[M][N] Completely Normal Generic Mini Mafia - Page 21

On September 21 2015 06:55 scott31337 wrote:
So shall we get the Marv wagon rolling then?

Or do you have a better suggestion?

On September 21 2015 06:58 ritoky wrote:
jat have your reads changed at all? i am assuming not really since literally only confirmed townies and you have posted.

On September 21 2015 07:00 Damdred wrote:
You both are dumb and bad.

On September 21 2015 07:13 geript wrote:
I don't get it. I've made reads pretty clearly. Palmar is town. Marv is town. Damdred is town. Ceph is kinda likely-ish to be town. Scott is 98% town. Koshi is dead but town. Like there's not much that has changed. So everyone calling me scum can kindly drop to your knees and do your duty.

Like I'm not scum. Theres like a million good reasons for why I'm not scum.

On September 21 2015 07:14 ritoky wrote:
like seriously, how am i supposed to read any1 but jat town out of you lot recently?

none of you are dying during the night phase and out of the 6 of you only 2 posted over the course of 24 hours. 1 of which is geript who said literal nothing with his posts. like some of you have to be town who are just fucking off. you're supposed to be vets, you're supposed to be respected players, you're supposed to be good. well fucking step it up if you're town.

On September 21 2015 07:18 Damdred wrote:
2) Your an idiot ritoky because you are lynching someone with what amounts to a green check at this point. When you just got done getting lynched in another game with a green check on you.

On September 21 2015 07:51 geript wrote:

Yah probably Onegu was.

Mod confirm. The D1 Damdred read. My flip on Palmar. My bad Rayn tunnel. General giving no shits after like N1. Me voting for Wile for a god awful reason.

Like I'll do most anything as either alignment but I think the major difference between my scum play and town play is when I'm scum I need to be in control of the thread. That doesn't mean everyone has to sheep me, but I don't like being "at town's whim." I don't like trying to let town ever organize. I prefer to wholly disrupt any and all ability to trust anyone but me. I'll spend time to focus people on reasonable but useless rabbit trails. I bank up thread control to spend it at key points. That's basically the opposite of, for the most part, irrelevant player I've been. Even when I'm busy scum I do my best to positively contribute to the team.

On September 21 2015 13:14 geript wrote:

I'm doing the best I can with the time I can allot to this game.

On September 21 2015 18:44 Palmar wrote:
So I'm not sure what to do here. Here's some generic thoughts.

scott won't get lynched this game, I think. Yes I know he's a replacement and replacements are always mafia. The problem is we don't know how many mislynches we have. Scott needs to continue posting if he's town because there definitely exists a scenario where he buses a teammate (although vigi+mason+mason seems kinda weak).

Another thing. I didn't mention this last night or yesterday or whenever I was berating JAT and geript for not reading the OP, but I do not really see any option for a limited-shot tracker. (look at the difference in wording between the vigi and all the "each night" roles). if scott is tracker he has unlimited shots. This means either mafia wasn't aware of this, or (probably more likely) they're not afraid of a tracker at all (ie: they have a godfather). Or obviously, that scott is actually just mafia. But I have no interest in sorting out tinfoil hat scenarios, at least not now, so I'm treating him as confirmed town. Props to him/his team if it's a play.

If we assume Onegu is mafia, Damdred can only be mafia if he is a godfather. But more importantly I don't want to lynch Damdred. I still believe the points I brought up on him make him town. I don't even care that wile eventually flipped mafia. Damdred's point about wile was a townie train of thought from Damdred. Like I know there exist multiple mechanical scenarios where Damdred is mafia but who cares, he doesn't sound like one.

I'm going to read Damdred's filter later because so many people seem to think he's likely scum but for now meh.

ritoky is obviously confirmed, mafia has no option for a vigilante.

This leaves ceph/marv/jat/geript. All of them have good reasons to be called mafia. I almost feel like this game is "figure out jat or marv (one way or the other), figure out the game".

On September 21 2015 18:45 Palmar wrote:
Like I'm not gonna argue about the damdred thing unless people get actually close to lynching him.

It's a super daunting task to read marv and jat's filter. Like there's probably no people (well holyflare is up there) whose filter I despise reading more than those two.

On September 21 2015 18:51 Palmar wrote:
About the geript thing and why it bothers me so much.

I like geript, and I think he's a nice, reasonable guy. In order for him to blow up on ceph like that because of real life stress, he has to be far more emotional than I think he is. Like I talk to geript on ts, play with him here and stuff, and it's just way out of his character range. Like if geript was really (and I believe he was) stressed out by his rl, the attitude I would have thought he brought to the game is more in the lieu of:

"dude.... please. Just back the fuck off. rl is shit and I don't have the willpower to argue with your shit right now so just stop it please"

Instead of the caps lock (it was caps, right?) tirade he went on.

Maybe I just don't know geript. But it seemed excessive.

Also, this:



Is kinda not true, but it's also not a thing that makes him mafia to think. I'm mostly pointing out that he's being extremely useless if he's town. Not that it makes him 100% mafia.

On September 21 2015 18:52 Palmar wrote:

Who cares about damdred, you want to lynch marv, right?

On September 21 2015 18:54 Palmar wrote:

pick one.

On September 21 2015 21:01 Palmar wrote:
if marv is mafia his #1 scumplay is to just shut up and not post.

On September 21 2015 21:04 marvellosity wrote:

Silly. Of course i can avoid the lynch. i've not started reading yet. i'm not sure you quite grasp my mental state right this moment :p