[M][N]Holy Guardians Chapter 1 - Page 41

Hmm, only 2 ish pages after being asleep forever =[. I did see that Onegu did actually post once yesterday upon rereading through the thread though , totally missed it and thought he hadn't posted at all, to be fair though he may as well not have; here is his post, pretty void of any content (I do get an odd vibe from it though, seems he is doing an awful lot of "I am town look at me"):


I still stand by my initial two scum reads on milo and sicklucker for now but I have some reservations for each now, more so than I initially did when I made this post:

I think the fact that milo is new to forum mafia is giving me some reservations about how sure I can be that his actions indicate alignment, that said I still am suspicious of most of his actions thus far. Also my suspicions on sicklucker were addressed, tictock told me that my concerns about how sicklucker posted is actually typical of his posting, and that he posts like this as town, as with milo I still find it suspicious, but if this is his usual play (maybe someone other than just tictock can corroborate this) then it wouldn't be as suspicious.

For now they would stay on my scum list but I am going to add another. GGTemplar is reading scum to me since he arrived in the thread and his overnight posting whilst I was asleep hasn't done anything to change this.

On GGTemplar
I announced my suspicions after he had only posted twice or so in these posts:



First issue I took with GG is that he came in and posted "Hi I am townie" and then town read someone without actually reading through the thread. Town reading someone when you clearly haven't read through everything is odd to me. Here is the post in question where he town reads me:

And then what makes me fairly sure that he did that without even reading through things is that he retracts his read on me shortly after based on things that were said almost immediatly:

I also found it weird that he says to me "I agree with everything you said but the way you say it makes you suspicious", I don't get that at all but I am probably biased as it is about me.
Also note the trend of just saying everyone seems townie to him (that others have pointed out). Take a look through his filter and you will see that a large number of his posts are just him going "good point, I have a town read on you" to several people.

The other issue I took with GGT was his immediate vote onto Ticktock which I didn't understand at all, here is his post throwing down his vote:

A silly vote in my mind masked by some bullshit about "policy vote", whole thing makes no sense to me. Not to mention that he is giving someone flack for something he deems as them 'hinting being town' as he says, when his very first post was "Hi I am town". I just don't see what he sees at all. I suppose I should know from ticktock if you guys have a history similar to that of yours and sicklucker. You were able to explain the sicklucker vote on you which I also found odd, but GGTs is even stranger to me, especially if he has no history with ticktock.

This post I also don't like because ticktock was definatly stating an opinion that most of the thread held at that point in time but GGT makes the claim that TT is scummy for saying it. He also makes the claim that TT isn't being genuine and doesn't actually believe what he is saying (or that that is how TTs post appeared to him), I don't like that either.

Last thing, while not much, is the classic pure list post that is completely void of content:

I have already expressed that I don't like either of his "scum reads", if they can be called that. But what is stranger to me is the town list because again, a look through his filter will show that he has called several people townie, some of whom aren't even on the list (ritocky), and others who are on this list he hasn't even said anything about (milo, fideu).

Given that I have some reservations about my previous scum reads, as I have outlined, I think now I feel that the order of most scummy is GGT, followed by milo and then sicklucker. Even though I still find milo and sicklucker suspicious for all the reasons I stated, I think GGT is far more likely to be scum at this point in time, and thus, my vote goes on him for now.

##Unvote
##Vote: GGTeMpLaR

If you could, I would like for you to explain your list post more GGT, specifically the town reads you've put on there when you didn't even mention those people or interact with them at all before. Would also like to know if you still find tictock and myself suspicious, if not then who, if so then why?

Got to run for now, took me way longer than I expected to make this post and I'm probably going to be late for my appointment! Be back in like 90 minutes or so!

Well I am back, took me a bit to reread through the thread. :waves at Damdred:. Don't like Damdred railing on me at all and I still don't think he has given us what he promised earlier in the day, but I will save that for cycle 2.

Don't know how much time we have so I will make this quick, I actually really like GGT's posting and defense recently, and on the complete opposite end I think Chocolate's has been just terrible. It doesn't seem like there will be enough support for a milo vote, and I agree that while SL does seem off, there should be enough information to work with to go for someone else at the moment. I would just like to say that I don't like Onegus posting either, but I asked about it and everyone who has played with him tells me that this is normal from him, so I won't vote him today but if he continues like this I would never allow it to get towards the end of the game if this is all his posting is like. Also wan't to note that my two town reads are both on Chocolate, and that chocolate has put his vote on Onegu which will tell us nothing, which I find odd.

I posted my initial concerns on him earlier and like I said his defense of himself has not been good at all, I can explain more later if necessary.

##Unvote
##Vote: Chocolate