|
On July 12 2015 10:03 Oatsmaster wrote:
Why are you only commenting on wave as people who have done nnothing? What about ebh? Or scott.
I'm scared of EBH, from the way he posts he seems like a smart player.
I didn't like his opening post with the blue hunting.
Since then though he's been making ok posts with reasoning behind them. I can understand how his logic is flowing so that's good.
I really liked how when I asked him a question, he actually re-evaluated his stance and was willing to admit he was wrong in a way that didn't seem overly defensive.
I'd say he's a slight townlean for now.
Scott is well...
I feel like a lot of his content is useless.
It's just fluff and list-posts.
He's not really pushing anyone or trying to figure out the game really.
I wouldn't be sad to see him lynched.
Slight scumlean atm.
|
On July 12 2015 10:22 LightningStrike wrote:Show nested quote +On July 12 2015 10:17 ruXxar wrote:On July 12 2015 10:12 LightningStrike wrote:On July 12 2015 10:06 ruXxar wrote:On July 12 2015 08:25 LightningStrike wrote:On July 12 2015 08:23 ruXxar wrote:
According to you then Rsoul is town and HF is scum.
What do you think about Trfel? Do you have a meta read on him?
Have you ever seen him play like this before? I had seen afkish before as town it seems weird but rsoul can read him well and I will trust her read on him. That's not good enough LS. You can't trust rsoultins opinion, she could be mafia. I want your opinion on trfel: Town or mafia? I think rsoultin is town. Tfrel most likely town? I just wish he was more active but last day phase it been mainly us just lynching damdred with a check the tracker. Yeah I can understand how you feel less incentive to participate when the lynches seem lined up, but someone mentioned that it's the perfect opportunity for the scum to hide inside the lurkers, which I don't think is bad logic. Not exactly bad logic but as you saw in our last game together HF was the most active person alive that game yet he was scum. You were semi active in that game too ye you were scum. Sometimes the big posters are indeed scum.
That's true, but I would think that HF is the exception rather than the rule.
In general it's harder to keep a natural flow as scum.
It's also harder to give opinions on people because you have to make up "fake" evaluations of people when you already know their alignment.
Those evaluations also have to evolve as the game progresses.
It's easy to fall into a lull of "I don't need to pay attention to people" as mafia, because you already know their alignment.
There's no thrill there in figuring them out.
As such when you give opinions on people you usually do it more from their filter and try to craft a case in a sort of artificial robitic way.
A town player will have paid attention to the context of people's statements and will generally evaluate more based on feelings rather than facts.
That's what I do when I play anyway.
|
Blazinghand
United States25560 Posts
Hey guys I've noticed a lot of triple posting, posting a bunch of responses to comments as several posts when you could just have one, etc. Generally, please avoid multi-posting whenever possible and consolidate posts. If you're having a conversation and miss something, or if you EBWOP, or if you think of something later, that's fine-- double posting etc is allowed. But when you are 10 of the 20 posts on a page and most of it is you responding to stuff on the previous page that you are too lazy to consolidate, it makes this game hard for you read, and more important, hard for me to read
I expect everyone to do better, as you are all capable of it.
|
Lynch Clarity, HF, Boxer, Scott.
|
On July 12 2015 11:03 milo109 wrote:
Lynch Clarity, HF, Boxer, Scott.
nh
can you flesh any of these out for me?
i don't actually have a ton to talk about today, but if you're actually town here and we're making a mistake, it would be nice to have your thoughts, and i'll talk to you about them as much as you want?
|
meeeh actually, milo...can you also address your read on rit? you were happy to lynch him after his claim...third scumread i believe...but then you changed your mind and i couldn't find anything in your filter to explain that change other than claiming cop yourself?
|
Just got back from Magic Mike XXL
It's been a few days.
|
Blazinghand
United States25560 Posts
Vote Count
milo109 (1): LightningStrike, milo109, scott31337, Oatsmaster
Not Voting (18): Marvellosity, WaveofShadow, Clarity_nl, ruXxar, Vivax, boxerfred, Trfel, ObiWanShinobi, KelsierSC, Breshke, rsoultin, Half the Sky, Harkon, Holyflare, XEliteBlueHunter69X
Currently, no one is set to be lynched. With 19 alive it takes 10 to lynch. Day ends at Monday, Jul 13 10:00pm GMT (GMT+00:00) in .
