|
On April 11 2015 21:15 Soren333 wrote:Show nested quote +On April 11 2015 07:04 jarjarbinks wrote:On April 10 2015 20:43 Soren333 wrote:On April 10 2015 20:24 prplhz wrote:soren333 what do you think about jarjarbinks defense of bloodydwarf? i think it was pretty good. On April 10 2015 15:24 jarjarbinks wrote: [...]1. He kept getting more and more defensive and not looking logical 2. He didn't early vote someone (right?) thinking that it isn't a big deal. 3. He didn't read the rules or something, which makes me think he is liable to focus on people scumming him because he doesn't really grasp what he is supposed to be doing. 4. Look how much attention dwarf got. [...] especially 1 1. Saying that someone loses a logical standpoint more and more seems to come from scum than townie because scum obviously clammed up and lost his shit. However, considering that dwarf came into the game without reading the op and was under the influence of sc2 arcade mafia, this is understandable. 2. I think he did vote. 3. Makes sense. 4. He got attention, but I don't see how this is a reason to town read him. My point on 4 was comparing Dwarf to plot. When Dwarf went crazy, people jumped on him. Not everyone, but enough people I would say. When plot did it? Pretty much disregarded until I mentioned things. I would think that mafia people would be more hesitant to jump on their partner. Again, not a strong point but most of my points weren't that strong. Let me check the vote thing. I might have been wrong lol What did plot do?
lol... so my defense of dwarf was really just to show the differences to their reactions at being voted on. I was trying to say plot looks worse than dwarf. They both did the same thing actually. Both voted early on someone. Then overreacted when they got scumread/voted on early.
The key difference was that plot talked about how early votes didn't mean much before he overreacted. He later makes a defense for it, which I'm not sure I believe. I'm diving him and Prp after all this catch up.
|
On April 11 2015 23:37 rsoultin wrote: meh lol
plot and wallpost of null beautiful
bourne i still cant follow, why plot now ><
tch, sorry guys im out for the day
plot/soren should be the lynch...if not follow bresh...hes smart and prob town this game
ill be back later this evening
....using logic....lol
soooo if prp, bresh and me are her top town reads....that means....
MY MANFEELINGS!
|
On April 10 2015 07:30 plotspot wrote: Since the rules states I have to vote, and I can't decide, I vote alphabetically. It's still plenty time lift for interaction, I might change my vote anytime, hence I asked whether we can change our vote. I don't see it written on the first page about changing votes. So better vote before I forget to.^^ Btw, I didn't read any mafia threads yet, just the general guide.
This post aligned with him describing his vote was alphabetical (to me) is saying "this vote is too early to actually matter so Aces technically shouldn't get mad at the vote."
|
On April 12 2015 01:46 plotspot wrote: Lol I'm found out, why don't you all vote me? Then you don't have to discuss anymore why to vote anyone else. This might spare distrust within town.^^ Top readers here. Obviously I've made it look too easy. Too bad.^^
lol you still got time!
Of all the people scumming you right now, which one do you think is most likely the mafia person trying to hop on the train?
|
On April 10 2015 08:12 plotspot wrote: I'm considering changing my vote to Onegu. He's playing like a fucktard. But of course I'm still not sure whether it's his strategy or him inadvertently not "getting" some of the things.
Overreaction to Onegu scumming him....
|
On April 11 2015 07:43 plotspot wrote:
I only said I considered switching my vote, because he made 2 strange mistakes, like wanting a voting thread or saying I didn't explain myself to prplhz when easy checking could have confirmed I did. It was very early in the game, but why am I explaining things, isn't the uncertainty what he is obvious in the quote?
Defense. This IS feasible. I COULD be tunneling on him. I could see him coming up with this though to look better. If anyone's around please halp
|
On April 12 2015 01:55 plotspot wrote: Like I give away my partners.^^ I want scum to win remember? Why would I do that? Ok, since town should have a chance as well. I'm giving out 4 names, that's maximum 50%, be happy: Bourneq, Soren666, Half the Sky and prplhz. And don't ask, I won't explain.^^
lolz so If was to come by with a dollar and say "Mr. George Washington REALLY WANTS you to give up your scumpartners" would you change your mind?
On another note, I didn't find too much else in your filter. Your biggest post is defensive (which is bad). That being said from reading your posts I don't think you are holding back anything (which is towny).
I think you are definitely lynchable today. You have mentioned you are seeing the train coming. Advise? Make a case on one of those guys. Show your trying to find scum rather than defend yourself.
Personally I think you are hilarious, if that means anything...lol
|
Ya you got the tunneling one. Not sure about the baby seal.
|
On April 10 2015 09:43 prplhz wrote:Show nested quote +On April 10 2015 09:41 Half the Sky wrote:On April 10 2015 09:31 prplhz wrote: 1 the observation was incorrect 2 he just claimed town in mini mafia xxx and he was scum Townies can be incorrect. I pay attention to the tone and the timing. Onegu in his town games, for what I recall, claims VT or town early on in game. I know I played Hammertime with him and I don't recall a VT/town claim in that. Admittedly I did not pay as much attention to XXX. If I recall correctly though from the obs QT, I think that claim came on pretty late, or when he was in more trouble. okay i don't see the tone or the timing as anything to give townlean for the second part of your post is pure nonsense lol like complete nonsense
Prp, for saying you never look towny you look pretty towny in this game. I liked your prodding of HTS. I also liked your recent spat with Soren. Tunneling on Bourneq isn't too terrible either, as he wasn't too strong early game if I recall. Your standing went up in my book.
