Also if someone asks while I sleep most likely explanation of holding rb I suppose is that scum team didn't want to confirm anyone else since the town rb just flipped.

Damdred

15669 Posts

May 05 2015 14:35 GMT

#5717

I'd rather kill bats today I think.

Damdred

15669 Posts

May 05 2015 14:40 GMT

#5722

Honestly I already have, I blocked Yamato the kps went through anyway, a 6 man team is kinda doubtful so id rather just lynch another scummy person and see what shinings check tells us

Damdred

15669 Posts

May 05 2015 14:44 GMT

#5725

Btw do we have a screenshot of where players were before hand?

Damdred

15669 Posts

May 05 2015 14:46 GMT

#5728

Don't want to lynch obi, really close to his town meta atm.

I could listen to chez, ls though

Damdred

15669 Posts

May 05 2015 14:55 GMT

#5732

Its not quite as close as you think it is for obis meta all in all. Scum hes always looking for an out as scum and not leaving himself in a bad position like the reads you just posted.

he did some of the same things in Slythern mafia. I suppose if I had to characterize his scum game its cleaner than his town game, he doesn't make sense as town and he makes more sense as scum.

Its just general things that make me not want to lynch him at this point

Damdred

15669 Posts

May 05 2015 14:59 GMT

#5735

Well you do make sense most of the time obi but as town you do nonsensical things that you wouldn't do as scum. Like town reading two scum partners who will be prone to flip

Damdred

15669 Posts

May 05 2015 15:03 GMT

#5742

Vivax is a sinking ship in this game how hard aligned he was with sandroba though, and his play d1 was lackluster and probably would of been lynched d2 if not for the tracker check anyway.

but that's besides the point.

Damdred

15669 Posts

May 05 2015 15:07 GMT

#5745

I don't think y will agree with me whatever I say in regards to that, but I don't think scum obi would link himself so early and leave himself with very little options if they flip.

Damdred

15669 Posts

May 05 2015 15:15 GMT

#5747

I think someone asked me why breshke is so high up, I think its very likely Jean checked him. And his play while uninspiring I don't see a lot of scum motivation in it at this point

Damdred

15669 Posts

May 05 2015 19:20 GMT

#5837

I honestly don't know how anyone has a townread on LS at this point.

I don't think that hes necessarily mafia really....but I do think its highly possible hes a third party. Then again that whole jester mess has me scratching my head even more

Damdred

15669 Posts

May 05 2015 19:25 GMT

#5838

Honestly at this point I've read a lot of filters and what not.

Damdred, Indignant, Xatalos are the three people I really won't entertain anything on till much later in the game if we get to that point.

Have a decent reason to town read but want them to do more Breshke

Don't want to lynch today, Yamato, Sicklurker, Stutters.

Think that they could be town, some things make sense as they are town from a meta standpoint. Obiwan.

Third Party Land (?) Chezinu, LightningStrike(?)

Probable Mafia Batsnacks

Hope the Gym works out: HF

Damdred

15669 Posts

May 05 2015 19:36 GMT

#5842

N1: HF takes 6 damage (factional kp assumption)
FF is tracked to Xatalos and Rsoultin (rolecheck possible on Rsoultin)
Rsoultin is hit for 2 dmg and Roleblocked (Matches up to my ability and not Vivax roleblock)
Xatalos is hit for 12 Dmg
Indignant is hit for 12 dmg
Marv is hit for 7 Dmg
Vivax claims 2 dmg and roleblocked (Damdred claims this block)

D2: Jat is healed by FF for an unspecified amount
FF is flipped
JAT takes 3 random dmg at eod

N2: Rsoultin Is Roleblocked and takes 0 dmg (?)
Sepu takes 2 dmg and Roleblock (Damdred claims dmg) Stutters redirects dmg from HF PGO to Sepu for 6-7 (?) HF claims dmg is missing.
HF takes 8 dmg (Stutters claims)
JAT receives 6 Dmg
Breshke receives dmg
Shining receives 6 dmg

D3: Vivax is flipped roleblocker
Sepu faints mysteriously
Shining takes 3 dmg randomly eod

N3: HF disappears from game
Damdred takes 3 dmg
Rsoultin takes at least 10 dmg (?)
Shining takes at least 3 dmg
Lightninstrike takes 1 dmg
Yamato Roleblocked and takes 2 dmg

This is what my spreadsheet for dmg states have I missed anything just for keeping up with things?

Damdred

15669 Posts

May 05 2015 19:45 GMT

#5844

Some of it is POE, it has to be at this point a bit.

Early on you have sandro as a scum read/lean and you never mention him again for a good portion of the day. You vote on vivax but almost never interact with him. You also don't really show a real progression on either read and just sort of drop both to vote with both of them on yamato.

While its true that you are a smurf and so activity isn't necessarily indicative you are a decent bit less active than you normally are as town. And you haven't tried any of your typical trap plays or really tried to solve the games even in a backsnacks way. Typically i'm used to seeing bats being engaged around lynch time and d1 since that was almost the only lynch I do not see it as much.

His ability that he has claimed also doesn't make sense to an extent, for example why does he visit the people he chooses to put in the fight? When shining revealed he caught FF he revealed that he visited Xata, i'm still not sure why he would be visiting necessarily when the fight happens during the day. That's probably not as alignment indicative as I think it is but it is interesting.

The three dmg is also interesting to me HF talked about it some as well, could be coincidence but I think its a bit more.

Still feels a bit disconnected at points in the filter and in the thread unless you are specifically going after him.

Just a few things and poe.

Damdred

15669 Posts

May 05 2015 19:46 GMT

#5845

On May 02 2015 08:03 Breshke wrote:
Took 2 damage.

Who sent me a present?

Damdred

15669 Posts

May 05 2015 19:51 GMT

#5848

Well i'm not exactly sure why you wouldn't support it I don't think there are really reasons to town read bats eh?

But on another topic, how many herbs can Sl hand out a night?

Damdred

15669 Posts

May 05 2015 19:55 GMT

#5850

But that's not a reason to town read or push against the lynch of someone who put up two pretty towny people for a amateur fight, or two people who were going to either be lynched or be in the main fight wasteing the moves anyway.

Damdred

15669 Posts

May 05 2015 19:56 GMT

#5851

i'll be afk for a bit but you can keep talking about this and i'll respond later.

Also the sl ability should be looked at a bit, i'm kinda thinking it has to be town but i'm not sure i'll explain when i'm back

Damdred

15669 Posts

May 05 2015 21:15 GMT

#5865

LS that argument is so bad...

I've already given an argument, I know your meta better than almost anyone in this game. Even games where you were "lazy" as town makes this look worse.

You pressured people had ongoing thoughts and Scum reads etc., you were super lazy in joat and guardians and it looks closer to here thananything

Damdred

15669 Posts

May 05 2015 21:19 GMT

#5868

It's not like you are really up on the block honestly you could be spending your time better.