hmm don't understand why people don't wanna join. First I thought it was just some shooting, but since it has parties like a mafia game, it is basically the same in that the key to victory is figuring out who's mafia by talking to each other.

plotspot

800 Posts

August 04 2015 11:56 GMT

#87

/confirm
yeah no filter kinda sucks, but we'll see

plotspot

800 Posts

August 05 2015 00:00 GMT

#103

wow since when did the rules change to 3 loads and 3 defends? I thought it was 5 loads and 5 defends before.

plotspot

800 Posts

August 05 2015 00:15 GMT

#104

like this should be very easy for town, we all agree to load and everyone has 2 shots for tomorrow. Makes the game very interesting, and ok maybe mafia doesn't agree and shoots, who the fuck cares 2 townies dead but we know who is mafia for sure, because they didn't load but shot instead.

plotspot

800 Posts

August 05 2015 03:09 GMT

#113

On August 05 2015 10:19 Damdred wrote:
Well actually we kinda can tell if everyone says load whoever doesn't have two shots tommorow is scum ya?

yeah that was the plan, but Sulfurus is right, I wasn't paying attention to the sample post Sentinel made. Though still if we agree that everyone loads, and every townie does, it leaves mafia back to shoot especially if you see 2 townies dying.Though still we are left with 4 townies who have 8 shots and 2 mafia who has no shot, this is advantageous to town, no? More likely we bring mafia to the game too by having them load, but then we have 6 townies with 12 shots and 2 mafia with 4 shots, I still think in such a game it favours the mass.

plotspot

800 Posts

August 05 2015 03:27 GMT

#114

actually I've thought more about this, as town we don't need to load up so much. We only need 2 kills, that means if we defend more and hit the right spots, this should do it. We don't need to load, if you die with many bullets, it's all the same. I doubt this game last more than 4 turns.
But consider this, if we don't misshoot, mafia needs at least 5 turns to win: shoot, load, shoot, load, shoot. Successfully defending one or two shots can drag this out to 6 turns for mafia to win, while we'd only need to hit two of them somewhere in between, killing one of them basically doubles the remaining time for them to win, if we don't misshoot.
I'm stressing this "don't misshoot" because we don't have lynch mechanism to balance it out, so we have to be extra careful when shooting someone.

plotspot

800 Posts

August 05 2015 19:03 GMT

#137

TT, you have set on default load in your first post. My first reaction was too that everyone should load, but shortly afterwards I pointed out that a defensive stance might not be so bad, since town doesn't really need that many bullets. And then you kinda agree that everyone should rather defend today.
Well I'm still waging between loading and defending, we'll see.

plotspot

800 Posts

August 06 2015 12:22 GMT

#164

Good stuff, I have aimed my cannon at one of the liars in this thread from the beginning of N2. LOL everyone loading was kinda what I expected.

plotspot

800 Posts

August 06 2015 19:10 GMT

#170

On August 07 2015 00:53 ObiWanShinobi wrote:
Btw, I don't really like Shockey either.
:/

what don't you like about Shockey, besides probably that he has not more than one post so far?

plotspot

800 Posts

August 06 2015 19:26 GMT

#172

yea and I'm fucking tired, have had a few rough days, you guys can do whatever you want
I'm shooting too, I have Sulfurus as town, so he is the only one I am definitely not shooting

plotspot

800 Posts

August 06 2015 20:24 GMT

#174

haha this game

plotspot

800 Posts

August 06 2015 20:29 GMT

#175

well, I didn't shoot any of them.^^

plotspot

800 Posts

August 06 2015 20:37 GMT

#178

nah I defended. I pointed out the dangers of shooting in the wild earlier, not gonna shoot If I'm not sure.
btw Damdred, your conclusion is wrong, not everyone shot. I just tried to make a cannonball analysis. It's not possible, you don't know whether the guys who died shot or loaded.

plotspot

800 Posts

August 07 2015 00:38 GMT

#182

? what kind of math is that. 1+2+2= 5 not 6.
Assuming so far: me 2 shots left, you 1 shot left, TT 2 shots left.
That's 5/8, so it's 3 CB for both Sulfurus and Shockey. One of them must have shot and the other defended, because they both went in N2 with 2 CB each.

plotspot

800 Posts

August 07 2015 12:24 GMT

#193

Like, I don't know. Whoever comes out now and claims having shot Obi is extremely suspicious (easiest bus claim ever), you won't find that person, yea maybe Sulf or one of the dead shot him, but who knows, it doesn't matter, I grant that townies can be a bit secretive in this game. Lying is absolutely not a mafia trait here. It's proven that I've "lied" about my NA last night, TT has "lied" twice, Onegu "lied" about his N1 action and we don't know whether he really shot someone N2 either and flipped town. It's more like decision swings not being proclaimed to the thread, which is fine and in essence not any different than anyone who didn't proclaim any NA in the thread.

plotspot

800 Posts

August 07 2015 21:02 GMT

#198

I defended. So Sulfurus has 1 CB left and defended too?

plotspot

800 Posts

August 07 2015 21:03 GMT

#200

Let me guess you shot Sulfurus because he wasn't willing to "participate", or me? I dunno.

plotspot

800 Posts

August 07 2015 21:10 GMT

#203

This is something I don't understand either. As either alignment you could choose one of the 3 dead or even the one you shot but who defended himself, and give some explanation, it's not like people will rip your head off because your reasoning isn't super tight and logical in this game.

1 2 Next All

Please or register to reply.

Live Events Refresh