Voting is Mandatory! Voting is done in the voting thread: (link)
|
On July 12 2015 11:51 rsoultin wrote:
meeeh actually, milo...can you also address your read on rit? you were happy to lynch him after his claim...third scumread i believe...but then you changed your mind and i couldn't find anything in your filter to explain that change other than claiming cop yourself?
His WIFOM read on me. I understand what it is, and why he doesn't want to say it.
|
On July 12 2015 11:43 rsoultin wrote:nh can you flesh any of these out for me? i don't actually have a ton to talk about today, but if you're actually town here and we're making a mistake, it would be nice to have your thoughts, and i'll talk to you about them as much as you want?
Not in the mood for filter dives, but happy to chat. I wrote earlier on that either Clarity or MZ was mafia. It was just based on the reaction of clarity, and how hard he went after MZ. Pretty certain on that read now. HF... HF and I have had quite a few chats. I think his play is obviously abrasive and dismissive, and he is leading town the wrong way. Into mafia land. Boxer just feels off to me.. Scott is the same. I would lynch them in the order that I listed.
|
Back, going to try and hang for 60-90 in the wee hours. Catching up from prior to the flip...
|
On July 12 2015 12:16 milo109 wrote:Show nested quote +On July 12 2015 11:51 rsoultin wrote:
meeeh actually, milo...can you also address your read on rit? you were happy to lynch him after his claim...third scumread i believe...but then you changed your mind and i couldn't find anything in your filter to explain that change other than claiming cop yourself? His WIFOM read on me. I understand what it is, and why he doesn't want to say it.
?? is there any reason you can't say it?
lol >< meh i don't really want to talk about hf right now
i kinda understand bf and scott but not really clarity. why does there have to be scum between him and mz exactly? like i though damdy voted awfully quick on clarity...a bit wifomy, i know, but if you're really town and were roleblocked, he knew that your check was fake, so it wasn't because he was afraid you'd actually gotten a red check?
i'm practically willing to clear clarity on that alone, frankly, but i also just like a lot of his posting when i've been in-thread
|
If you want to clear him on that, you're being silly. Clarity was in no danger of being lynched there.
|
On July 12 2015 12:32 milo109 wrote:
If you want to clear him on that, you're being silly. Clarity was in no danger of being lynched there.
after geript outed with the track on damdy, he definitely wasn't
but considering this all happened before, had you kept your check i don't see how he wasn't in danger of being lynched? i'll give you that it's wifomy, but i just don't see him jumping on a check on a scummate that he knows is fake, any more than i see you two together orchestrating that on a scummate
kinda pointless
|
Here I am and nobody wants to talk.
K back to the abyss
|
whatever. I've put enough effort into this game. I've given my reads. I've told you my role. Vote as you wish.
|
On July 12 2015 12:39 WaveofShadow wrote:
Here I am and nobody wants to talk.
K back to the abyss
I'm here, catching up, some filter diving right now. Long story short I vigged MZ and that was a failure.
Ras in her last few posts is doing fine deconstructing against how milo could possibly be coming to the conclusions he is as a town DT.
WoS, basically long and short of it is that there's a load of people that for many people in the game are clocking in at null to soemwhat scum/not memorable (vivax/ebh/scott/bf/ows, etc.) and then there's discussion on the ruxxar/hf/rasputin/trfel area that has been dominating on and off the entire game. So that would be a good starting point to start going on/for. Additionally about 2-3 of us have seen reason to re-consider townreads on KSC.
|
-_- eh i had a weird reason to think milo might be town, but i think i may just be overthinking things with that response
maybe if someone else sees it
wave, i'm assuming you're not caught up, so yeah...it's not like you need us to talk to you for you to talk xP
|
I mean I can't say I've done more than skim stuff. 300 pages is fucking ridiculous, even for my standards.
Can you direct me to something/somewhere specific while I still have a shred of motivation?
|
Like without looking specifically I bet there's been people attempting to somehow push me while I wasn't playing (supposedly for good reason) and yet knowing very well this isn't how I normally play. Probably some scum in thar.
|
|
|
|
|
|
EPT
