Mafia Mini Mafia2: another miniature game of mafia - Page…

On April 10 2015 12:47 GlowingBear wrote:
Damdy you make your case look like a vote count analysis when it's just narratives. A huge pile of fluff.

The effort you've put makes me wary because I know you're effortless as Mafia. The problem is that you put effort into deceiving people, making them believe you made a huge vote count analysis when you actually just post narratives.

I said once and I'll repeat: town Damdred knows me too well to call me Mafia for the reasons you called me Mafia for.

You have an idea of what my tells are. Where did you see them in this game?

On April 11 2015 12:26 GlowingBear wrote:
Like, Damdy, I decided to take a step back and try to see you coming from a town perspective. For instance I thought that if you were Mafia, your team wouldn't try to roleblock a possible jail keeper when you were in danger of being shot by the vigi.

But I fail to see you coming as town Damdred everytime I read you. I simply can't believe in any of your posts. Your night post is, again, not a "legacy" as you try to make it look like. It fits much more of a frightened Mafia perspectice who desperately seek to look townie in order to not get shot.

I fail to see what people are seeing as townie in you.

On April 12 2015 03:42 Vivax wrote:
Ritoky the moment you post a meta guideline for how to identify you as town is the moment you have a guideline for how to play as mafia.

OH BUT I TROLL ALL GAEM I CANT BE MAFIAZ. Meta is meta and your contributions to this game are zero. Your play is maximum half assed.

On April 12 2015 03:50 ritoky wrote:


every1 keeps telling me it gna be a girl, what name should i prepare for that?

2 games since i posted it, all of them have lined up with that post 1 way or the other, it's your fault if you don't follow the guy tryin to give you a helping hand.

On April 12 2015 03:46 Damdred wrote:
So your scum team is Koshi/Palmar and ? vivax?

On April 12 2015 04:00 Vivax wrote:
Lynching yamato is actually a very attractive option. Palmar doesn't play on weekends.

On April 08 2015 18:56 yamato77 wrote:



Based on this post alone, I'm willing to townread Damdred.

He gives a short but accurate summation of Eden's play (and the problems with it) which shows both attentiveness to the thread and a critical level of analysis about Eden's lack of overall attentiveness to actual thread happenings that people would call important.

Why does Eden soulread rsoul at that point in the game? Why didn't he comment on GB, the leading lynch and perhaps the most-talked-about player in the game. It is strange. I scumread him for the same sort of reasoning. The fact that Damdred reached a similar conclusion with similar reasoning is enough to call him town.

---

Eden

To segue nicely here, let's talk about Eden and his choice of discussion topics.



I pointed out this post as horrible because it IS horrible. Not liking some sort of distracting thread-game is not alignment indicative. If one player decides to endlessly bitch about it and do nothing else, sure, but for me to simply opt out of joining in on HF's stupidity should not be anything alignment indicative to anyone. I'll talk more about this later when I get to HF but my point is THIS TYPE OF POST IS FUCKING STUPID



These are his reads, for better or worse. He doesn't really explain ANY of his townreads, and his scumreads are all "called me scum but didn't vote me". Aside from that he comments on NOTHING ELSE THAT HAS HAPPENED IN THE GAME.

Who gives out thin townreads and is preoccupied with how other players perceive them? Mafia. He does this at the expense of noting the huge Palmar/GB interaction that goes on for pages. I find it difficult to believe a townie overlooks that and simply focuses on people "scumreading" him.

As for his explanation...



"skimmed gb's posts". But didn't he earlier call Palmar town? Shouldn't that clue him in on GB? and then...



>_________>

then we get the list post



Apparently he's confident enough to call Palmar town but HE DOESN'T EVEN REMEMBER WHAT PALMAR WAS DOING, BY HIS OWN ADMISSION

HE STILL HASN'T LOOKED AT GB! (wtf?!)

His read on me is so non-committal it makes me want to puke.

Soooooo yeah. I don't understand how he read the thread.



Apparently he's even really attentive, but entertains the idea that he should keep people's reads secret, for whatever reason. It doesn't make any sense. HOW DID HE NOTICE THIS IN HF's POST AND NOT KNOW WHY PEOPLE WERE VOTING GB?!?!

Page 3 of his filter is him actually going back and reading the thread, and at the end of it he comes back with this:



Lol? Two of his townreads aren't actually town to him now and Vivax suddenly isn't scum?

Wtf was he doing before this point, if he's going to arrive at this conclusion now? Fucking off? Ugh.



And apparently I'm now town as well, just becuase I played ONE SCUM GAME where I didn't post basically at all?

Did you know that I've won as scum before in a game that contained rayn, marv, and Palmar all as town? My range of scum play isn't simply "doesn't play whatsoever", yet Eden is confident enough after reading a single filter of mine to give me a townread.

Overall, Eden's initial reads to the game fucking blew, and his reread of the game has him coming back with complete 180s on several people. It's nice to see that he's able to change his mind but I find it difficult to believe a lot of his reasoning. He's definitely not lynchworthy but he stuck out to me early. The more I read what I've written, the more likely I am to just call his early game play fucking lazy and write him off as town if his activity continues.

Damdred still gets points for noting his shitty early play.

---

Holyflare

I'm only commenting on his posts about me/obi because they are the only things actually related to the game of mafia!

http://i.imgur.com/AJAwkQ6.png

Boils down to:

"yamato doesn't like my game so he's mafia"

lolhf

fucking play the game.

http://i.imgur.com/DJnkL7n.png

Also boils down to:

"obi doesn't like my game so he's mafia"

lolhf

fucking play the game.

(notably, he must think eden is town because he also picks out posts where we shit on Eden. lolhf)
???

alignment: who the fuck knows? having fun does not = town

---

List Thingy For People Too Dumb To Read

Because there are many of you and I don't discriminate

ritoky
rsoul
Koshi
gb
eden
Palmar
damdred?
obi
HF
Onegu
Vivax
DreadReturn

##Unvote
##Vote: DreadReturn

On April 12 2015 04:34 Damdred wrote:
Ok so obviously i'm happy that my preferred lynch is leading at this point. None of my townies or confirmed towns believe in this lynch though, which is really frustrating because all of them think I am decent at finding mafia. So I really invite you again to look at the points that I brought that Palmar brought and look at games like arnie got a gun Fanfiction Mafia.

And vote GB. I'm not going to waste my vote though, i'd rather you guys move to GB.