|
On April 12 2015 02:20 plotspot wrote: So I am "lynchable today", but you don't necessarily think I'm scum? Hey townsfolk, he is suspicious.^^ How do I make people think 100% that I'm scum, still trying to work this out.^^
Defense is bad right? yeah I know. I've given up on it. But what did prplzh say? Defense is better than "rolling over". He is on the defense, definitely scummy.^^
lol
Yes "lynchable" as in scummy enough for me to be OK lynching you. I understand the confusion and how you can spin it though.
|
@Prp
what do you think of bourneq's recent play?
|
I'm leaving to play some Frisbee golf. Might miss the flip, might make it. I'll leave my list and vote in this post.
IF I had to say someone's town:
1. Stutters- not a lot of posts but I like what I see 2. Tubesock- crazy theory correct or no, usually town pulls out those crazy theories. Plus if Dwarf IS Godfather, then Tube is definitely MVP.
Prob town? Concerns
1. Breshke- Lack of attention early got me curious, but my analysis shows town behavior. 2. Soren- Prodded early. Disappeared and called out for it. Miraculously comes back when called out. Good analysis after though and I liked his prodding. 3. Prp- Recent analysis of him looks towny. I might not like the blatant sheep but Bourneq train probably isn't starting Not Lynchable
1. HTS- Decent analysis but a couple things bothered me. Still probably vocal enough to catch later if she is evil 2. Bourneq- Someone I want to look into more, but haven't. I thought the beginning was weak. 3. Onegu- Where did he go?
Lynchable
1. Dwarf- Theory could ring true I guess. His actions were definitely not helping town. Could be new (I was kind of similar) 2. Plot- Yup. The guy I can't shake. Gonna be my vote unless something crazy happens.
|
On April 12 2015 02:40 plotspot wrote:Show nested quote +On April 12 2015 02:33 jarjarbinks wrote:On April 12 2015 02:20 plotspot wrote: So I am "lynchable today", but you don't necessarily think I'm scum? Hey townsfolk, he is suspicious.^^ How do I make people think 100% that I'm scum, still trying to work this out.^^
Defense is bad right? yeah I know. I've given up on it. But what did prplzh say? Defense is better than "rolling over". He is on the defense, definitely scummy.^^
lol Yes "lynchable" as in scummy enough for me to be OK lynching you. I understand the confusion and how you can spin it though. I don't understand the bold part. If you could elaborate that would be great. Is "spin it" another mafia terminology for some kind of stuff?
I don't think its a term for this game or anything. It's kind of something like the news does?
It's kind of like how news anchors can "spin" somebody's quote to make them appear like they are saying something they don't mean. I wish I could think of a good example of people doing that. If you watch college basketball, I could give you a good reference.
|
|
Missed the sis on my list...lol
She's under prp (prob town? section). Concern on the ace tunnel, which I think she's done with. They stuff she did last night and today looked pretty good though.
|
Sorry we killed you plot. I hope you keep playing cuz I really thought you were pretty funny. Hope to see you back on here!
I'll be on for a little bit to catch up. Anyone else on?
|
I'm not seeing the case against stutters. Out of his top 3 scum targets (bresh, prp, and plot), plot was gaining traction and he had to leave. It wouldn't make sense to place a vote on the other two at the time.
I thought it was interesting that he said he was very liable to bus as a mafia teammate(and would bus a bad mafia teammate), and then hts votes plot BECAUSE she thought he wouldn't bus. Did she just miss his quote? It seemed like she was analyzing him pretty hard at the time to decide her vote. Crucial time to miss something like that in a guy with a small filter.
|
On April 12 2015 15:47 The Shining wrote: Sort of. Top of page 23. At this pace, I should be caught up before EoN though, provided I don't fall asleep lol.
Nice to see you again, JJB. I came in dead set on nailing you in particular if I read you as scum at all(See: our last game together). I'm really hoping your alignment is diff this time around lol.
lol that's why I secretly wanted you to take my spot before the round started. I saw you wanting to play and I was like O CRAP i'm totally paying for my sins this round. I hope your as good this time around as last time. You were so spot on last round lol
in my defense that game I did call myself "the scummiest" like 4 or 5 times that game lol
What do you think of strutters and hts so far?
|
On April 12 2015 05:58 Half the Sky wrote: Stutters voted plotspot. Would someone bus someone this early in a newbie game?
He's a veteran, but probably not.
##unvote ##vote stutters695
Can I call myself an idiot now? Disregard that bit about hts
|
On April 12 2015 06:02 Onegu wrote:Show nested quote +On April 12 2015 05:58 Half the Sky wrote: Stutters voted plotspot. Would someone bus someone this early in a newbie game?
He's a veteran, but probably not.
##unvote ##vote stutters695
I think rsoul is. My second newbie I bussed the shit out of my partners day one
She does have a tendency to bus "bad" mafia teammates. I wouldn't say she started the train on plot, but I think her vote greatly helped it get traction. Leader-1st follower mentality. I don't know if I would say that is the smartest play (and she is beyond logical) unless she didn't see anyone else as an easy lynch.
I'm interested in your case on her though. She seems less "on top of the game" than the last time I played with her, but that could be due to the whole travel/LS thing.
|
|
|
|