TL Mafia LXXI: Gaiden - Page 37

On July 18 2015 04:02 Vivax wrote:
Like, you literally just defended a flipped mafia post death in your argumentation.

On July 18 2015 03:59 rsoultin wrote:
did everyone see va's read changes on hf? am i the only one who finds that hella weird? the guy was barely playing and he couldn't even remember his top townread? lol ><

On July 18 2015 03:59 rsoultin wrote:
did everyone see va's read changes on hf? am i the only one who finds that hella weird? the guy was barely playing and he couldn't even remember his top townread? lol ><

On July 18 2015 03:59 rsoultin wrote:
did everyone see va's read changes on hf? am i the only one who finds that hella weird? the guy was barely playing and he couldn't even remember his top townread? lol ><

On July 18 2015 03:59 rsoultin wrote:
did everyone see va's read changes on hf? am i the only one who finds that hella weird? the guy was barely playing and he couldn't even remember his top townread? lol ><

On July 18 2015 03:59 rsoultin wrote:
did everyone see va's read changes on hf? am i the only one who finds that hella weird? the guy was barely playing and he couldn't even remember his top townread? lol ><

On July 18 2015 03:32 rsoultin wrote:










^^^^^

va's convenient read-change on hf...you forgot? i'll grant that it's possible, but if it is SO GOOD that you're going to hard townread hf over all your reservations precisely when hf is up for lynch, i have a very hard time understanding how you forgot it in the first place

not to mention that read is pretty bogus anyway. like lol >< there is really only one good town reason to make the "joke" first post, and that is essentially if you didn't read the OP at all, and frankly even so hf knows that most hosts will post a copy of the vt pm and other pms in the scum qts of games like this...i think he was even one of the people who informed me of that last time in assassination?

you think it's natural for vt to seriously claim vt first post? granted, i'm no psyche dude or whatever, but i can tell you for a fact that i am ten times more likely to do it as scum than as town, because in the first case it buys town cred without risking anything, and in the second case it just helps scum poe blues

if you're town and this is how you really think and your jimmies are just rustled that i don't think your read is worth anything because i don't expect the majority of people in this game to be too stupid to read an op and go 'oh look, vt is called investigator, i can make a post alluding to that for free town cred!', tough

i'd ask you how you forgot your most confident townread based on that flimsy post for several cycles, but frankly there's no response to it

On July 18 2015 04:13 Vivax wrote:
Also nice to see how rso was your scumread all along and now you're both holding hands and singing kumbaya.

On July 18 2015 04:13 rsoultin wrote:
-_-

meh, i'll just go swim. being ignored puts me in a bad mood

let me break it down for the particularly slow here today

- va has hf as top townread for joke!post
- va makes a point of saying hey! look! i thought that, too! <- hint, hint: i'm vt too! (yes i'm aware this bugged me about scott, too, and he flipped town, but i really, really don't see why people say this shit, especially mr. "bluehunter", unless they're trying to use it to get townread in a very anti-town way)
- va forgets he even was townreading hf??? instead scumreads/encourages to shoot
- va suddenly "isn't sure" about hf when hf is getting lynched
- va goes "oh wait, remember that first post that i had him as top town for? yeah, he's totes town herpderp"

On July 18 2015 04:23 Clarity_nl wrote:


To be fair I've read HF's first post as likely from town from the start, it just got overshadowed by other stuff, so I get where he's coming from with that. It's not really an argument that should be used on d4 though, but why does being dumb on HF make him scum? If anything if EBH was scum he'd just jump on the wagon at some point.

I wasn't sure on HF either while he was getting lynched. It was a combination of annoyance, doubt and no real counterwagon that kept me on him (HF didn't wanna switch to ruxx).

On July 18 2015 04:25 Vivax wrote:


Can anyone tell me how a guy with such a list of possible scummers shouldn't be drooling at my analysis?

Instead he opposes everything I say? I wonder what his own arguments are for these people being scum, cause he sure didn't care to present them. Instead what we get is emotional, contradictory gibberish.

On July 18 2015 04:29 Clarity_nl wrote:


I'm not familiar with EBH/VA whatever but seems to me he's a bit all over the place in general.
I mean the guy blue hunted in his opening post on day1, you expect him to remember his reads as either alignment?

Not a great defense I admit but I think his stuff is somewhat townie and I'm willing to sheep all the dead town who said the same.

On July 18 2015 06:32 Vivax wrote:


It's only like a quarter with the conditional I attached

On July 18 2015 06:37 boxerfred wrote:

because I'm town as fuck and you're not maybe? while my efforts might've been not the greatest in terms of quality, I actually made efforts and did jump off the HF train (with a correct read btw. not so dumb now, huh?)

you got my vote, rsoul.

On July 18 2015 06:37 Clarity_nl wrote:


Basically he had the dumbtell of not knowing how many scum are in the game, but I am starting to doubt because I literally disagree with everything that he's posting.

On July 18 2015 06:52 rsoultin wrote:
being right doesn't make anyone town any more than being wrong makes anyone scum -_- like this whole argument between you two right now is pointless?