On March 23 2015 21:04 Palmar wrote:
Like almost the entirety of my perceived uselessness comes from the fact that I never managed to get a good read on marv this game which is uncharacteristic for me, but also a weird thing to do if I'm mafia (I think). Just that little thing clouded up so much of the game for me.

no, it isn't, it's quite characteristic

just usually one or the other of us dies before it can rumble on for eternity like it did this game

marvellosity

United Kingdom36161 Posts

March 23 2015 13:53 GMT

#6390

i think horn was the first game ever you committed to a townread on me when we didn't lynch mafia day 1.

marvellosity

United Kingdom36161 Posts

March 23 2015 13:55 GMT

#6392

that is true

marvellosity

United Kingdom36161 Posts

March 23 2015 15:08 GMT

#6397

yes, it seems so long ago now...

it's pretty nice letting other people lynch mafia

it's less nice when you get your ass bitten later for not crusading it in the first place

another ironic thing - you give me massive credit for my capabilities as mafia that I don't even have
but then you made the argument that if I were mafia I might not bus jat and I would hope that he managed to dig himself out of the hole, which in turn gives me not enough credit for my *actual* strengths
i *always* know when a scumbuddy is going down and I act sooner rather than later.

funny game.

marvellosity

United Kingdom36161 Posts

March 23 2015 15:08 GMT

#6398

actually i made one post that would truly be the best post in the game if rayn is mafia, i'll see if i can find it

marvellosity

United Kingdom36161 Posts

March 23 2015 15:09 GMT

#6399

On March 18 2015 01:35 marvellosity wrote:
Essentially my position has been the same all day.

People I will lynch:
1. rayn
2. whoever rayn wants

^

I give myself two options, they would be
1. mafia
2. mafia

marvellosity

United Kingdom36161 Posts

March 23 2015 15:17 GMT

#6406

I can help you with your case on rayn. Not whether I believe it or not. Further things (on top of the things I mentioned before) that I found odd, and haven't really been expanded on that much.

Remember when Koshi got mad that rayn wouldn't clarify his claim, and claimed himself? And rayn still wouldn't clarify forever, before finally claiming VT. But it went on for ages, and the thread was turning to shit. If you're actually VT, the right play is to simply put your hands up much sooner and say "ok ok, i'm VT, I fakeclaimed to secure the lynch", rather than drag it out for so long.

rayn went from voting you at the start of yesterday to being "absolutely convinced" that Eden was mafia. I don't believe it was in any way possible to be convinced that Eden was mafia.

In fact I afked from the thread because I knew I'd just double guess myself constantly, and my vote would be moving around on a whim. (that's why i appeared at deadline almost exactly).

It's actually the correct mafia play to appear certain that one person is mafia, so it doesn't look like you're hedging. I just don't think it was warranted that Eden was definitely mafia yesterday, at all.

marvellosity

United Kingdom36161 Posts

March 23 2015 15:21 GMT

#6410

the thing is, we kinda know our arguments are pointless when we start them, we just can't help ourselves.

whereas the argument about his role actually did have a point, because it was a major point of contention for the thread/town at the time

marvellosity

United Kingdom36161 Posts

March 23 2015 15:21 GMT

#6411

On March 24 2015 00:20 Palmar wrote:

Show nested quote +

I actually want to think that I'm smart enough as mafia to double wifom (IE I would have waffled on Eden as mafia). But maybe I'm not.

imo the right thing to do is to absolutely waffle, because like I said, I don't think being certain was in any way warranted.

I didn't afk until deadline because I was certain Eden was mafia, I'll tell you that for free.

marvellosity

United Kingdom36161 Posts

March 23 2015 15:24 GMT

#6414

On March 24 2015 00:24 Palmar wrote:

Show nested quote +

I think you think rayn is mafia and I think you have thought that since yesterday.

HOWEVER, I also think you know it's almost the incorrect play if we assume the information as presented for example by koshi to be true, to lynch him over me or even eden.

yup