On May 08 2015 10:10 sicklucker wrote:
we know theres probably 1 mafia left. We know stutters is the only one not playing. we know mafia can not concede because of third party. The dots connect

also there is probably 2 mafia left since on the day yamato got rb'd 2 people died and they needed 6+ dmg to kill them

Holyflare

United Kingdom30775 Posts

May 08 2015 01:20 GMT

#6364

On May 07 2015 08:50 indignant wrote:

Show nested quote +

Go and read how I questioned Obi again and see if his answers make sense to you.

My point is - who as the guy mafia wanted dead after night 1? Me. Except for Xata I was the one who took the most damage. Then I took 3 additional damage and scum had hopes to finish me during the night.

Who was the guy mafia wanted dead the most after night 2? SHINING. No explanation needed. And Obi moves himself below him for NO reason. Look at his explanation for this. What happens? Shining takes 3 damage.

this is the most on point thing in the thread so i have no idea why you'd ignore it and just go for stutters for being afk

Holyflare

United Kingdom30775 Posts

May 08 2015 03:08 GMT

#6398

On May 08 2015 11:45 sicklucker wrote:

Show nested quote +

yes its a potential scum role tbh hes the main rival of the protaganist. But pretty much everyones a good guy in that show so im not sure. I expect your powers to be really strong tho. Have you ever fully explain them? in the manga hes known as a "counter puncher" so thats obviously your ability here

But do you like not understand that of the 4 main character 1 has flipped scum? That means the other two remaining are almost certainly gonna be town because THEY ARE TOWN AND THERES NO REASON TO MAKE THEM NOT TOWN WHEN THEY ALREADY MADE 1 OF THEM A VILLIAN TO BALANCE IT.

If nothing else aiko and my role are bascily two pees in a pod so they are likely to be the same role for that readon

terrible reasoning, onegu said he named all the roles and then rng'd alignments

Holyflare

United Kingdom30775 Posts

May 08 2015 06:55 GMT

#6400

Why do you think I haven't been pushing that mass name claim thing I brought up before? I simply asked him. Besides, it would be a terribly broken game if it wasn't that way.

Holyflare

United Kingdom30775 Posts

May 09 2015 05:04 GMT

#6470

On May 09 2015 14:01 Damdred wrote:
The only conclusion is that someone lied about dmg or we have an extra kp on a 6 man scum team meh

the latter is entirely plausible and there may have been some kind of vig power, think it's pretty wifom to talk about rather than assuming someone is lying tbh

Holyflare

United Kingdom30775 Posts

May 09 2015 05:35 GMT

#6475

I mean I know I should be putting effort in but I think the game is pretty much over after today/tomorrow

Holyflare

United Kingdom30775 Posts

May 09 2015 10:01 GMT

#6478

hmm the dmg i took could have actually been mafia kp btw, I think it's better to vote obi

Holyflare

United Kingdom30775 Posts

May 09 2015 10:31 GMT

#6480

I don't particularly think any of those people are mafia though? They have 1-2 people left and at least one of them has the ability to switch fights around, stutters has dmg'd me and bus driven me, chez has done some weird shit giving people towels and radios and sending me to see my mother and that just leaves bats and obi, I mean, if you want to hedge your bets it's probably best to kill 2 of them at once since bats claimed 30 hp or something entirely ridiculous but in terms of powers obi has been moving into some weird shit places and people have been taking dmg and we've never seen his power go off and he's been generally underwhelming.

I really don't see how obi goes from the last newbie game where he was flaming people and telling them to play and getting all annoyed at people not particularly doing things and being all pro town to this games obi unless he's genuinely uninterested and mafia/3p. I guess you could make the argument for bats not using powers too but he's done some stubborn shit like putting people into fights that he thought were best instead of listening to people and meh I got this far and realised he hasn't really done much either

basically i may have actually taken kp which means 2 kp happened yesterday and bats was rb'd so meh?

Holyflare

United Kingdom30775 Posts

May 09 2015 10:57 GMT

#6482

sep was crazy scummy that night? don't think mafia would have used kp on him at all??? didn't he claim cop in the day phase? it doesn't add up at all anyway, the missing dmg is only 1 or 2 and loads of people keep seemingly taking 1 or 2 little bits of dmg for no reason

Holyflare

United Kingdom30775 Posts

May 09 2015 11:01 GMT

#6483

basically i may have actually taken kp which means 2 kp happened yesterday and bats was rb'd so meh?

^ the most relevant part

the stuff about the fight changing was that it got changed on day 2 into me and marv so mafia have that power (maybe 3p? but unlikely since mafia should have one of those powers if town does?) and the other people you mentioned had powers that weren't particularly relevant to fight changing, bus drivers/item vendor thing

Holyflare

United Kingdom30775 Posts

May 09 2015 11:20 GMT

#6485

On May 09 2015 20:17 Breshke wrote:

Show nested quote +

Mmm I don't remember/wasn't in touch with the game as much as i should have been so idk but from what i remember even if he was scummy we were going to be putting him into fights because he said he was a heavy hitter so I could say mafia could have put kp on him because they ddin't want us to utilize his extra damage. I realize im grasping here though.

Show nested quote +

I don't really want to lynch bats either he is on the bottom of that lynch list for me.

Well like... Do you agree or disagree with what I said about the powers then? :o obi is ultimately the best lynch imo since there could be variables that we don't know about if he's mafia in a fight