Basically it boils down to this:
1. He's playing differently than he does as town.
2. He's responding differently than he does as town.

Yes. He randomly calls people scum for bad reasons; but that's not alignment indicative. Rather look at the scope of things. There's no overarching thought process behind it. Not even a bad one. As town, there is a series of thoughts behind who he calls scum and why. It will bend it's way back and forth between what he says. Rather, there's no thought behind anything whatsoever. It's just mafia this person. That's BS. There's no interconnectivity between his reads which you see when he's town.

Second, he doesn't snap back at people like he did at me as town. Like he'll bring it with more of a push or a thought as to why I'm scum and push me OR he'll make a push to try and figure out what he actually thinks about things.

In short, he's posting how he usually does. But it lacks the real impulsivity his town play has and lacks the theme his townplay has.

geript

10024 Posts

July 07 2015 01:50 GMT

#1668

On July 07 2015 10:35 Holyflare wrote:
also geript i don't know about the meta so i can't really comment on it's accuracy so it's kind of a giant wall of text right now, trfel's new post is like wtf since he scum reads ls for something his town read and I have said is town indicative from LS and if he was reading the thread there's no way he misses that

Ok. IDK wtf to do w/ trfel. He's weird. I actually find the whole trfel-rso-ls triangle pretty weird to be honest.

geript

10024 Posts

July 07 2015 05:17 GMT

#1782

Let's talk about Oats. When does Oats not have a reason to vote for someone? Yes the reason's almost always a shitty one, but he always has it. Second, when does Oats not make a dumbass Omgus argument at some point early.

Just saying folks. It's pretty easy.

geript

10024 Posts

July 07 2015 05:36 GMT

#1793

On July 07 2015 14:26 rsoultin wrote:
oh i see why you're voting geript, oats...reminds me of bats lol >< it's just as flawed as that was, though

No it's not. I've listed at least 4 different distinct reasons for why I'm voting for him and why you should as well.

BTW, all of them are damn good reasons. And none of this even brings up my magic first post reads.

geript

10024 Posts

July 07 2015 05:37 GMT

#1796

On July 07 2015 14:21 rsoultin wrote:

Show nested quote +

that at least i've seen a lot

although in all honesty i think i've seen him call people mafia without a reason, or is this specific to just voting?

Call people mafia... yes. Push people as mafia... no.

geript

10024 Posts

July 07 2015 05:40 GMT

#1798

Also, there's ~16 hours left and there isn't 7 votes on any candidate. We need to start consolidating or else we won't get any lynch off.

So if you aren't voting for Trfel or Oats, then you better have a damn good case on them as of right now or you're not helping/are scum.

geript

10024 Posts

July 07 2015 05:41 GMT

#1799

On July 07 2015 14:39 Oatsmaster wrote:

Show nested quote +

Oh sorry, you need a reason why your play is scummy?
How about doing nothing but continously call someone mafia but not actually trying to convince people I'm mafia.

Doing nothing but this the whole day.

Yeah, you can die.

That's right Oats. I've never said anything to push you or made any arguments against you the whole time. Keep on lying bro, cuz you about to get your ass lynched.

geript

10024 Posts

July 07 2015 05:42 GMT

#1800

Not Voting (13): Scott31337, WaveofShadow, ritoky, Meapak_Ziphh, Trfel, LightningStrike, KelsierSC, milo109, Oatsmaster, Damdred, XEliteBlueHunter69X, Harkon, Clarity_nl

FWIW, there's probably a good amount of mafia in this group right here. Interesting how similar it is to my "not town reads" list.

geript

10024 Posts

July 07 2015 06:57 GMT

#1826

Well he seems a lot like Oats. Constantly doing nothing. Promising to do stuff. Never following through.

geript

10024 Posts

July 07 2015 07:26 GMT

#1828

Vivax completely failing to read again. Someone with a gun, please shoot Vivax dead.

geript

10024 Posts

July 07 2015 07:28 GMT

#1829

Like that's at least the second time he's read something completely wrong in addition to taking things out of context. He's a quite decent lynch as well.

geript

10024 Posts

July 07 2015 07:38 GMT

#1833

[quote=Kelsier]
i don't remember

you dont like hf

but uou like ,marv?

???[/QUOTE]
[quote=Scott]No, you misunderstood here. Marv usually does a bit more as town then his one post - he's probably waiting for his buddy Palmar - they love to interact - I'm not caring for Marv. HF has a slight townlean for now, I liked his first post (although it could have been pre-made, I had a mindmeld with it)[/QUOTE]

Seems quite clear. Kelsier's all like, "LOL WUT??? U LIKE MARV'S BIG GAY DICK?" Scott's all like, "U RED DAT RONG BITCH. I DON'T LIKE MARV BUT HE MAY BE WAITING FOR PALMER."

I understand that english isn't your first language. But your comprehension is terrible. Somehow you thought Oats was the thread sentiment when I pushed him. Now you're trying to make a case where there's literally nothing there. You're completely divorced from any sort of actual reality. I'm just trying to figure out if you're a few nuts short of a fruitcake or if you're plain old mafia. Either way, you're a detriment.

geript

10024 Posts

July 07 2015 07:39 GMT

#1834

Kelsier wrote:
i don't remember

you dont like hf

but uou like ,marv?

???

Scott wrote:
No, you misunderstood here. Marv usually does a bit more as town then his one post - he's probably waiting for his buddy Palmar - they love to interact - I'm not caring for Marv. HF has a slight townlean for now, I liked his first post (although it could have been pre-made, I had a mindmeld with it)

Seems quite clear. Kelsier's all like, "LOL WUT??? U LIKE MARV'S BIG GAY DICK?" Scott's all like, "U RED DAT RONG BITCH. I DON'T LIKE MARV BUT HE MAY BE WAITING FOR PALMER."

I understand that english isn't your first language. But your comprehension is terrible. Somehow you thought Oats was the thread sentiment when I pushed him. Now you're trying to make a case where there's literally nothing there. You're completely divorced from any sort of actual reality. I'm just trying to figure out if you're a few nuts short of a fruitcake or if you're plain old mafia. Either way, you're a detriment.

fixed for prettiness

geript

10024 Posts

July 07 2015 07:42 GMT

#1835

I want to be clear. I think Vivax is a pretty terrible player. But this level of incompetence is really pretty stunning. Any vigi who doesn't shoot him is not clearly thinking through their shot.

geript

10024 Posts

July 07 2015 07:50 GMT

#1837

It's pretty clear. In the first he's talking about Marv lacking impetus to post/play as mafia. In the second he's saying maybe Marv is town wants to have fun with Palmer instead of other shit. But Scott is clear that he still doesn't like the low activity. They're conflicting thoughts along the same line. It's not Marv clearly 100% mafia then Marv clearly maybe 50% mafia. It's, "I don't like Marv's low activity and that makes me think he's mafia but maybe he just wants to be chill this game instead of 20p filters. This isn't rocket science.