Student Mafia XV - Page 3

On October 12 2015 06:19 The Shining wrote:
Oh and "I don't like this so far" & a quick "Oh you're right Celestial, he's lying and that post felt half assed so let me instavote" isn't you trying to get Obvious killed. It's a quick jump onto something someone else caught on someone you were suspicious of. You could even be spewing Obvious town here.

Now let me go eat and watch my kdrama in peace, Fecalscum @.@

On October 12 2015 10:25 MoosyDoosy wrote:

Because you take drugs and I am omniscient.


So did you read the whole list post or not? Did you have any issues with the list posts that Shining and Eversince provided?

On October 12 2015 10:37 MoosyDoosy wrote:

But you just said you didn't read the post...

On October 12 2015 10:39 MoosyDoosy wrote:

So how do you currently read ObviousOne?

Can you point out the posts from ObviousOne that you liked in particular and explain why?

On October 12 2015 10:40 The Shining wrote:


Regardless of whether i agree with them or not, his point regarding getting both of his partners killed if my scumlist is correct is a good one. And his OO vote was something i did overlook when i scummed him, although i did explain how he could just switdh votes. But he did come off of OO pretty easily now that i look at it...

Like i said. I still dont have warm fuzzies about him, my vote is still on him but it also makes perfectly good sense to lynch the guy who did nothing and then fucked off when most here know his potential as town. I only havent switched to marv because Fecal did, which means I'm wrong on one of them but I'm still hoping Marv can show up and clear it up. But at least FF is responding to pressure

On October 12 2015 08:24 ObviousOne wrote:

No reads on half the game - you don't need to tell people your town reads, it's just not necessary and sometimes gives mafia ideas for who best to kill, the unlynchables.

How he looks - he doesn't seem to care that he looks bad, just states that Vivax looks bad. He didn't make any effort to make himself look any better from what I can see. Maybe he wanted to honeytrap vivax into shaping up, in an effort to either get him to start taking the game mega-seriously for one reason or another.

I'm aware of how I look -- it's pretty obvious from the votes and general sentiment and my level of participation, but I just have to look slightly better than the scummiest guy in the thread and I don't get mislynched and I also don't get shot at night which is a good skill to have if I ever want to be good at the mafia side of things. Which in retrospect sucks because that means I'll have to spend more time in-game but that's what I signed up for, after all. This game is alright so far.

His vote on me - probably could be swung away to another wagon, you have that right. But that's telling us something about him. I wish I knew more about his general style of play to see if this is out of the ordinary for his town play, but I'm not invested enough to do the research. Someone said he wasn't particularly fecalfeasty but didn't really expand on that idea and I'd like to hear more in that vein if it's indeed true. Sometimes it's easy to overlook in analysis that we're working with imperfect information and while he's not committed to scum reads, he's also not defended anyone that I can remember. I may just be the best candidate in his mind, at the moment of posting. If he leaves it there I might be miffed, but again, something that could be telling in the future with better information (flips).

On October 12 2015 07:33 ObviousOne wrote:

Just been going back through the thread. Why would I be mad?


Interesting thing for a (town)marv to do, there was no pressure or threat of pressure towards Eversince. I could see him doing this as town if he's genuinely impressed or interested in playing more games with someone like Eversince.

I could see (scum) marv might use this as a basis for pushing a (town)sicklucker but there's been no further indication that marv is even reading/playing right now. sicklucker had a pretty townie response to this, in rereading.

The proceeding vivax-sicklucker interaction makes me like vivax less than originally thought. Still aware it was in the interim between silly and serious (if he made it to serious time again, haven't re-read that far). Sort of redeems himself with this post about the mental challenges many players including myself face when assigned a mafia team role.

Also anyone who thinks that I'm scum with vivax and didn't decide in the mafia QT to have a laugh in the thread together and in general make distractions town playing the game is goofy, I didn't realize he's brought back some of his trolling when I signed up for this game but that's pretty much how I'd get my kicks this game.


Yeah me neither. Kind of reminds me of the posts I saw about Onegu and myself written by Eversince. Lotta summary shit. TL;DR

On October 12 2015 11:04 MoosyDoosy wrote:
So Shining is voting for marv because he thinks marv is more scummy than FF although he believes that both are scum.

And FF is voting for marv because he changed his read on ObviousOne.

@FecalFeast, just one last question.


What is with this post?