[M][N] Completely Normal Generic Mini Mafia - Page 26

On September 23 2015 07:47 Palmar wrote:
I'm out for tonight.

On September 23 2015 08:46 geript wrote:
But idk who is mafia. I think I'm going to vote for Scott tomorrow.

On September 23 2015 07:48 Cephiro wrote:


Irrelevant until I have information of what happens during the night.



Any information available during the night is there just as much for scum as it is for town. It's a good time to re-evaluate and analyze your own reads on different people, but there's not much of a reason to share it with town unless you come up with something significant that would likely affect the way a power role would act that night.

Otherwise it's best to keep things to yourself and post anything of relevance before the deadline. That combined with whatever the results of the night cycle are gives a good start for the following day to continue upon.

What happens during the day is much more relevant for scumhunting than what someone says during the night in most cases.

Feel free to disagree, but this is how I see it.

On September 23 2015 19:42 Palmar wrote:
We're lynching geript tomorrow.

I can't remember if I pointed it out but at some point he said something like "I'm doing all I can with the time I have" when he was literally talking about penises.

He has to be mafia.

On September 24 2015 01:11 geript wrote:
Anyone who lynches me tomorrow is stupid/bad/mafia. Pick 2.

On September 24 2015 02:00 geript wrote:

I have multiple times. But here's another new wrinkle. Do I really hard sheep mafia buddy Marv d1? Nope.

On September 24 2015 02:45 geript wrote:

I'll take stupid/bad. I'll give you bad/mafia.

On September 24 2015 03:26 geript wrote:

I have. I'm pretty sure multiple times. I'm about to head into work. For people who are spending so much time on the game, they give zero time to read my filter or anything I post. I could give zero fucks what those players think. I don't have time to keep repeating shit. What I really need is a massage because my legs are killing me.

On September 24 2015 04:20 ritoky wrote:
also jat are you here?

On September 24 2015 05:18 ritoky wrote:
I don't think you're mafia as of now. But I am not 100% on you not being mafia either. So I am gonna list what I feel are the best reasons in the thread you could be mafia, and I want you to tell me why they're wrong. I don't care about calling them bad, I want to know why they are wrong.

1) The guy tryharding the most when no1 else is -> mafia. I did this in DU2, judgejudy did this recently. It is not always true, but it can be true in a lot of cases.

2) Overselling your Wile push. It is not that you didn't push on Wile, it is that the way you described your push on Wile is way more glorified than what you actually did.

3) Destructive day 1 play. Day 1 you were snarky and more concerned with tearing arguments down than building arguments and moving town in a positive direction.

4) The disappearing cephiro read. Disappearing might be a strong enough word, but you felt he was mafia enough to deserve your vote day 1 over moosy, marv, and wile; but since you haven't really done a lot of pushing of him in any particular direction.

5) Koshi list. Koshi's list of people he wanted lynched before he died was essentially you, marv, palmar. He had slightly softened on you, but still #koshisays. No but seriously this post:




6) A few too many "I wouldn't do x as this alignment" kind of posts that stand out in your filter. A lot of self-meta examination even under very little fire.

7) Marv was kinda deflecting you pretty substantially around the lynch time day 1. Could be spew, could be deflection.

That's all I remember for now. Your filter is a behemoth so I might have forgotten some shit. Just start here telling my why this is all wrong.

On September 24 2015 05:18 ritoky wrote:
I don't think you're mafia as of now. But I am not 100% on you not being mafia either. So I am gonna list what I feel are the best reasons in the thread you could be mafia, and I want you to tell me why they're wrong. I don't care about calling them bad, I want to know why they are wrong.

1) The guy tryharding the most when no1 else is -> mafia. I did this in DU2, judgejudy did this recently. It is not always true, but it can be true in a lot of cases.

2) Overselling your Wile push. It is not that you didn't push on Wile, it is that the way you described your push on Wile is way more glorified than what you actually did.

3) Destructive day 1 play. Day 1 you were snarky and more concerned with tearing arguments down than building arguments and moving town in a positive direction.

4) The disappearing cephiro read. Disappearing might be a strong enough word, but you felt he was mafia enough to deserve your vote day 1 over moosy, marv, and wile; but since you haven't really done a lot of pushing of him in any particular direction.

5) Koshi list. Koshi's list of people he wanted lynched before he died was essentially you, marv, palmar. He had slightly softened on you, but still #koshisays. No but seriously this post:




6) A few too many "I wouldn't do x as this alignment" kind of posts that stand out in your filter. A lot of self-meta examination even under very little fire.

7) Marv was kinda deflecting you pretty substantially around the lynch time day 1. Could be spew, could be deflection.

That's all I remember for now. Your filter is a behemoth so I might have forgotten some shit. Just start here telling my why this is all wrong.

On September 24 2015 07:58 geript wrote:
I'm voting for JAT. Because I trust Rayn's reads. And Rayn scumread JAT for all of D1.

On September 24 2015 08:06 geript wrote:

You first. I've covered why Rayn's N1 read on you is irrelevant and incorrect.

On September 24 2015 08:20 ritoky wrote:


that's cool, what specific post by rayn or parts of his read do you find compelling? cuz rayn's been dead so long i don't particularly remember his reads...so i am assuming you dug through some filters or notes to find this.