I just realized HF is HolyFlare. Whoops. So, Half the Sky. I did respond to your points. Thoughts? As for my Geript vote, I'm an impulsive player. I vote based on the hard information I have and the feel others give me. I do realize that we need to consolidate, and will switch my vote if needed.

milo109

466 Posts

July 07 2015 11:29 GMT

#1917

On July 07 2015 20:19 marvellosity wrote:

Show nested quote +

i'm just going to quote myself because i think this is really notable and i'd like to know if i'm alone in this, it could be pretty important.

That is odd. Someone town reading you is not a reason to do the same. Mafia do have to town read town.

milo109

466 Posts

July 07 2015 11:32 GMT

#1920

On July 07 2015 20:30 Palmar wrote:

Show nested quote +

That's super situational though. If someone townreads you for the right reasons it makes you feel super warm and fuzzy.

Meh. Town shouldn't be playing to stay alive but rather to find mafia(unless a power role).

milo109

466 Posts

July 07 2015 13:48 GMT

#2046

Hey Half the Sky, working at the moment. I'll be able to answer the questions in arohnd 2 hours.

milo109

466 Posts

July 07 2015 18:15 GMT

#2437

Yo HtS, I don't really understand this style of play. I'll answer your questions, but may I ask why you have decided to have this rather elongated conversation with me, a scum read? I still think KelsierSC is scum, yes. He has had the opposite reaction to me on almost every major event in the game. I've also disliked most of his one-liners, and that is almost all of his posting. I also think there is scum on both the town and mafia side of his list, something a mafia would almost have to do. As for Damdred, I also still think he is mafia. I voted for Ritoky because there isn't enough time to get a wagon started on the other two, but I would advise looking at them.

HF is weird. You're weird. LS is weird. Rsoultin is weird. Who knows if that is mafia indicative or not?

milo109

466 Posts

July 07 2015 18:52 GMT

#2479

I want to lynch ten people.

Damdred
Scott
Ritoky
HF
HtS
Clarity
Kelsier
LS
Rsoul
Vaxx(whatever his name is)

Hopefully I might be able to narrow that down a little.

milo109

466 Posts

July 07 2015 18:58 GMT

#2492

Marv, can't explain until I get a computer.

milo109

466 Posts

July 07 2015 19:14 GMT

#2514

Sigh. I'm two-shot cop. Fun fun fun.

milo109

466 Posts

July 07 2015 19:18 GMT

#2520

Because it is a 25 person game.

milo109

466 Posts

July 07 2015 19:20 GMT

#2523

Nope.

milo109

466 Posts

July 07 2015 19:20 GMT

#2526

I'm claiming to hopefully avoid one mislynch.

milo109

466 Posts

July 07 2015 19:29 GMT

#2547

Because I hated his attack on HtS. Who I also think is scum. It's complicated.

milo109

466 Posts

July 07 2015 19:40 GMT

#2574

No restrictions I dont think

milo109

466 Posts

July 07 2015 20:33 GMT

#2718

This 'afk' you speak of is me driving home. I do apologize for the necessity. My read on you two is simple. I don't like HtS's way of accusing others, and I didn't like your 'caught him in a paradox' post.

milo109

466 Posts

July 07 2015 20:33 GMT

#2719

My reads are as fluid as my votes.

milo109

466 Posts

July 07 2015 20:39 GMT

#2745

On July 08 2015 03:19 Holyflare wrote:

Show nested quote +

You REALLY can't understand why I think you're scummy??? After i've posted about 20 paragraphs about it and made a case? REALLY?

Why do I care if you're impressed. If you town read Trfel and now I think his last post was honest and start town reading him why is your initial read of suspicion and how does that make sense for a mafia holyflare to even do. It doesn't, you're grasping at straws. You have no responses for any of the questions I raise. You misquote things, you take things out of context and then you try and spin it in a scummy way (milo post, ritoky actions) and then when I do it ONCE in this game (which isn't even true) you completely flip your read around. Your thoughts do not align with your actions. Your posts have no direction. Your scum read on milo did not progress in the slightest because you were "waiting for him to answer questions" despite him posting several times after that and I was asking him questions which you still didn't acknowledge.

You keep posting how I am pushing milo but think you are also mafia which very likely makes me mafia but I am pushing milo and you think i'm mafia. That is the biggest double standard in this game. SO SO SO mafia double standardy in fact that i'm voting you.

I don't even think that HtS took my words out of context, and I think his explanation of his lack of progress was reasonable, even though I still think he is scum. That first sentence of the third paragraph is so odd. When I read that I feel like I'm reading a mafia gloating about the fact that he found a genuine logic slip. Except that it doesn't actually make any sense. Even leaving aside the poor wording, mafia can push mafia. It isn't a double standard to believe it possible.