Lost But Not Forgotten Mini Mafia

On July 18 2015 18:14 Rels wrote:
I have town leans on yamato KSC and damdred atm.


Can you explain ? 'cause he seems to post a looot more than the last few games I obs of him, where he was town each time I think.

On July 18 2015 18:21 Rels wrote:

That may be bad meta, but I remember town Onegu being mostly AFK day 1 in all the games I obsed, and in each game people kept saying how Onegu loved being scum and was AFK as town to justify that.

On July 19 2015 03:35 raynpelikoneet wrote:
I really want to know why my read on yamato is shit and Damdred's is really good when we posted the exact same reasoning for the read and i even did it first.

On July 19 2015 04:01 Damdred wrote:
This is difficult.

I don't think geript is a good lynch at all. Its based a bit on crappy meta and gut feelings a bit. Meh

On July 19 2015 04:12 geript wrote:

Nope it's not. People seem to be happy to let everyone be fine with townreads on Johnny. But he has done basically nothing to be townread; and anyone who's townreading him is doing so awfully. So when that continues, it's generally because the guy is mafia. Yet you haven't cared about the fact that I'm not townreading Johnny whatsoever. You haven't even bothered with it. Plus the reasoning that I quoted is shit. Quite often as mafia, you call people town to look good for awful reasons. Just so that you can emulate your townplay. You could be not wanting to bus, but I find that unlikely.

Second, you've failed to go through and actually analyze the argument I'm making and Kelsier is making. Like if you followed the thread in context, you'd understand the point I've made. It's not me taking things out of context whatsoever. Rather, Kelsier has continued to ask stupid questions and try to make points that are literally not following any reality in the thread. For example, he's quoted the post where Yam responded to me, and yet as asked where Yam responded to me. He's constantly asked why I don't find his posts to be short/assholey. Yet my wording has specifically and clearly pointed out that I find them short/assholey. Rather the point I've been making is that Yam doesn't feel short/assholey enough; that as town, he's usually more prone to being extra dumb/short/assholey. Which is why I'm thinking he might be town considering his follow up. But Kelsier isn't actually trying to think about what I've said. He's just trying to be active.

On July 19 2015 06:13 Fecalfeast wrote:
therefore I am scum? Do you know whether I have silly d1 reads often or only as scum?

Why are my reads silly?