|
On September 20 2015 17:42 scott31337 wrote:
I thought Damdred's reactions to my claim were reasonable - or were they Scumdred trying to throw us off?
He did have that one post where he was like "damn, i shoulda just kept pushing him". That felt a little like "Hey guys, remember how I was pushing him before the claim made him slam dunk mafia? Give me my proper credit". But tbh 90% of my methods for reading damdred revolve around d1 and n1 and that didn't happen during that period of time so I defer to my other stuff.
|
On September 20 2015 17:46 scott31337 wrote:
Cephiro is just shit town until proven otherwise - give it a day or two - Wish you would've shot him but can't waste our lives on should've.
as opposed to coin-flip afk onegu? i am content with my shot, even though i kinda think it was a miss based on wile's "being content with outting roles" post.
|
On September 20 2015 17:49 scott31337 wrote:
Geript - could be mafia because last game him and i were town bros from like day 1. we had the feels. he doesn't have the feels this game. also he had that one crazy tonal shift post where he has not been angry all game and then suddenly goes off on some1 then back to calm. could be trying to manufacture some of his town fire.
Geript is a very good scum player and like JAT said - has some crazy dumbtells and maybe trying to play it off? WIFOM etc ?
Nothing fucking sticks out.
For me, when geript leaves a lasting impression on me he tends to be town. Like if I hate him or love him, he is probably town. If I nothing him, he is potentially mafia. This game I nothing him, so he is potentially mafia.
|
Tbh mechanically I should be the one shot tonight since there's literally 0 world where I am mafia ever. But I might live through just cuz some people may respect koshi's town game more or be afraid you're lying about the # of uses of your ability. Probably dead though.
|
On September 20 2015 18:18 justanothertownie wrote:Show nested quote +On September 20 2015 17:58 ritoky wrote:
Tbh mechanically I should be the one shot tonight since there's literally 0 world where I am mafia ever. But I might live through just cuz some people may respect koshi's town game more or be afraid you're lying about the # of uses of your ability. Probably dead though. Mafia aren't idiots dude. Thanks for finally putting in the effort. I don't really see why you think we shouldn't lynch damdred even though you think he is more than likely mafia. I get that you say he might be with Onegu due to his weird read progression there but that is pretty speculative to me. We still have at least 1 mislynch left so we should just lynch who is the likeliest scum. Btw. what exactly do you want me to summarize or consolidate? I said where I stand in my big post.
maybe i missed it, but i didn't remember at the time i was typing the state and details of your reads on non-confirmed people.
|
On September 20 2015 18:31 justanothertownie wrote:Show nested quote +On September 20 2015 16:07 ritoky wrote:
if damdred is mafia, he is mafia with palmar or geript. You might have wrote it somewhere but why can't he be mafia with marv? I have a hard time seeing a world where Palmar is mafia and marv town.
damdred like to do this thing i like to do as mafia where you either completely ignore your partner or you give reads on your partner bus never really press them. he is doing that mostly with palmar and geript i think.
|
On September 20 2015 18:43 ritoky wrote:Show nested quote +On September 20 2015 18:31 justanothertownie wrote:On September 20 2015 16:07 ritoky wrote:
if damdred is mafia, he is mafia with palmar or geript. You might have wrote it somewhere but why can't he be mafia with marv? I have a hard time seeing a world where Palmar is mafia and marv town. damdred like to do this thing i like to do as mafia where you either completely ignore your partner or you give reads on your partner bus never really press them. he is doing that mostly with palmar and geript i think.
it's more complex than that but i am tired so that's it simplified. also palmar overjustified his read on damdred that was another thing
|
On September 20 2015 18:49 justanothertownie wrote:Show nested quote +On September 20 2015 18:43 ritoky wrote:On September 20 2015 18:31 justanothertownie wrote:On September 20 2015 16:07 ritoky wrote:
if damdred is mafia, he is mafia with palmar or geript. You might have wrote it somewhere but why can't he be mafia with marv? I have a hard time seeing a world where Palmar is mafia and marv town. damdred like to do this thing i like to do as mafia where you either completely ignore your partner or you give reads on your partner bus never really press them. he is doing that mostly with palmar and geript i think. Hm, okay... because marvs read progression on damdred could be mafia/mafia to me. Really doubt damdred is with Palmar unless marv really sucks this game.
