Newbie Student Mafia VII - Page 14

On April 16 2015 03:02 Trfel wrote:
After rereading Breshke's filter, he is my strongest townread.

He hasn't necessarily been the most forceful player here, but he's shown a clear desire to solve the game. He's been sharing important reads, and he's made a lot of very good observations. I just don't see Breshke being scum here.

If you would like a meta reason, Breshke suffered from inactivity in the last game I played with him (Guardians of the Galaxy). He still made several key observations, but ended up being mislynched for his periods of inactivity. Given that I feel that his posts in this game have been more insightful than last, I am even less inclined to lynch him.

On April 16 2015 03:23 Trfel wrote:
Okay, fine, his Day 2 was weaker. But I don't care? He played an extremely solid Day 1. Read through his filter again, there's an explanation for everything he's been doing.

On April 16 2015 03:35 Trfel wrote:
To be honest, right now I'm kind of wondering if the hosts screwed up and didn't make any scum team. Really though, I'm kind of kicking myself. I'll spend maybe another hour or so digging through filters trying to find something, but then I'd better get to my schoolwork, as I'm quite far behind.

I guess the people I'm most suspicious of are Bourneq, The Shining, and maybe Tubesock or Stutters695.

I'm leaving you (rsoultin), Half the Sky, and jarjarbinks for later. I'm looking at prplhz presently, though I don't expect to find much that is scummy.

On April 16 2015 06:39 Bourneq wrote:
Explain to me please what we achiev with not lynching? Newbie question im sure but I need to know before I cast a vote.

On April 16 2015 06:42 Trfel wrote:
I just eventually realized that I don't think that no lynching has that big of an effect on our chances of winning.

It gives scum an extra night kill, but they'll just kill our towniest player. And at this point, we kind of need to start assuming that our somewhat towny people are town, since we can't afford to be paranoid about everyone (unless you have a ton of time on your hands, in which case by all means go ahead). I think that the main value of no lynching is to get extra time to solve the game. This helps me quite a bit, since I have a bunch of work to do over the next day (real time), but I'm not sure if it would help enough to warrant dragging the game out for three extra days (real time).

It's basically up to everyone else. If they want to play the game and scumhunt, no lynching is the best play. If people are kind of done, I'm fine to just lynch and end it.

On April 16 2015 07:03 Trfel wrote:
You know, I didn't believe him, but this reaction is extremely scummy. Maybe he really is on to something.

On April 16 2015 07:04 prplhz wrote:
i can't. rso is scum because she's really good at mafia but she only done mafia things and she's notting putting in that effort she does as town. especially letting two townies getting lynched while acting like she hadn't a clue what a tone read is. anyway i suggest we don't no lynch today, me or rso go go go. i'll tell you the other two scum before i die but i'm a little less sure of them.

shoutout to onegu for getting this right on d1.

On April 16 2015 07:05 prplhz wrote:
rso trfel is super town just you suggesting he is scum is ridic. i hope people realize because i'm so shit at explaining things

On April 16 2015 07:17 Bourneq wrote:

How come? Quoted from OP "If there is a tie for most votes, whoever most recently had more votes than the other is the person who is up for the lynch."
Concidering there is talk of not voting at all then there is quite the chance that it could matter.

On April 16 2015 07:18 Trfel wrote:
A vote for a no lynch is still a vote.

If we do end up with a tie, which isn't terribly likely, then it will be the order of the last votes that matter, not the first.

On April 16 2015 07:39 Breshke wrote:
I really think we should actually no lynch here because there is a possibility we will kill the roleblock. It is quite obvious now that our setup is vet/vigi which is the worse one because town can jsut roelblock their kill every night because who cares if the vigi shoots because even if they hit scum it doesn't gain town a misslynch and if they hit town we lose a misslynch.

This being said we can get a misslynch back if we lynch the roleblocker today.

I also think lynching Rso today is great. The most damming thing that makes rso scum is the fact that she has not made a will post either of the nights. I let this slide N1 because she was travelling or whatever but this is something TOWN rso ALWAYS does. The only game she ever didn't do this she was mafia and reflected on it later that she was suprised noone noticed. She doesn't do this as mafia because she obviously does not think she is going to die so does not feel the need to leave information to town in that eventuality.

##Vote Rso

On April 12 2015 21:36 rsoultin wrote:


lol sorry fell asleep >< on the plus side im on track to be home an hour or two before eon so woot

unlikely? 4:7 is actually fairly close...just need 2 vote switches...that said its possible if one of the wasted votes was a scum player lol but i dont see the need for risky plays here?

if it was town/town id look for non-committal type shifts to stutters. maybe hts? and/or wasted votes. prob 1-2 mafia on the main wagon. onegu almost def not scum in that case cause of how vocal he was about the lynch

kk not gonna post overall reads right now cause i think im super behind but top towns at the moment: bresh (revisit if stutters scum) and tube (enthusiasm on dwarf seemed like excited townie thinking hed found something awesome lol)

prp i think i need to reread just cause so many ppl seem to have a diff read? ive been mostly skimming so lol coulda missed something

mmmm shinings entrance last night looked pretty good? wasted vote not so much xP but i dont remember the context for hus vote so yeah

also sidenote bus means scum on scum so...huh?

kk starting the drive now @.@

On April 16 2015 08:56 Breshke wrote:


This is a really nice paragraph even though im still fairly certain you are scum. I don't think you really think my D2 was that bad. You asked me for reads and i gave you 3 town reads that i was fairly sure about at the time. ( less sure about JJB right now because of stuff prp has said). Yes i still do agree that it is important to talk stuff through during the night phase but i wasn't really interested in talking with you because i didn't want to mention then will post thing because iw anted to see if you would post one or not.

I think this second paragraph is you being frustrated as scum because people are pushing you for reasons that you dont think make you scum and it is really frustrating you. I dont think anyone wants to lynch you because you havnt lynched mafia. Maybe you are referring to this post.



I don't think prp means that by the bolded i think he is saying that you still lynched TBD even though all the points he brought against him being town. He would be the best to explain that though.