EPTi thought you had a 1 word reply
furthermore how do you ever vote someone because they have a case on you? my vote stands
Newbie Student Mafia VIII - Page 3
| Forum Index > TL Mafia |
|
Bill Murray
United States9292 Posts
i thought you had a 1 word reply furthermore how do you ever vote someone because they have a case on you? my vote stands | ||
|
Bill Murray
United States9292 Posts
scott31337 wrote: Yes, I have a meh read - not enough to go one way or the other, espically on Day 1 - is that possible? YES!Everyone else was null - Damdred and OWS were stirring the thread in the right direction, and I did not have an opionion on anybody else yet. If I added to that now, I'd give a slight town to Trfel - him and Damdred going at it looks innocent, and you look a little scummy. Fair? This is my second game - I wanted someone else to explain a "tone read" better then me looking up mafiawiki or urban dictionary - nobody ever did though. So helping newbies out is scummy? I'll have to remember that in the future. No, I do not think it is a terrible plan, because I think you are scum. I am going to OMGUS you and your terrible case. From what I read on TBD's last game, he was actualy very similar before I voted for him. He started posting afterwards, and has faded - but I don't think he'll be the lynch today - tomorrow we can re-evaluate. So you go in the same post saying "billmurray looks a little scummy" to "I think you are scum" Big jump there Scott. You are still AtA even in your defense trying to suck up to what you view as the better players... I can tell you are new or else you wouldn't find them to be good players. Ah, it's your second game. That makes sense. also *than not then. It doesn't matter if you are wanting someone to explain it better than me. That was just the icing on the cake. You are consistently deferring to other people to make analysis for you because, it is my opinion, that you have an entire player list nailed down on who is town/mafia because of deductive reasoning. This comes across in the wording of your posts. You are trying very hard to say this person leans this way or that person leans that way when to me it feels forced and contrived. I'm not coming off my vote. The fact you know and say you're OMGUSING me because "my case is bad" when you didn't even understand the major times you were giving information instead of analysis, appealing to authority, appealing to statistics, and pushing what you would view as an easy mislynch (which you are guilty of twice now considering your omgus and how often i am mislynched on d1 [so make that bloodydwarf and myself]) yeah i'll go ahead and paint you red. All in all you are beginning to look like scum to me, especially given your reaction to my case, which I'll admit was somewhat reaching | ||
|
Bill Murray
United States9292 Posts
On April 21 2015 02:59 Trfel wrote: Hello, Holyflare. This game is extremely inactive. Town isn't managing to do much of anything. There is some suspicion on Bill Murray for bluehunting. Some people want to lynch cakepie for taking a very long time between starting to read the game and posting reads, as well as being non-committal. I want to lynch Bourneq for a terrible read progression, but no one else agrees with me. ME, BLUEHUNTING? ARE YOU DUMB? DAFT? If I wanted to bluehunt I would just nightkill them wow. | ||
|
Bill Murray
United States9292 Posts
You want me to defend myself buddy? 1) I have made 2 major posts which is way more effort than I put in as mafia 2) I have been analyzing the setup regarding when we will hit lylo/mylo given different circumstances 3) I accidentally didn't realize the setup in and of itself which is a mistake mafia would be unable to make You can attack me for self meta because I realize self meta is the worst meta but any meta is better than no meta | ||
|
Bill Murray
United States9292 Posts
How come the 2 people you want to lynch are the 2 who have been suspicious of you? | ||
|
Bill Murray
United States9292 Posts
On April 21 2015 03:07 Trfel wrote: Bluehunting means finding blues, presumably so you can night kill them. There is suspicion that your statements asking the power roles to claim is bluehunting, because they claim and then you kill them. That is the biggest reason that most people are suspicious of you. Trfel I am the best person at killing blues in the night as scum I don't need to say A SINGLE WORD when I am scum to "blue hunt" | ||
|
Bill Murray
United States9292 Posts
Where I sniped the entire blue pool a year ago | ||
|
Bill Murray
United States9292 Posts
| ||
|
Bill Murray
United States9292 Posts
| ||
|
Bill Murray
United States9292 Posts
| ||
|
Bill Murray
United States9292 Posts
On April 21 2015 03:39 Trfel wrote: My reasons are clearly stated in my filter at the time. I don't know why you are asking. If you are trying to say that I am scum because of OMGUS, then say that. I just wanted to see how you would react | ||
|
Bill Murray
United States9292 Posts