is this in your filter? or can you splain it to me?
|
On September 20 2015 18:18 justanothertownie wrote:Show nested quote +On September 20 2015 17:58 ritoky wrote:
Tbh mechanically I should be the one shot tonight since there's literally 0 world where I am mafia ever. But I might live through just cuz some people may respect koshi's town game more or be afraid you're lying about the # of uses of your ability. Probably dead though. Mafia aren't idiots dude. Thanks for finally putting in the effort. I don't really see why you think we shouldn't lynch damdred even though you think he is more than likely mafia. I get that you say he might be with Onegu due to his weird read progression there but that is pretty speculative to me. We still have at least 1 mislynch left so we should just lynch who is the likeliest scum. Btw. what exactly do you want me to summarize or consolidate? I said where I stand in my big post.
yes you should lynch the most likely mafia. if i didn't find someone better, i would lynch damdred. the only 2 reasons i even mentioned potentially waiting on him a day is 1) he could be a world of 1; 2) pride. don't wanna drive a ML on him and be wrong for 1st time D:
|
i clicked your filter and found exactly what i was looking for. nvm on the above.
|
list of unlikely worlds of 2:
damdred + jat - damdred non-stop pushing jat all day 1 even when things were cooling down (damdred and gb once did this to eachother so outside of range, but unlikely due to nature of pushing)
cephiro + marv - marv non-stop refusing to let me town read ceph or taking him off the table for tmrw and calling my reason shit constantly.
palmar + geript - palmar called geript out on his tone shift when no1 else seemed to care.
|
wow i failed at english *so not outside of range
|
I kinda think marv and cephiro are like almost always opposite alignments.
|
The reason is a bit shit, but after reading JAT's post about marv and how he hands out too many or too strong of town reads I started thinking about how I would try to win this game if I were mafia from this spot. You basically need 2 MLs and you have a pool of players to lynch from that is 4 of geript, JAT, cephiro, marv, palmar, and damdred. 5 of those players are capable of shitting town rainbows from my experience....some more consistently than others. the odd one out being cephiro (no offense, i just don't know you).
so if i was in a mafia team of 2 and not with cephiro, clearly my goal is ML ceph + 1 rather than try to bust through 2 ppl who can shit town rainbows. what makes them likely not together also sketches me out about marv cuz of this very thought. i also remember i was typing something like this out earlier in the thread then erased it all thinking it was dumb and i should just go to sleep instead. i didn't take the advice this time. but now i will go to sleep.
|
all that is assuming 2 mafia instead of 1
|
the disrespect on scott is strong. i was like 80% certain he was lying about the # of uses of his abilities.
world of 1 damdred not possible now.....bleh he might actually end up being town and i might have just been wrong all game.
|
On September 21 2015 06:38 justanothertownie wrote:Show nested quote +On September 21 2015 06:37 ritoky wrote:
the disrespect on scott is strong. i was like 80% certain he was lying about the # of uses of his abilities.
world of 1 damdred not possible now.....bleh he might actually end up being town and i might have just been wrong all game. Of course it is still possible. Onegu could have been janitor and damdred GF. This result does not make damdred anything.
oh wow, didn't read that part of godfather in the OP.
|
On September 21 2015 06:42 geript wrote:Show nested quote +On September 21 2015 06:41 justanothertownie wrote:On September 21 2015 06:40 geript wrote:
I stalked JAT last night. Turns out he uses a penis pump. Can we all admit that's pretty scummy? Yes I believe so. Plus, there's the penis size to mafianess proven correlation. Very creative and convincing. You should vote for yourself then since it's so convincing.
you should post reads since you've been lurking for so long.
|
like...koshi dying in 1 sense points to jat as mafia in that scott and i both read jat townier and he was on koshi's 3 person lynch list....but in another sense jat i kinda think he isn't lying when he says he asked if it was a troll kill cuz i was also pretty sure scott wasn't 1shot ability....and does jat really miss my soft and the fuck up killing scott there both in the same game? he's derp but that's pretty derp for him.
|
he originally wanted to lynch you and marv. then he changed to palm and marv. but i have serious doubts you would fuck up on 2 claims in a row there. probably never lynching jat today.
|
|
|
|
|
|
EPT
