has scumreads. Go read it.
##Vote: FecalFeast
Because I've got a case of the fuck its and I listed him first.
I disagree almost entirely. Commentary inline
Super underwhelming. Subjective, debatable, what is your expectation? You're repeating what he said about himself. I found his joke post of "worried about appearance obvious mafia" kind of ironic since he states in his very next post that Vivax is as underwhelming as he is, which shows he is quite aware of how he looks in-thread.Knowing how you look to others is how you get not lynched, or more importantly not mislynched. Also, most of his reads don't seem to lean very strongly either way which leaves a lot of wiggle room. Seems pretty convinced I'm mafia, even has his vote on me. Note this also means we're not likely to be mafia together, but it's also not impossible. Gums opening is awkward but not screaming scummy, wants OO to come back to confirm suspicion, Moosy is posting fine things but has the ability to play scum well. What do the previous things have to do with fecal's alignment? His eye is on vivax but he's just as bad. That's scumming yourself by default lol. That doesn't invalidate it as a scum read. And believing Vivaxs scum claim is just bad. I've seen vivax just roll over and die as scum but I haven't seen him outright claim it. Some people here will instalynch people who claim mafia. It's one of the easiest things you can do as mafia to create a why/why not discussion that distracts from legitimate talking points. I don't know if he's one of those people.
No reads on half the game and yes, I even said that he said that about himself. He also said it about one of his scumread, Vivax. So by that logic, if its an acceptable thing to scum someone for, its an acceptable thing to scum him for.
In my experience, scum is much more aware of how they look because their only goal is to survive. Town cares, or should care, less about surviving and how they look and spend more time on how OTHERS, namely scum, look.
Reading his filter doesn't look like he's that convinced. If you think you found scum, you push it. I just see a vote and some meh posts regarding you. The next few lines were examples of Fecal's reads that didn't lean strong either way. How did you not realize that?
No reads on half the game - you don't need to tell people your town reads, it's just not necessary and sometimes gives mafia ideas for who best to kill, the unlynchables.
How he looks - he doesn't seem to care that he looks bad, just states that Vivax looks bad. He didn't make any effort to make himself look any better from what I can see. Maybe he wanted to honeytrap vivax into shaping up, in an effort to either get him to start taking the game mega-seriously for one reason or another.
I'm aware of how I look -- it's pretty obvious from the votes and general sentiment and my level of participation, but I just have to look slightly better than the scummiest guy in the thread and I don't get mislynched and I also don't get shot at night which is a good skill to have if I ever want to be good at the mafia side of things. Which in retrospect sucks because that means I'll have to spend more time in-game but that's what I signed up for, after all. This game is alright so far.
His vote on me - probably could be swung away to another wagon, you have that right. But that's telling us something about him. I wish I knew more about his general style of play to see if this is out of the ordinary for his town play, but I'm not invested enough to do the research. Someone said he wasn't particularly fecalfeasty but didn't really expand on that idea and I'd like to hear more in that vein if it's indeed true. Sometimes it's easy to overlook in analysis that we're working with imperfect information and while he's not committed to scum reads, he's also not defended anyone that I can remember. I may just be the best candidate in his mind, at the moment of posting. If he leaves it there I might be miffed, but again, something that could be telling in the future with better information (flips).
Not to mention the defense of me, I am pretty self centred. Besides, unless he's going for the hardest of pockets, he's defending me rather than pushing for my mislynch. Vivax is already on my case, shining with his pressure too. OO could have helped bury me but instead looks at it rationally and breaks down why shining's logic is flawed.
On October 12 2015 10:56 Fecalfeast wrote: ok well that was supposed to be 1 post but forgot to cut/paste sorry
On October 13 2015 06:44 sicklucker wrote: Thats a late dinner. honestly I dont know. theres people I kinda wanna kill and people I dont want to kill. And people only seem interested in the ones I dont want to kill. Theres no one I really wanna kill
I think we should just lynch gumdrop honestly I dont wanna deal with a replacement and his drop out was potentially due to unwanted call outs. oh and his 1 post was scummy as fuck
I'm west coast and it will start before 6 most likely but I have plenty of family that will be there
770
260
249
202
69
32199
3574
1620
92
EPT