On April 21 2015 03:14 Trfel wrote: Bill Murray, I don't know your meta. Why would you think that I would? I'm a new player to this site. Did you miss the part where I said that I don't want to lynch you any more? And Damdred has been pushing me the most, and at this point he's probably town. But I said that I don't want to lynch him long before. Why would I think you would? Because you (i thought it was you) referenced a post about me from a different thread? Did I miss the part where you said you didn't want to lynch me? No, I didn't, but I feel like you're lying. There is a difference between not wanting to lynch me because you don't want to, and not wanting to lynch me because you can't. Damdred hasn't been pushing you the most. He has been arguing with you. Why are you flip flopping on your Damdred read? You had him in black before, very near your list of scum, and said you only had him there "because he's damdred". You can't play the "i'm new here" card and also suck up to people you respect... how do you even know who people are? Which way do you want it? Do you want to be able to know the players or do you want to be considered a new player? Saying you don't want to lynch Damdred why though? Because he is who he is? Just because you are who you are doesn't mean that you didn't roll mafia dude. That's a terrible reason not to vote someone. I don't even think that you believe your own reasoning on that. | ||
|
Bill Murray
United States9292 Posts
awesome | ||
|
Bill Murray
United States9292 Posts
On April 21 2015 04:06 The Shining wrote: Yeah BM's off my lynch list for now. I skimmed to catch up so I'm going to reread but off of first impressions, I don't like Scott's OMGUS. And Cake doesn't look any better from that last post. Still don't think I'd lynch him but it's becoming more likely. Especially plynch voting Plot after being against his own plynch. Hypocrisy. Trfel - Suspicious of/scums Bourne - Damdred - BM - LS. You've been suspicious of a good percentage of the game already. At what point does it go from scumhunting to town paranoia to scum flinging scum every which way? Right when I was about to respond to your post and read progression on Bourne, I've got a whole new case on LS to address now. LoL. How many times has LS been mislynched for this in the past? He even mentioned it himself this game. "I usually get scummed for my list posts." But I'm who asked him for it so I won't scum him for it. yeah and it's funny because Trfel made a very very scummy nearly slippy list post himself I don't like Bourne's vote. The obvious sheep vote "well i gotta go" right now is on cake I know you guys are thinking Trfel wagon is leaking blood and you all are swarming like sharks but I really don't want to lynch Trfel right now. I believe he is likelier town than half of you. He just has somewhat been grasping at straws. It's not really alignment indicative to be throwing things out to see where they'll stick I agree with OWS in that I dont want to lynch Damdred or Trfel Damdred and Trfel are BOTH voting Cake who posted his best defense when he was directly pressured/voted, within 15 minutes coming out with a big wall to try to make himself look town my REAL problem is I wouldn't be surprised if Cake is a Powerrole. If I was scum I would easily just throw a 3rd vote onto this wagon, say well he was actively lurking, etc No, I still want to lynch Scott. Nothing Cake has done will top Scott's reaction to my shitty case on him. | ||
|
Bill Murray
United States9292 Posts
| ||
|
Bill Murray
United States9292 Posts
On April 21 2015 04:26 Holyflare wrote: what? why are you voting him but giving a provision where you don't seem to want to? he said he will be back in a few hours and is merely making that vote. The guy earlier said he wanted to lynch Trfel. This isn't out of nowhere HolyFlare. However lynching Bourne isnt a bad idea. He has been the 2nd least helpful I can think of. Let's look at worst case scenario, though. If this guy is scum, are we worried about him? No, we are not. I want to lynch someone who is going to actually be pushing good nightkills and terrible lynches masked as good lynches Someone like Scott, or even the person Bourne is voting, Trfel. Now, I don't want to lynch Trfel, but even he (if they both flipped scum) would be a MUCH better lynch than Bourne. While I will not deter the Bourne wagon more than I am, you know you are taking his post out of context. TL;DR The wording is a bit funky but it's just a placeholder vote. | ||
|
Bill Murray
United States9292 Posts
Admits to skimming Says he's not going to be active | ||
|
Bill Murray
United States9292 Posts
I'm considering voting him. I really want him to have to claim. Voting him now gives him time to be able to claim You can say I'm bluefishing all you want but I dont want to lynch a PR slot. I'd kill to have this guy replaced by someone who will actually be active and not lurking | ||
|
Bill Murray
United States9292 Posts
| ||
|
Bill Murray
United States9292 Posts
Both he and Bourne seem to be the only ones with 1 page filters. The activity this game has been great, probably due to everyone complaining with how slow it has gone. We need to stay in the Goldilocks Zone of activity, not too much, not too little. That being said, If we are going to lynch based upon activity, we need to do so today. my question then would be, if you guys are so hot and heavy on Bourne, why not LeiNadk? | ||
| ||
